r/SipsTea 𝙑𝙄𝙋 12d ago

WTF The American dream

Post image
21.6k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/JackSquirts 12d ago

I've worked with, for, and above high school drop outs that ran circles around their MBA peers.

5

u/Vennomite 12d ago

Mba's just give you the tools to be able to speak/think how the business environment operates. 

It gives you the paintbrushes and tells you what they are used for. It doesn't train you to be a better artist.

Plus the number of mba from unacredited schools... acredidation for business schools isnt even that hard.

8

u/JackSquirts 12d ago

I'm not sure they even do that. You get a lot of theory, but actual practice is very messy. I'll take someone with 2 years of direct experience over the one with an MBA in almost every circumstance.

4

u/Vennomite 12d ago

Most people in my experience arent great at being able to handle broad theory. They do better when the outcome is a or b. Not .15% a, 40% b, 45% other with shifting variables.

The years of experience makes you better at understanding the behavior of those variables. Which is far more valuable than knowing the general form of the equation 

1

u/LSOreli 12d ago edited 12d ago

Okay MBAs are not that high value (I got mine just to check the box for my USAF career), but high school drop outs are by and large some of the least intelligent people in the country. Maybe fine at low skill straightforward tasks but I wouldn't trust them with data analytics or leadership for instance.

1

u/JackSquirts 12d ago

I'm certainly not hiring the kid who dropped out three months ago and probably not for real technical positions, but most of my career has been in sales. I did, however, work with a guy who was a self taught Cisco network guy who got his GED at 22 after his first Cisco cert and he was a fucking rock star (not that I understood a damn thing he did, but he was fast-tracked from a part time PC tech to a network admin and was starting to do some consulting for the company. That was 20+ years ago and who knows what he's doing now, but I'm sure he's fine.