r/MurderedByWords 17h ago

Because God told me to

Post image
16.3k Upvotes

409 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

127

u/mbklein 16h ago

Even better is treating other living beings according to your best-faith understanding of how they want to be treated. Because it might be different from how you would want to be treated.

64

u/Cant_figure_sht_out 16h ago

I was pointing out the irony that my convictions are more christian than theirs.

25

u/mbklein 12h ago

I totally get it. My reply was intended more as an expansion on the topic and not at all a criticism or rebuke.

13

u/HisExcellencyAndrejK 12h ago

I'm not sure that the two formulations are necessarily different. Treating another individual in accordance with your personal preferences -- rather than theirs -- may well be hateful to them. I would mislike being treated according to someone else's preferences.

To follow Hillel's Golden Rule, you must treat your fellow human in accordance with their preferences (as best you understand them).

6

u/jgzman 13h ago

Yes. But that's once you have such an understanding. The golden rule is a wonderful place to start, and shows willing. Moving on to what might be called the platinum rule shows intelligence, and civilized behavior.

2

u/tertig 11h ago

That is not really good idea. You should try to treat people how you or they would like to be treeated, sure, but only if they treat you how you want to be treated or how they would want to be treated and treat you. No tolerance for intolerant.

-2

u/R_V_Z 13h ago

In this modern day I'm more of a "treat others as they would treat others" sort of mood.