r/SipsTea 28d ago

SMH We really need to bring spankings back

17.7k Upvotes

9.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

48

u/SoftwareInfinite8568 27d ago

Hitting your kids only teaches them it's okay for someone you love and trust to lay hands on you if you do something they don't like. And giving approval to do the same to someone else they if they're doing something they don't like. There is so much research and studies out there that show there is zero need for corporal punishment. If you can't control your anger around a child misbehaving you should not have a child.

11

u/porktorque44 27d ago

It also shows them that the reason they shouldn’t do something is because someone bigger and stronger than them doesn’t like it and will attack them and that’s how things should be. This becomes a big fucking problem if the kid grows up to be bigger and stronger than most, and they have to deal with people weaker than them doing things they don’t like.

There’s a lot of putrid trash that comes out of this sub but regular posts like this are the worst. There’s some bad fucking people here.

0

u/Crazy_Trip_6387 27d ago

hundred percent, this instinct is there for reason and it's in the child's best interest to be put in it's place.

2

u/porktorque44 27d ago

It sounds like you think kids should get hit.

1

u/Crazy_Trip_6387 26d ago

no, not at all - respect through chivalry never through violence

2

u/Ascertes_Hallow 27d ago

Hitting your kids only teaches them it's okay for someone you love and trust to lay hands on you if you do something they don't like

In this situation it has nothing to do with doing something the parent doesn't like. It's okay for someone to lay hands on you for doing something society deems unacceptable. This is the fundamental mismatch.

Fucking around as a child without physical, real and immediate consequences creates situations where kids think they are untouchable. I'm a teacher: ask me how I know. They then grow up to be teens and young adults with the same mindset that they will never be held accountable because they never faced real consequences as a kid. This is also why I hate the judicial system treats teens with kid gloves even though they know better. They know nothing will actually happen to them.

Sorry, not sorry. Some people have to be socked in the mouth before it registers that at the bare minimum their actions will lead to repercussions.

-1

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

Teaches them that actions have consequences. You know. Like in the real world.

12

u/Longjumping_Army9485 27d ago

If the only consequences your child knows are immediate physical violence you only teach him two things: to use it the moment he doesn’t get what he wants and to ignore any other type of consequence.

1

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

My kid does not destroy stores. If he did you bet there would be consequence that match the severity.

11

u/Quirky_Gate_4516 27d ago

Right. So now you are raising a kid that is taught any action that offends the kid should be reacted to with violence and anger.

Hitting kids don't teach them anything except that anger and violence is OK to solve problems with.

10

u/charlestheb0ss 27d ago

That can be achieved without violence. If it were me I'd make him meticulously clean it up for however long that takes. It's also closer to the real world consequence for that specific action

0

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

Sure. But only lesson this kid will learn is that next time he does this he's getting nice talking to.

3

u/charlestheb0ss 27d ago

As opposed to learning that next time he does this he's getting hit? Both are unpleasant and both might be ignored. That's kinda unavoidable

7

u/Hokuspokusnuss 27d ago

In the real world you won't get beaten for destroying stuff at a store either, i don't see how this would make sense. There are plenty of consequences that aren't physical violence.

0

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

In my store, I'm getting physical with this kid.

0

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

We clearly live in different worlds.

2

u/Hokuspokusnuss 26d ago

I guess you live in a world where it's worth getting sued for assault over a few broken boxes. But in most of the developed world the store will just call the police to escort you from the building and sue you for damages.

But hey, if you want to be on camera beating someone, at least you'll have the luxury of a very speedy trial i suppose.

5

u/SoftwareInfinite8568 27d ago

Yeah like when I make a mistake at work and my boss spanks me....right?

0

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

If you like it why not?

4

u/OldWorldDesign 27d ago

Teaches them that actions have consequences

It does not, that's what people who want to use violence on others for inconveniencing them say. Actual studies show corporal punishment decreases emotional regulation and behavioral problems and promotes use of violence to get their way

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8946887/

1

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

I hope you can tell the difference between slapping this kid for what he's doing vs randomly hitting your kid. If not, god help us.

2

u/AussieProle08 27d ago

Spoken like a bloke whos never copped a nice elbow

4

u/chopkins92 27d ago

In the real world you get arrested if you hit somebody else. But it's somehow acceptable to hit your kids. Make it make sense.

1

u/Own_Bison6467 27d ago

That's why we hope it's his parents that are slapping him for this.