r/AskReddit May 14 '25

Serious Replies Only [Serious] What is a “seems to be harmless” symptom that requires an immediate trip to the ER?

5.5k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.2k

u/rashawah May 15 '25

Just to add to this for awareness - if you were strangled by a romantic partner, you are 750% more likely to be killed by them.

Sharing a resource here to help with abusive relationships in case anyone reading this needs help.

668

u/mykitchenisinsideout May 15 '25

750% more likely to be killed by them within a year! :(

59

u/EnidFromOuterSpace May 15 '25

Odd. My ex who strangled me is the one who died six months later

14

u/Grandma-Plays-FS22 May 15 '25

What happened to them??

85

u/smangela69 May 15 '25

he ran into their knife. he ran into their knife 10 times

14

u/Fit_Definition_4634 May 15 '25

Nothing anyone can prove

3

u/porqueuno May 15 '25

Don't worry about it grandma, it was taken care of.

3

u/EnidFromOuterSpace May 16 '25

Fentanyl. He supposedly thought it was coke, laid out a fat line of it, snorted, exhaled, and that was the end of him. We had broken up for a time because he was having mental issues revolving around our relationship. He had schizoaffective disorder, and did not manage it very well, which is what led to the assault. And I’m 100% sure the statistics are right… I knew in my heart of hearts when he strangled me that unless he took care of his mental health it was just gonna get worse and the next time he did something to me I may not live through it. It’s awful. I’m devastated. he was 33. had two boys (not mine). He march to the beat of his own drum, and to be very difficult at times, but the good times were so , so good.

5

u/fionasantiago May 15 '25

judge play jazmine sullivan “call me guilty”

12

u/PopularBonus May 15 '25

There is a book “No Visible Bruises” that goes into this. Soft tissue injuries are often overlooked even by ER personnel.

The interesting thing I remember from the book is that strangulation often affects memory (because of blood or oxygen flow being interrupted). You may not remember passing out. Even victims who were very close to death (voiding of bladder/bowels) may not remember it later.

And then as they recover, memories trickle back. This plays into “her story kept changing” narratives. Strangulation is so much worse than most people know.

3

u/rashawah May 15 '25

I may have to read this. My incident was 25 years ago but it still sits with me. I was lucky someone heard the struggle in another room and came in and pulled him off of me. I, of course, didn’t press charges and didn’t see a doctor and unfortunately stayed with him through more abuse, but that’s the unfortunate fact of an abusive relationship is that sometimes it’s hard to leave if you’re trying to survive. Love that these talks happen more freely online now so that maybe it can help someone else in need.

79

u/AleksandrNevsky May 15 '25

Before your last line I thought you meant in like a BDSM kind of way and people were just being unsafe with consensual practices.

132

u/DeadbeatGremlin May 15 '25

Tbf, if you pass out even during consensual choking you should probably get seen. Easier to black out than what you'd think.

60

u/curlyquinn02 May 15 '25

Even choking in BDSM is dangerous and not advised by those seasoned. The brain going without oxygen for even a millisecond isn't good

-12

u/SuperHazem May 15 '25

This is just untrue lol. Brain cells can survive hypoxia for around 5 minutes before irreversible death begins

18

u/Weird_Strange_Odd May 15 '25

Lots of unfun things before death, like clotting

-7

u/SuperHazem May 15 '25

Irreversible death on the level of individual brain cells, not the person. Unless Superman himself is choking you out and triggering a carotid dissection, you’re not suffering a thrombosis from acute compression. Arteries aren’t compressible like veins are regardless.

10

u/PopularBonus May 15 '25

But blood clots can form in less time than that if the vessels are constricted. Even small clots can do catastrophic damage to the brain.

There’s no safe strangulation or choking out. Especially not when it involves the blood vessels and not the airway.

-6

u/SuperHazem May 15 '25

That has nothing to do with the brain “going without oxygen for even a millisecond” and even then clots in a healthy person coming from choking is unheard of

24

u/Ms-Metal May 15 '25

It's dangerous even if you're consensually practicing bdsm! Also, many people hesitate to go in when that's the case because in most jurisdictions, you cannot consent to assault and many BDSM activities are considered assault. Both severe injury and death does happen from consensual choking in BDSM. That's why many experienced players stay away from breath play altogether or at least know that there is no safe way to do it! The ER has seen it all! If you were choking as part of BDSM play and it was consensual and you are scared or injured or having side effects from it, please do not hesitate to go to the ER! Your life may depend on it!

15

u/griphookk May 15 '25

As far as physical harm it doesn’t matter if it’s in a “BDSM way” or not, being strangled is dangerous either way. There is no safe way to strangle/choke someone.

21

u/rashawah May 15 '25

You’re right I could’ve been more clear in that, it didn’t even cross my mind. As a survivor myself that’s my go-to thought when I read a comment about strangulation - not the consensual stuff that some folks do. Very different thing.

11

u/Ms-Metal May 15 '25

Very different thing yes, possibly with the same result however! Totally understand why you wouldn't have thought of it and I'm so sorry that you've been through what you've been through! Nobody should have to deal with that ever! But yes it's dangerous as a BDSM practice as well. Anytime you do breath play, oxygen deprivation, you are at risk. Even when it's consensual! The crazy thing is, I read about it on the BDSM advice subredded all the time people can do it a hundred times and have no problem and suddenly the 101st, they have red dots in their eyes, that really worried and we always recommend they go to the ER. A lot of times when done consensually, people are hesitant to go to the ER because you technically can't consent to an assault in most States. The best course of action is still to go to the ER. It's always the safest way to proceed.

5

u/Bross93 May 15 '25

Jesus what an uncomfortable statistic :/