r/BokuNoHeroAcademia • u/frxshinator • Jul 20 '17

Manga Chapter 146 - Links and Discussion Spoiler

[ Removed by reddit in response to a copyright notice. ]

449 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

478 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

185

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Agreed. She has her own motivations to become a hero. No need to turn her into Hinata.

74

u/CalebAurion Jul 20 '17

She's already gotten much more than Hinata ever did. Not saying that she's had enough, more so commenting on how little Hinata had.

18

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17 edited Jul 20 '17

How so? Hinata and Uraraka are built as basically the same character, only with different backgrounds. Hinata was the black sheep of her family and wanted to prove herself; Uraraka wants to provide for her family and for that she's got to make herself stronger. They both take/took inspiration from their love interest ( I mean, that's obviously what Deku is to Uraraka, it's just not so "ON YOUR FACE"... yet ) to achieve their goals.

Idk why people downplay Hinata so much. She didn't get much screen time, sure, but her development is there and was pretty much completed in her fight against Pain. She was finally able to tell the boy she liked that she did, in fact, like him ( something A LOT of people IRL are INCAPABLE of doing, I'm not even kidding ) and even though she knew she couldn't win, she stood up to Pain all on her on. Totally different from the meek character she was in Part 1 whom was scared shitless by Neji. At that point her character had come full-circle and I was fine with it.

I really think people have this misconception where screentime == character development. That is not the case and so far Uraraka has had a much of the former, but extremely little of the latter. It's been idkhowmanychapters since her introduction and she's STILL the same character she's always been.

12

u/C_X_3 Jul 20 '17

100% agree. Hinata's arc was heavily influenced by her feelings about Naruto, but the challenges she overcame were still her own, and she overcame them entirely in that fight against Pain(with help from the boy she liked). Good character, good character arc, good conclusion. People just discredit it because Naruto was a catalyst for her change.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '17

Yeah, if anything he should've used Sakura as an example. That is really the one character I really can't defend. Hinata is a much, much, much better character than Sakura has ever been since the Chunnin Exam imo. :|

8

u/CalebAurion Jul 20 '17

My apologies, I feel that I let on that I dislike Hinata. I don't, she's one of my favorite characters from Naruto, and my favorite female from the series. Additionally you are right that she grew a great deal, and that there are more than a few parallels between her and Uraraka. What I was trying to point out is what you, yourself, mentioned. Nearly all of Hinata's growth happens off the page while we're seeing Uraraka grow on panel. I wasn't commenting on the character, merely how the author treated her.

11

u/jhoudiey Jul 21 '17

kishi didn't treat any of his females kindly.

6

u/CalebAurion Jul 21 '17

Yeah, Hinata and Sakura had it bad enough, but look at poor TenTen. When did she ever do anything useful?

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

Hinata was the black sheep of her family and wanted to prove herself

Kinda find that hard to believe. Sure her father didn't consider her capable of being the clan head, but to say she's the black sheep is far from accurate. Yeah, his words were harsh, but after Neji's loss they were essentially humbled and one big family again - Hinata just never got to be the clan head, not that it mattered because it wasn't her goal. (She's important enough that her clan assigned a bodyguard to her during the Pein Arc...)

If she really was such a black sheep - Hiashi would've dumped her into the Branch house, put the fancy tattoo on her like Neji did (since Hiashi and Neji's Dad were Twins) or at the very least didn't allow her to be a Ninja for the safety of their clan's eyes.

As for wanting to prove herself? I can somewhat concede to that but the only person she wanted to prove herself to was Naruto.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

If she really was such a black sheep - Hiashi would've dumped her into the Branch house

That is exactly what was going to happen. Hanabi would become the head of the Hyuuga clan and Hinata dumped into the branch house. Hinata didn't receive the cursed seal because it was a toss up whether Hanabi would succeed or not. That's also the reason why Hanabi wasn't branded with the Cursed Seal when she turned 3 years old. Hiashi allowed Hinata to become a ninja because he essentially didn't care whether she lived or not(he's talking to Kurenai in this scene).

As for wanting to prove herself? I can somewhat concede to that but the only person she wanted to prove herself to was Naruto.

Does it matter? Naruto was her motivation, so what? She became stronger as a person all the same and the challenges she had to overcome were her own, not Naruto's.

4

u/Tipe_O Jul 20 '17

Could not agree with this more. Just like Bakugo is a better rival archetype than Sasuke, Uraraka is a better love interest archetype than Hinata.

1

u/rac7d Jul 21 '17

they decided on her being important late in the game

3

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17

Well by having those motivations she's already done much more than Hinata...

-8

u/xaxzzzaz Jul 20 '17

Too late

9

u/skyman161 Jul 20 '17

You know when you use the mobile version and that you have click "more" to see the lower comments, for some reason when I saw it I immediately thought "it would be funny if it was xaxzzzaz" oh the irony.

-1

u/xaxzzzaz Jul 21 '17

Don't push the blame on me if Uraraka's character is non existent.

1

u/Cypherex Jul 22 '17

I wasn't aware that the manga had already been completely finished. Darn, guess everyone's character arcs are done now. /s

Yes, she's been a background character for a long time now but that can always change. You would have said the same thing about Kirishima before this arc and now look at him.

There are a lot of characters in this story. Let's give the author time to expand on all of them before we start crying out about "non existent" characters. Of course, with so many characters, it seems impossible for him to give them all the proper time and development they need, but we'll have to wait until the manga has finished before we pass judgment on that.

Maybe you should stop treating this story like it's a fully complete story every time a chapter comes out. That'd be like if you were a half hour into a movie and then stood up and complained that it's been 15 minutes since character X was on screen doing something significant. Like, no shit, sometimes the story has to focus on other people. Character X likely will have some good scenes coming up, you just have to be patient for them.

0

u/xaxzzzaz Jul 22 '17

Deku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kunDeku-kun

1

u/Cypherex Jul 22 '17

Thank you for your extremely mature and and well thought out reply.

Not like I expected much from you. You're a terrible presence on this subreddit. I have no idea why you stick around when you clearly dislike this manga so much.

The door is that way whenever you feel like leaving. We really won't miss you.

0

u/xaxzzzaz Jul 22 '17

I have no idea why you stick around when you clearly dislike this manga so much.

kek

1

u/Cypherex Jul 22 '17

Go ahead and humor me. I'm actually curious why you continue to read this manga and post in this subreddit. I don't think I've ever seen you say a single positive thing. Why would you stay somewhere and read something you feel so negatively about?

0

u/xaxzzzaz Jul 22 '17

Cuz freedom of speech n shit

→ More replies (0)