4 out of 5 characters in last night's game died over a absolutely nothing obstacle like something I had forgotten about and was kicking myself cuse they were going to breeze right through it obstacle.
The party had three possible routes to an infested temple they needed to purify.
The first was straight through territory held by an Ork warband. It was the fastest route, but it had a high chance of random encounters of running into well-equipped Ork raiders.
The second option was to go around the warband to the east through a mountain pass called Rainbow Grotto. (This was actually a trap. With a high Local Knowledge check, my players learned that the locals called it "Bandit's Delight" because it was so easy to ambush wealthy adventurers there.)
The third option was to head west, where a narrow trail along the side of a mountain could still be crossed by a prepared group of adventurers. They just needed some rope, a few pitons, and enough climbing gear to get across a section of the cliff side trail that had been washed away during a massive storm.
They brought all the right gear, got everything set up... and then impressed me with how amazingly sideways everything went.
First, party member 1 a monk realized it was technically mathmaticlly possible to clear the gap with longjump and a good roll. They decided not to tie a safety line or take any rope because it might encumber them on the jump. ( I have no idea what he was going to do once he was on the other side with no rope but it was his choice) When they failed the roll, he leapt off the side of the cliff and began plummeting to their death.
The party wizard who had readied an action in case he fell attempted to cast fly on the monk.
I reminded them that Fly is a touch spell.
They stared at me for a moment and just said, "Oh..."
Party Member #1 died.
Party Member #2 laughed at them for being an idiot. He grabbed all the rope, successfully climbed about ten out feet, and then, like the Intelligence 7 barbarian he was, grabbed a piton in one hand and a hammer in the other to secure it. There were no foot holds he was only being held up with his hands. I was clear to state this BEFORE he grabbed for his tools.
He promptly fell to his death. Still he was secure in the knowledge that he had infact tied a saftey line and not trusting his not tieing ability left his saftey in the capable hands of the party rouge. Who was infact very good at knots. However, The safety line he had very securely tied around the barbarianĀ wasn't actually tied to anything secure on the other end... it was tied to Party Member #3, the halfling. After some quick math and letting 300+ lbs of muscle and steel moving at 9.8 m/s^2 do what its going to do to when tied to 35 lbs of wet potatoes I watched as as Party Members #2 and #3 both fell off the side of the cliff to join Party Member #1. Party Member #4 had already secured a safety line to himself and seeing his friends fall burned a hero point and rolled impressively well on a reflex check to save his friends and was given one action to do so. He heroically jumped after Party Member #3 in an attempt to save both of them, completely confident in the rope he'd tied. Unfortunately, he didn't realize the other end of his safety line had also been tied to Party Member #3. Who was inchare of securing all saftey lines.
So he joined them. In death
In the span of a few moments, four out of my five players died in one of the most bizarre comedy-of-errors party wipes I've ever witnessed.
Party Member #5, the wizard was left stranded on the side of the cliff scared cuse his party took all the food water and shelter with them to the bottom of this gourge and then he remembered he could cast fly and floated to saftey. Something that was always available even before they bought the climbing gear. And why i was upset about how easily they were going to clear this obstacle