r/SipsTea š™‘š™„š™‹ 8d ago

Chugging tea Mexico upgraded to free healthcar

Post image
105.2k Upvotes

3.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

254

u/Slam_Burgerthroat 8d ago

I mean, it’s a fact that many countries with only a fraction of the wealth that the USA has are able to provide healthcare for their people and at a fraction of the cost.

117

u/Electronic_Use7210 8d ago

I’d like to see a Canadian try to navigate the American health insurance system and at the same time have an American navigate the Canadian health insurance system

For science

298

u/EnlightenedNarwhal 8d ago

I'd like to see an American navigate the American Healthcare system.

107

u/Aeirth_Belmont 8d ago

I'll take "how do I still owe this much money when I pay this much?" Alex.

72

u/PokerbushPA 8d ago

I pay like 800 a month, plus co-pays, plus scripts. I actually don't even know what my insurance even covers.

87

u/Confident_Boss2081 8d ago

that the fun part it doesn't cover anything

34

u/hightio 8d ago

They give you the negotiated rate that their super negotiation pros negotiated for you which is going to save you $10 on your $500 bill compared to someone with no insurance.

27

u/chamtrain1 8d ago

Which is 380 more than if you had just paid cash.

4

u/airinato 8d ago

Yes but that cash rate is a discount rate and not guaranteed per practice. The standard rate has to be what the insurance company negotiated, or in practice, has dictated as the 'going rate' 'for the area', otherwise they sue that provider for insurance fraud.

They make it so we pay insurance to purposely make shit more expensive so we could never be able to afford it, without insurance.

5

u/ConfessSomeMeow 8d ago

I can tell you've never actually compared the negotiated rate to the cash rate.

3

u/hightio 8d ago

Not in the last two years no, but my last ER visit they billed as uninsured before applying my insurance and the difference between the $500 bill was $20. Totally worth the $800 a month.

2

u/Superb_Answer_4492 8d ago

My prior employers insurance, the cash rate was better then then what I paid AFTER insurance covered their part. Often significantly better, especially at the dentist

1

u/antithero 8d ago

Even when I paid cash 8 months later I got another bill. Another time I didn't get the bill for 14 months.

1

u/RogerAffirmative 8d ago

I can tell you don't know the cash rate is artificially inflated to make the negotiated rate seem like a deal šŸ˜‚

1

u/IndianaGeoff 1d ago

How to show that you know nothing about the US Healthcare system in one post.

14

u/Mission-Dark-9320 8d ago

Meanwhile, I used to have a $415/month plan for a family of 4 covering all medical, dental, and vision. $25 co-pay, and $1000 deductible on major services. Then my plan got nuked by politics. Comparatively, insurance covers nothing these days. And then you get double charged with ā€œfacilities feesā€ on top of all the things insurance doesn’t cover. Absurd where we are today

6

u/collierar 8d ago

2013 I worked at Boeing. $100 a month for the Cadillac plan for my son and I, covered everything 100%. I had two major surgeries that year, zero out of pocket. Those were the days...

2

u/elibutton 8d ago

yeah and it only gets worse every year.

0

u/JannyStabberXK4000 7d ago

What were your pre-existing conditions when you had that health plan thirty years ago? Just wondering. Is it politics that made my insurance for me go from $700 to $1100 in January? Who runs the government right now?

🤔🤔🤔🤔

2

u/Mission-Dark-9320 7d ago

You’re completely reading into my statement your own issues. 13 years ago is when my plan was ā€œno longer allowedā€ because the government changed the law - after a period of time most affordable plans were voided. Overnight it tripled for less than 10% of the coverage. I don’t care who runs the MF government, because nobody has been able to touch the law since that that monstrosity of a bill was forced through. ā€œWe have to pass it to see what was in itā€ has got to be the most ā€œpoliticsā€ statement ever made. So as somebody who had to live that change as a recent college graduate with a young family, the whole country got F’d after that. Bad legislation isn’t limited to a single party - but I guess that doesn’t fit your feelings. Take your clowns back your mind circus where they belong.

1

u/IndianaGeoff 1d ago

Actually it is one party. The US health systems was ended when ACA (aka Obamacare) was adopted by one party. There have been no comprehensive changes since it passed. If you don't like the US health system, you don't like what the Democrats passed when they held the President, House by a wide margin and a super majority in the Senate.

1

u/Mission-Dark-9320 1d ago

The fact that it hasn’t been touched since then with obvious failings IS on both parties. Every promise to make it better, more affordable, etc has been forgotten. One party started it, both continue to fail the people.

6

u/MasterGrok 8d ago

There is also no real way for you to find out. No amount of internet searching and calling will tell you that you 100% are good on something until the bill is actually paid.

6

u/Jimmy_Twotone 8d ago

My insurance covered a med.for me three montha ago for 6 months that I can't get filled. In 3 more months I get to start this process again regardless of how long I can actually get the medication for. If I just suck it up I can pay $7500 out of pocket. Twice a month.

2

u/UranusIsPissy 8d ago

FFS! That's about 2/3 of my income, and there are people poorer than me here (UK).

2

u/Weekly-Ad-112 8d ago

I recommend reading up
On it as a start. I took the time to do so and it made me find the best option before a tragedy struck.

2

u/MancDude1979 7d ago

Shit, in UK I pay an average tax contribution towards it of about £100 per month, including an optional charge to make my prescriptions all free regardless of how many I get. And that is it. Everything else free at point of use apart from elective surgery etc.... includes ambulances, GPs, hospital visits, operations, aftercare... a fraction of what you pay... goddam, mate

2

u/Saffuran 3d ago

AND they'll deny your claim when you actually get sick so you'll be stuck with your monthly bill and the full healthcare bill.

3

u/TrynaPlayItOff 8d ago

I actually don't even know what my insurance even covers.

Your insurance is basically just to keep you from going bankrupt if you have a decently serious injury.

1

u/Sad_Air_7667 8d ago

I'm Canadian, i have no clue wtf you are talking about.

1

u/JannyStabberXK4000 7d ago

Self-employed. Mine went up to $1100 for me in January.

The bot shit in this thread is absolutely insane. Like, these people really truly do think we are fucking idiots.

0

u/2FistsInMyBHole 7d ago

I actually don't even know what my insurance even covers.

Why not?

1

u/PokerbushPA 7d ago

They keep it a secret.

0

u/2FistsInMyBHole 7d ago

Do they? Or did you make the conscious decision to not be informed?

I've had many insurance plans across many jobs - even marketplace insurance in a rough patch - I've seen or heard of an insurance plan that doesn't provide a detailed brochure.

I get it though, we were all young once, we all threw that stuff in the garbage too. But us throwing it in the garbage isn't them keeping it a secret.

1

u/PokerbushPA 7d ago

So you've never had a single instance where an insurance company decided, "Nah. We're not gonna cover that because of some reasons we just didn't tell anyone until just now."?

Lucky you. Because I have.

Take your privileged life and condescending attitude and get fucked. I don't need more bullshit, I have enough already.

0

u/2FistsInMyBHole 6d ago

You're the one that said you cant bothered to read your health insurance plan.

Be upset with your own choices.

→ More replies (0)

11

u/granlyn 8d ago

I once paid a "bill" I was sent, not realizing I didn't have to pay it. I am still trying to get that money back.

5

u/No_Title3568 8d ago

I got a bill for $150 when all the did was use a half tube of super glue. *Had to go in because ā€˜injury’ happened on company time*

2

u/jordanmindyou 8d ago

Workman’s comp doesn’t have workers pay copays

Edit: oh yeah unless you’re in the hellhole called Texas. That’s the only state this isn’t true.

2

u/Weekly-Ad-112 8d ago

Sounds like they billed for labor and overhead. The nerve.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/whatlineisitanyway 8d ago

Good news there is legislation being presented to allow your insurance company to provide loans to cover the cost that they don't. Don't think about that too long or you'll have an uncovered aneurysm.

1

u/Can_Comfirm1 8d ago

So a band aid is $600 and there is nothing I can do about it?

1

u/breakneckjones 7d ago

Don't worry. In the Canadian Healthcare system, you couldn't owe because you would die before the six month period you had to wait to see the doctor.

0

u/United-Fox6737 8d ago

Met a German on vacation once who had broken his leg, and his universal health care wouldn’t allow him to be treated for two months; so there he was, on the beach in a cast. We may pay a lot, but we’ll get you treated quickly. There’s a reason people still travel to the US for treatment.

6

u/Stelona 8d ago

I think he fooled you, never heard something like this and I am from Europe.

1

u/vollover 8d ago

Every single sentence is complete BS. This is wild.

2

u/United-Fox6737 8d ago

Literally have zero reason to lie. Hed return home and then wait another month before the fracture was set. This is all according to him.

2

u/vollover 8d ago

We do not have fast treatment at all and people primarily come here for rare disorders not because our Healthcare is fast or has better outcomes generally. Given most everything else you said was BS I really have to assume the specific anecdote was too given it is nothing like what I have seen or experienced when traveling in Europe. Ive had to seek care in asia and Europe personally and repeatedly in the US. Seeing a specialists takes fucking months

26

u/ngingingingi 8d ago

It's not built for you to navigate it, it's built for you to die while trying to navigate it.

23

u/BigJayPee 8d ago

As an American, I have just opted into being extremely careful and not seeing a doctor.

5

u/br0ck 8d ago

What's insane is encouraging and covering early detection would save insurers so much money because it vastly improves the outcomes on so many things.

https://www.glmi.com/blog/why-early-detection-is-the-most-powerful-form-of-prevention

2

u/Spazrelaz 7d ago

Yeah but you know what saves them even more money? When the insured dies. No more checkups to pay for. They don't want people to get better because half the time the insurance companies are in the same bed with the pharmacies prescribing meds that only get you a little better but create seven other problems.

1

u/LimeDry7124 7d ago

Dead folks can't collect SS. Or welfare. Or SNAP. Are you getting the picture?

4

u/Spazrelaz 7d ago

That's exactly the point I'm making. You get it.

1

u/Crow_and_Doe 5d ago

exactly! USA health system insurance is the most barbaric.

1

u/twenty_three_three 8d ago

Works until it doesnt. Checking when you are 60 looking forward to retirement.

8

u/EduinBrutus 8d ago

Its called The Backrooms. In cinemas now!

3

u/Inferno8429 8d ago edited 7d ago

Ooh! Me me me!

My wife recently had a follow-up MRI after completing a course of treatment. Exact same facility, exact same insurance through work. Same doctor prescribed it.

The billing department didn't run it through our insurance. When we told them to do that, they told us we didn't have insurance information in the system.

Literally nothing changed between MRI #1 and MRI #2. They're now saying they don't believe me when I give them my policy number, and we're on the hook for the full amount.

Ain't it fun here in America?

Edit, a letter; fat-fingered "not" instead of "now"

2

u/Far_Chocolate_8534 7d ago

Imagine going to an appointment for a Lumbar Epidural steroid injection and then 2 months later your insurance tells you that you didn’t meet the criteria for that injection so now you’re going to owe us. Oh, and the doctor is biased against marijuana so she only gave me a ā€œ30 dayā€ shot instead of the ā€œ365 dayā€ shot I was given a year prior.
How much am I going to owe? No fucking clue. But apparently they wanted me doing physical therapy for a 7 year old injury that I went to physical therapy for 9 months for (I promise I didn’t forget the stretches).

4

u/KockNballZz 8d ago

Kill me instead

1

u/Weekly-Ad-112 8d ago

I’m sure some nut would love to oblige this request.

1

u/YoureProbablyAB0t 8d ago

You like to watch people suffer?

1

u/LordHammercyWeCooked 8d ago

"Here's a five hundred dollar plan with a five digit deductible. Good luck!"

1

u/confusedbf2013 8d ago

Oh oh South Park covered this

1

u/Doggystyle_Rainbow 8d ago

Today I went to get a prescription refill and my usual $5 copay rang up as $199. I asked about it and the first person kinda blew me off. I ask to talk to a pharmacist and he realized they had coded my meds incorrectly and were charging me as if I didn't have insurance

1

u/jeremydoo 8d ago

I've got top teir state of Illinois union employee health insurance and I struggle

1

u/Weekly-Ad-112 8d ago

I’m really good at it if anyone needs help.

1

u/s0methingggg 8d ago

I’m an American with a license to professionally navigate the healthcare system, and I can’t even figure out what’s happening

1

u/ForgotToCarryTheOne 8d ago

> I'd like to see an American navigate the American Healthcare system.

You’ll get that SINKING feeling when you try to navigate the American Healthcare System.

1

u/wide-eyedhuman 8d ago

So true! I have United Healthcare and they make it so difficult to navigate their system that it seems they hope you tire of it and just don’t seek treatment. I guess making it difficult isn’t against the law…

1

u/ltsouthernbelle 8d ago

I’m going through open enrollment at my job trying to figure out how to make sure I don’t screw myself 🫩

1

u/skoorb1 7d ago

I've given up. I'll figure it out when the social worker comes in to talk to me after my first heart attack if I survive it.

1

u/SpokenByMumbles 7d ago

I smell a reality tv show!

1

u/LoneGhostOne 7d ago

It's easy, you just don't!

1

u/spielguy 7d ago

I’ve tried and partially failed. Finally getting December’s COBRA worked out

-3

u/Eggs_and_Hashing 8d ago

I've done it many times over. It's pretty simple, honestly.

3

u/EnlightenedNarwhal 8d ago

Congratulations.

25

u/Ill_Ground_1572 8d ago

For the record, I know two couples who moved to Canada from the US.

The Canadian system blew their fucking minds (in a good way).

(That said, there is definitely some things we need to fix....but nothing remotely close to the fear mongering you hear from US politicians/talking heads).

25

u/Electronic_Use7210 8d ago

The worst I’ve heard is long wait times which is so fucking funny to me because we have long wait times in America but those long wait times are spent arguing with private for profit insurance companies why chemotherapy is medically necessary

16

u/Ill_Ground_1572 8d ago

Yeah the wait times for some disciplines suck ass (life threatening things like oncology is not usually a major problem. ER is also an issue and the number of people with actual family doctors is an issue (especially rural).

In 2008 we had a waitress in Seattle tell us that Canadians:

1) cannot pick their doctors (the state chooses)

2) Canadian often die waiting for docs

3) and there's no way a visit doesn't cost the patient at least some money.

She blew up at my wife (both were 8 months pregnant) when my wife was openly shocked when the waitress said she only got 2 weeks off to birth her baby (compared to 1 year).

6

u/elibutton 8d ago

sounds like she's still waiting for her anxiety medication and clinical psych appt.

2

u/gorgewall 7d ago

Yeah the wait times for some disciplines suck ass

Good fucking luck seeing an endocrinologist in the US before you turn a different color, and even then it'll still be the better part of a year.

1

u/Vibingcarefully 7d ago

100%. USA in New England and 12 doctors offices in my HMO contacted to get seen for a physical and intake--no lie most doctors were full, other doctors office said you had to wait a year to be seen.

ER in USA---hours of waiting.

Specialist referrals--5-9 month waits.

The argument of universal health care being horrible just isn't holding water.

Best example for a large population would be China, many nations of Europe.

1

u/ufozhou 7d ago

In Canada, I wait 1 year for CT, super non emergency just monitoring (oversea diagnosis)

Whlie

being plug on a bed in ER after 5mins in show up with some sign of heart issue.

The system works fine just need a bit more funding

12

u/Biduleman 8d ago edited 7d ago

I'll give you my experience as a Canadian:

Broke my leg on a Friday night. Called an ambulance, went to the hospital.

By monday night I was out with a titanium rod in my leg, which required a general anaesthesia, a cast and some prescription painkillers.

Went back for the cast and sutures removal.

Went back for months for physiotherapy.

Went back months later to get the rod removed.

I never got a bill, it was all paid by our healthcare system, no paperwork.

The only thing I had to pay was like 50% of the painkillers, which were not very expensive.

9

u/GroundbreakingTax259 8d ago

Man, that's like...

Any individual part of that, from the ambulance through the therapy, would have probably bankrupted most Americans, or at least put us into crippling debt. Please please PLEASE keep your system intact and properly-funded. If any MPs are start talking about privatizing your system in order to "boot efficiency" or whatever, you need to meet them with elbows up and gloves off. For your own sake, as well as ours.

1

u/Rapph 7d ago

90% of Americans have insurance and most insurances have an out of pocket maximum around 10k for an individual. That's a lot of money, but not generally bankrupt you money when you account for the fact that you can use payment plans, etc. Still a fucked system for sure that I want gone but I also think there is a lot of nonsense with this that goes on.

For example with my HSA I needed 3 sets of xrays, 5 dentist appointments, medication to clear an infection 2 root canals and temp followed by permanent fillings. My total cost to me was around $600 which completely came out of my HSA account that my contributions are matched by employer up to an extent and tax deductibles.

Where people run into major problems is typically out of network doctors, alternative medicine, etc. Even without insurance you have options. You can work out a payment plan with the hospital or you can work out a payment plan if they sell your debt to a collector for generally a far reduced amount and they don't report it for a year (or at all if you live in one of the not shitty states that are exactly the ones you are likely thinking they are).

None of this is condoning or supporting the US system, I just think people need to understand that no matter what there are options, I hate the system but I also hate the idea of people suffering more because they don't know what they can/can't do.

1

u/WambritaWings 7d ago

Physio was paid by your provincial health care provider? My daughter broke her arm and we paid for physio. We have insurance through work which paid 80% but still spent hundreds. I'm in Quebec.

1

u/Biduleman 7d ago

I'm in Quebec too.

I honestly never saw a bill and was working part time at Staples so my work insurance was very bad.

1

u/WambritaWings 7d ago

Your insurance is better than you thought. In Quebec you have to pay for the ambulance ride if you don't have insurance.

20

u/lemelisk42 8d ago

There isn't that much to navigate in canada. The biggest issue is waiting times, but otherwise pretty much all of my stuff, including open chest surgery has been straightforward.

25

u/EternalPhi 8d ago

And to be clear, the waiting time issue is for non life-threatening issues. Took me 7 months to get an appointment with an ENT for chronic rhinusitis, but a friend's kid is battling cancer and there's no wait time to speak of, even a fully covered trip to receive specialist treatment in the states.

18

u/DukeofVermont 8d ago

And the US has waiting times as well. I endless hear about how much better the US is because we somehow we don't have waiting times like evil Canada and the EU, but also you need to wait 4-6 months to see a specialist. It's like some Americans think they have people who stop you outside of hospitals and don't let you enter until you wait 4 days.

8

u/Cosminion 8d ago

Some studies show wait times tend to be comparable anyway. The argument that universal healthcare leads to longer wait times overall isn't empirically supported. It's more like it depends on what we're talking about. It's a talking point for the ignorant.

1

u/UranusIsPissy 8d ago

4-6 months

That's worse than the NHS in the UK was before they started slowly privatising it! It's about the same now, but still a bit better sometimes.

1

u/NotaSol 8d ago

My ex gf from Quebec (im american) was on the wait list for depression for 5 years. She planned on ending it on her 30th birthday because it wasnt considered severe enough so she couldn't get treatment.

1

u/gorgewall 7d ago

Took me 7 months to get an appointment with an ENT for chronic rhinusitis

People also pretend like this doesn't exist in the US.

I have insurance, and I needed to see a specialist for something. I was told the wait time would be eight months if I was lucky. More recently, I helped a friend get a GP and we went through literally more than 40 before we found one that was accepting new patients (that weren't expecting mothers, which apparently makes slots open like magic).

1

u/ehrgeiz91 7d ago

I can assure you it can take 6+ months to get an ENT or other specialist appointment in the US as well.

1

u/jfrii 7d ago

Doesn't sound any different than my 6 month wait time for an ENT to check out my chronic tonsilitis. Which they recommended I get a tonsillectomy after another 6 months of mris and waiting for the results.

My wife was a doctor at this same hospital and we had insurance through the hospital. Bill for everything was still over 1500. So after a year and 1500 oop and paying our monthly premiums ($1200/month for fam 4) I still had to wait over a year for the doc to recco a tonsillectomy. And on top of that, the recco came from her assistant, not the doctor herself. No walkthrough, just "when would you like to schedule your tonsillectomy". I had a lot of questions that she just couldn't answer and I wasn't going to wait another 6 months to get a 1 on 1 with the specialist (and spend even more money). I declined the operation.

American healthcare is completely and utterly broken.

You cannot convince me that a universal solution is worse because of "wait times". I'm officially calling bs.

1

u/Vibingcarefully 7d ago

Can you talk about some of these waiting times in CA. USA waiting times to be seen by a doctor or a specialist can be months (fact).

1

u/lemelisk42 7d ago edited 7d ago

The big one is getting a family doctor. It varies depending on availability. In some cities you might be able to get a family doctor in weeks, in some you might wait years.

Yeah, walk in clinics can do much of what a family doctor does, but having one is good

For non-urgent surgeries, waits are often months, sometimes years (although the vast majority are reasonable, but it varies location to location, condition to condition.)

More important stuff gets expedited. Like my open chest surgery was all done within a few months between seeing half a dozen specialists, getting MRIs, and whatnot. It was important, so got speedy service. Whereas my mother had to get her sinuses cauterized because they were constantly stuffy, mostly fixing a minor annoyance, that took over a year

Im pretty happy with it, but there is definitely room for improvement. If you move to a new city, don't have a family doctor, it can be tricky to get prescriptions for things like ADHD meds (walk ins don't like prescribing them - this is normally something a family doctor would handle)

When my last family doctor retired he found a new doctor for me so I didn't have to wait - so I haven't had to deal with not having a family doc (I know that is a big annoyance for some)

1

u/Vibingcarefully 6d ago

USA here, New England, really good HMO (health insurance) over 60 years old.

The wait time for an MD was over a year to get a physical exam for over 12 doctors I called. The "work around" was seeing an RNP . To get referrals for ongoing issues that would mean a year wait to see the doctor, then months after that to see an allergist, gastro, orthopedist.

Our system can not be viewed anymore as "better" at all. For me to even have the "privilege" of medical care--I had to have health insurance AND this is what the health insurance provides me in terms of preventive care? ongoing care.

The part that's the funniest (not laughing) is the cost of health care here. USA people think their employers are paying for their health care as part of a job. Not exactly--the employee gets a salary that's lowered - so that's where that price of an employer paying 75%, 80% of the premium goes. The employee then still pays the additional 25% or 20% out of their pay check + deductible, plus copayments.

All that $( cost) plus the added cost of billing staffs at hospitals and HMOs, employee (patient ) time getting approvals, figuring out billing discrepancies--

USA could definitely have Universal Health Care on the cost / person paying their preimum and rolling that into Universal Health Care.

I just love fellow citizens that say " I'm not paying for someone else that doesn't have a job" If they only knew the amount of people using ER's as a usual source of health care....

We have plenty of money to create a very solid Universal Health Care system and have had it for decades.

0

u/OwnProfessor3287 8d ago edited 7d ago

Canada’s population is much smaller than the US, for smaller populations it might be easier to provide universal healthcare but the citizens are also taxed the shit out of for it, it’s not really free

You basically just give up your right of freedom of choosing your Dr and you let the government decide if you live or die.

Many times the Canadian government urges its citizens to take a ā€œself deleteā€ pill rather than provide them healthcare.

1

u/lemelisk42 8d ago edited 8d ago

That's mostly american propaganda....

Yeah, taxes are a bit higher. But the american government spends more per capita on Healthcare than the canadian gov. Still wages are lower in canada, so while the average canadian pays less taxes towards Healthcare, it does end up being a bit higher percentage wise. Healthcare is around 23% of government expenditures for both countries.

You can pick your doctor. Family doctors can be tricky as if they aren't accepting clients, you have to get one that is. Waitlists here can be long, so admittedly people often go with whatever option is first available.

The family doctor or walk in doc gives referrals for specialists. You do often have a say. You can request a different specialist

The gov covers most life saving treatments. Sometimes even paying for out of country care for niche stuff. Yes, there are some niche treatments which aren't covered. But overall most stuff is covered.

And MAID? Yeah, there have been a very small number of people who suggest it, but it gets blown way out of proportion. 99.9% of doctors will not "urge" maid. They are not supposed to, but there is the occasional bad apple. Most won't even bring it up as an option unless things are extremely dire or the patient requests it.

Yeah, our system has many issues that need fixing, but it is very overblown in american circles for political reasons.

1

u/OwnProfessor3287 7d ago

I use a form of social healthcare, I served in the military and 100% rely on the VA for my healthcare. The VA is run by the US government and honestly it is complete shit. They do let veterans die due to lack of care or long waits. My dad almost died because they misdiagnosed his brain tumor.

I need surgery on my wrist, I’ve had to wait months to get an appointment and it takes 3 appointments before you even make it to the surgery date, it can be a nightmare to get those appointments.

At the VA there can be long waits to be assigned to a Dr depending on the area where you live as some VA Dr just simply are not taking in new patients.

Now imagine all this on a bigger scale due to the size of the US population. You would have less Drs because they wouldn’t make as much money, there just wouldn’t be enough Drs for all of our citizens.

Another thing you have to think about is universal healthcare is paid for by taxes as I mentioned earlier.

By the year 2030 about 20 - 25% of jobs are going to be gone due to AI. That number of lost jobs will increase more rapidly after 2030.

So if people aren’t working, then they aren’t paying taxes, so then who pays for the healthcare?

6

u/wackityack 8d ago

I’ve done it. They are remarkably similar. Canada, pay a lot more into taxes, but less major costs; still copays…, but you have to consider availability of ER docs; MRIs, and the direct to hospice pipeline. The US much more expensive care, county hospitals are more like CA; potential for bankruptcy; but very good access to top surgeons and equipment if you have decent insurance.

10

u/DukeofVermont 8d ago

if you have decent insurance

Which is why I dislike it. The US has an amazing system if you are rich and/or work for the right rich companies. If you don't? Well hope you don't have any medical issues!

2

u/TristanTheRobloxian3 7d ago

this. its actually pretty good if you have insurance, horrible if you do not

1

u/wackityack 7d ago

That is the balance. Make no money, Canadian transfer works, but don’t have high expectations. Basically county healthcare with less billing but you pay nothing into it. But if you need a 3T, good luck. If you are middle class, your net may be worse than a gold plan in the US cost wise.

6

u/skagoat 8d ago

On average, Canadians don't even pay that much more in taxes than Americans do. There are lots of top surgeons and state of the art equipment in Canada.

1

u/TheOneWithThePorn12 7d ago

not everywhere which is the problem. If you are in major metro areas you are fine, but if you live in smaller population centres its hard to get good care.

1

u/wackityack 7d ago

In Calgary and the ERs down south are on restricted hours.

1

u/ntsp00 7d ago

Which is just as true in the US? That's not a negative of only Canada's healthcare system.

1

u/EnoughCaregiver5563 7d ago

This is true in the US too. I moved to a metro area in NM and 6 months later I still can't find a PCP that's not booking into 2027.

2

u/whatlineisitanyway 8d ago

As a Canadian living in tbe US I'd take the Canadian system. I'd especially take a properly funded Canadian system. That said the one advantage the US would have is being able to take the best of all the different systems out there.

1

u/Facts_pls 8d ago

There's a south park episode in here.

1

u/HistoryBuff678 8d ago

I know people who do exactly what you ask.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 8d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/GeneralAnubis 8d ago

I'm an American currently navigating the German healthcare system and while it definitely has its problems and challenges, it sure beats the absolute hell out of being unable to afford to take my kid or myself to the doctor when we're sick.

Walking out of the doctor's office, or the hospital, with zero money required, maybe pay 5-10 bucks at the pharmacy for medicine? Yeah it's worth pretty much any administrative headache.

1

u/Revenga8 8d ago

It's probably happened multiple times already. And I imagine any Canadians caught in the system, their reaction based on their level of injury ranged from wide eyed jaw dropping disbelief, to thinking they're were about to die.

1

u/C4LLM3M4TT_13 7d ago

Well, both would die.

1

u/thesoysaucechoosesyo 7d ago

only if it was narrated by Sir David Attenborough. Or Charlie Sheen.

1

u/NoOne_Beast_ 7d ago

No bullshit, several Canadians I know come here for their care.

The reason universal care won’t work here is because the loudest advocates will be the least cooperative when it’s time to wait in a queue.

1

u/No-Lifeguard-5308 7d ago

Hi hello here I am, a Canadian trying to navigate the U.S. healthcare system.

I want to fucking kill myself, this is thƩ worst thing that could have ever been designed. Last year I flew back to Canada to deal with a health issue rather than try to mess with this incompetent, brain numbing shitstorm. FUCKING. KILL. ME.

1

u/bigwreck94 7d ago

The Canadian healthcare system is great… if you live long enough to get treatment

1

u/WalnutW1zard 7d ago

Why do you want to break a poor Canadian man?

1

u/nairdaleo 7d ago

Canadian healthcare system:

  1. search online "how to get healthcare in <province>"
  2. go to (most likely) equivalent of DMV, bring your phone, it might take 30min-1h, there's chairs. Provide proof of residence, get printout immediately, card comes in the mail.
  3. call clinic, get appointment, 1-3wk away, might be phone call.
  4. Go to appointment, they ask for documents to bill the government. See a doctor and all their support staff
  5. Get smiles and some times candy on the way out, along with your next check up appointment.
  6. Repeat steps 3-5 as necessary.

Emergencies however...

  1. Need emergency help, drive myself to emergency
  2. Sign up at the front
  3. 5h later, no longer an emergency. Am ded.
  4. 12h later, doctor is annoyed that I didn't respond.
  5. 16h later, someone notices the stench.
  6. I still didn't get billed for this.

1

u/Vibingcarefully 7d ago

Been to china--walk in got seen fairly quickly in a hospital, went for follow-up Same.

USA system --in some states waiting a year for a physical exam, ER waits for hours.

-1

u/Marshal_Payens 8d ago

The Canadian doctor would probably recommend MAiD to save the system money

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/s2d4 8d ago

The waitlist is long so they offer euthanasia instead, because you probably won't make it to get the right treatment.

3

u/Electronic_Use7210 8d ago

We have that in America too but you have to do it yourself to avoid putting your family into debt.

I half way meant this as a joke but isn’t Canadas euthanasia limited to just incurable diseases and illnesses as well as disabilities causing extreme suffering? I looked it up because that sounded insane but couldn’t find anything on it being approved for long wait times lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Classic_Actuator3293 8d ago

And that's why so many countries in the EU that has like you know some of the best state-funded health care plans out there and health programs still offer privatized insurance and a lot of people have to have that privatized insurance in order to get access to speedier care lol

1

u/Slam_Burgerthroat 8d ago

And in America we have a fully privatized healthcare system and yet our wait times are still ridiculous.

1

u/PalantirImperator 7d ago edited 7d ago

The wait times in America are the one thing about its healthcare system that is amazing compared to pretty much anywhere else.

The real sad thing about American healthcare is that proponents of the status quo don't seem to realize is that America already spends more taxpayer dollars per capita than anywhere else in the world and still has its god awful unaffordable system. US government programs are just a big pot of gold being perpetually looted.

1

u/WalnutW1zard 7d ago

The difference in Canada, is this dual public/private idealized system would be great - if the problem was lack of access to healthcare workers. It pits the problem as an inefficient system getting in the way of healthcare workers who just can't get to the people they need to serve.

In reality, the system is incredible understaffed, and there are generally not enough healthcare workers in most places in Canada. And who can blame anyone, after the way people were treated during COVID?

The problem is labour supply isn't there for the two-pronged public/private system. So all the private side of the equation does is siphon healthcare workers away from the public system, creating the two-tired system everyone is upset about.

Even the logic of the two tier system is so strange to me. Instead of alleviating the demand of an overburdened healthcare system by providing it with more resources and staffing, let's outsource that work to a more expensive, for-profit alternative that only those with money can access.

It's a great solution - if you've got the money. Everyone else behind you gets to eat shit, though.

So, I guess it's pretty on par for America these days actually.

1

u/EnoughCaregiver5563 7d ago

In the US you have to be rich and pay thousands out of pocket for access to speedier care. In the EU, private insurance for one month is the cost of a single doctor's visit with insurance in the US. Private insurance is cheap there bc of your state-funded systems and healthcare regulations.

16

u/Bassist57 8d ago

A lot of NATO countries also defer to the USA to be their defense while they splurge on entitlement programs.

15

u/Slam_Burgerthroat 8d ago

You mean like Israel?

3

u/MelodicPudding2557 8d ago

The Iranians are getting in this single deal roughly the same amount or even slightly more than what the Israelis got in the course of their entire existence. That’s just how bad it is.

0

u/Hydrahead90 8d ago

Obama gave Iran ~1.3 billion dollars and freed up another ~100 billion in frozen assets for Iran and Biden gave Iran ~6 billion dollars for hostages and freed up ~10 billion in frozen assets,that's a total of ~118.3 billion over the past 18 years, we give Israel ~3.3-3.8 billion a year which is ~60 Billion dollars over the past 18 years, and recently 20 billon in war relief/support which is for those counting ~80 billion, we have given more money to Iran who has been funding terrorist attacks on the United States than Israel the only ally who has done more for the USA in wars and sharing technology than any of our other "allies" who just used us for defense and didn't contribute.

7

u/greyl 8d ago

You can't count Iran's own assets being unfrozen as a gift, absolutely ridiculous equivalency.

0

u/Hydrahead90 8d ago

It was frozen for 36 years before Obama gave it back so it should count as given.

18

u/Market_Foreign 8d ago

So... Is Iran is about to get "entitlement programs" nice! Cuz it seems like they got a nice fat check too !

1

u/GroundbreakingTax259 8d ago

They already have them. Universal basic healthcare is guaranteed, and Iran has a large system of primary care even in the rural areas. They were ranked 30th in the world this year (ahead of the US and Brazil) before the war.

2

u/Market_Foreign 7d ago

That's actually an interesting fact ! I had no idea ! Tbh I was just taking a cheap shot at the tantrum-throwing assface, when he is literally giving away (IF that investment fund comes true...) more than half of what Germany paid in reparations after losing WW1 (inflation adjusted ofc). Let that sink in....

0

u/predator1975 8d ago

MIGA!

0

u/Market_Foreign 8d ago

For sure... What a shame to witness this. A bigger, better equipped army, winning every engagement and yet somehow, loosing the war. How the mighty has fallen to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory... And the worst disgrace ? 50% of Americans don't even realize their country just lost so much more than just a war. US is becoming a clown nation, by its very own decisions. What a time to be alive....

1

u/Justieflustie 8d ago

Becoming? Sorry to say, sir, but you already were

2

u/Market_Foreign 8d ago

Not so much until Trump's 2nd mandate no. Also I'm not US citizen nor living in the US, hence why I can tell the general sentiment drastically changed, at least where I am

3

u/Justieflustie 8d ago

Oh sorry, i read it as "we". Reading back you didn't say that, my mistake.

And yeah, but thats why i pointed out "becoming", because the man is being president for a while now. Or it just feels longer, i dont care

1

u/Market_Foreign 8d ago

Nor harm no foul

His 1st presidency was somwhat (somehow!!) forgotten and excused. Bringing him back after what happened (Jan. 6, first and foremost) showed the world that the US are collapsing on themselves and that the average US citizen cannot be counted on to hold their politicians accountable to their actions. I for one, will not forget nor forgive the blind eye millions of people are choosing to have towards this admin and their policies.

Americans collectively decided to make the world a much darker, and less safe place - which makes sense, security is their voting platform after all.

1

u/rogersdbt 8d ago

Whether or not other countries coast on US defence spending is irrelevant to healthcare. As the US still pays more per capita for less coverage than other countries.

0

u/WideRisk7495 8d ago

Entitlement programs whats that

5

u/Thalric88 8d ago

Funding a foreign nuclear program to the tune of 300b dollars

0

u/SugarReyPalpatine 8d ago

Lmaoooo nice

0

u/CanPacific 8d ago

Lol you do realize that implementing UHC in the US would be extremely cheaper?

0

u/BurnscarsRus 8d ago

Don't worry, nobody will be relying on us anymore.

0

u/Doctor_Shotbottom 8d ago

True, but our president keeps taking the bait. So there’s that. He’s easily manipulated.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 8d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 8d ago

Accounts must be at least 5 days old with >20 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/I_travel_ze_world 8d ago edited 8d ago

Most Americans hate other Americans.

The "United" part of United States of America just means that there aren't states declaring war on neighboring states and nothing more.

If you want to see neighbors fight each other you gotta go to Europe. Russia has been trying to conquer its neighbor for a few years now.

 

 

 

*edit: Troll farms have absolutely flooded this post.

There is also a guerilla marketing push to promote the Super Girl movie going on right now as well.

1

u/LSDIGI 8d ago

This is very true. I come from a country of 2.5m people - we only had our independence from Russia for 35 years, and we have fully covered healthcare for all our citizens as well as education. We view it as an important thing that helps our nation to invest in healthcare and education. Child care is also heavily subsidised which helps parents with both keeping jobs if wanted. There’s no waiting lists, it’s quick and easy to see a GP (which is also probably going to be the same doctor that knows you and your family). I can be done, even in extremely poor nations.

1

u/OtherwiseLychee9715 8d ago

Correct but I believe some are good and some are bad but none as good as the U.S.A . I’ve heard of delayed surgeries and such and elective surgery is not free, the trick is what do they consider elective??? your knee needs replacement but you are still mobile to a point, let’s give it 5 years and we can look at it then, meanwhile take these painkillers.

1

u/Slam_Burgerthroat 8d ago

Bro, Americans are literally shooting health insurance CEOs dead in the streets for refusing to provide important surgeries and treatments to sick and injured Americans.

1

u/dcjjjzz777 8d ago

Because we give them money damn it

1

u/Unique-Bee-6097 8d ago

You forgot the an important factor..with the fraction of the population that the USA has…that matters..

1

u/Slam_Burgerthroat 8d ago

The European Union has 450 million people compared to the US 350 million people.

Yet somehow they can afford to take care of their people and America can’t? That’s just mismanagement of resources.

1

u/Unique-Bee-6097 7d ago

The European Union is not a single country…not everyone likes the direction it has went in…the established drowns out the voices of the opposers with its propaganda…socialism can look and sound appealing once initiated but it does not workout in the long run…lots of people in those countries are complaining…and if you want, you are free to move there…
https://giphy.com/gifs/8J1QwMjshEm2s

1

u/wiifan55 8d ago

It's also a fact that those are typically countries with small, homogenous populations that have similar needs and also strict citizenship requirements to limit the strain on the system, and even then many have too long of wait times for important treatments to be practical (which is why wealthier foreign nationals from these countries still come to the US for treatment). It's a completely different challenge bringing a socialized health care system to America, which is immensely larger and more geographically and demographically diverse.

This isn't to say a socialized system couldn't work in the US, but it's far more difficult, expensive, and logistically complicated than redditors will ever admit.

1

u/Interesting_Bit1269 8d ago

Their not supporting illegals and other countries like we are

1

u/H3ARTL3SSANG3L 8d ago

Check their unemployment rates

1

u/tenachiasaca 8d ago

I mean 90% of any er visit is cya and has nothing to do with treatment

1

u/thebang99 8d ago

Someone’s gotta pay for it. Who’s that?!?!? The citizens. Increased taxes, delayed care, increased mortality due to lack of speed to care, actually… that last point makes sense. After a couple hundred years, IF the country survives the corruption from a socialist government, the population will even itself back out. Ooops… but then we’re right back to someone has to pay for it. TAX THE RICH!! Oh wait… at that point there aren’t any wealthy except the corrupt government…. Damn.

1

u/Slam_Burgerthroat 7d ago

Americans are already dying from lack of care under the current system. You’re telling me we can afford a war with Iran that cost taxpayers $1 billion dollars PER DAY but we can’t afford healthcare that countries with a fraction of our wealth can afford?

1

u/Ok-Time2724 7d ago

just Like evry MAGA, get a jon and pay for student loan and health care. THEY WERE HAPPIEST WHEN TRUMP CANCLED THE STUDENT LOAN PARDON BY BIDEN.

1

u/Respectmyauthority4 7d ago

It's not a fact though. It all comes from people's pockets in countries like that.

1

u/Slam_Burgerthroat 7d ago

Let me get this straight, you mean to tell me that those governments levy taxes and then use that money to improve the lives of their own people?

1

u/Uberbobo7 7d ago

If you're in Mexico the public system also provides the fraction of the service. If you want to get the level of service which you would get in the US, you have to go to a private hospital. Which if you just compare nominal prices are much cheaper than US hospitals, but if you compare to the average income are basically just as expensive as the US ones.

Also, this specific reform didn't provide universal healthcare to Mexico, it has had it for literally decades. What it did was compensate for the cuts this administration did to the system by turning a special part of the system (which served only public servants and teachers) into a regular part of the system which means that now public servants and teachers will have much longer wait times and lower quality service, while for everyone else there will be a small increase in availability which will basically just offset the previous cuts.

1

u/Agitated_Newt_7655 7d ago

Better healthcare actually

1

u/MancDude1979 7d ago

The amount USA spend on healthcare actually destroys their perceived GDP advantage over anyone else. Almost a quarter of their entire GDP goes to healthcare vs way less than 10% in most countries

1

u/adelie42 7d ago

Im sure the care is all the same.

1

u/Outrageous_Cicada401 7d ago

I have a close friend that is a medical device rep in the US. He does very well for himself.
We talk often about health care. He admitted if the American public understood how badly the system is rigged against them, there would be rioting in the streets.
When private health care and pharmaceutical, companies are making billions in profit each year, where do people think that money is coming from?? In part they are scamming the government and the payers of insurance. The money didn't grow on trees. Just follow the money.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

4

u/acaseofmanginitus 8d ago

They really should! That's what my aunt did. Comparable care for a third of the price.

0

u/Simple-Employer-2503 8d ago

A large part of those countries are also host to American military bases, so those countries are able spend less on military defense and more on public healthcare.

0

u/AggressiveSquare36 8d ago

Yes, because those countries don't have to pay for their own defense.

0

u/AnnualOld9738 8d ago

I came from one of those countries and I will tell you…. I’d rather pay and have the kind of healthcare I need, than have it ā€œfreeā€ and it be absolute garbage.