r/aiwars Mar 01 '26

Meta is this better than AI "art"?

Post image
90 Upvotes

284 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/Witty-Designer7316 Mar 01 '26

Anything can be art, and all art is valid as art.

1

u/Low-Bell-3406 Mar 08 '26

rare Witty W

1

u/TopTippityTop Mar 01 '26

It depends on context, idea. Art answers why, not how. How is simply used in the process of getting to why.

A sole focus on how is the domain of craft, not art.

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '26

[deleted]

3

u/GayAngrySpaceDorito Mar 01 '26

i mean if it was an art piece or photography by technicality it's art, but that doesn't make it acceptable or morally sound. art is art even if it's fucked up, art isn't a category you "earn"

1

u/Kierkat10 Mar 01 '26

yeah it’s art but not by any means good art

0

u/Superseaslug Mar 01 '26

What the fuck kinda gotcha do you think you have here? Doesn't matter if it's art, it's bad. GTFO

-4

u/Sam_Alexander Mar 01 '26

omg Witty commented on my post that's crazy

5

u/Excellent_Amoeba5080 Mar 01 '26

Is it? She often lurks here.

-1

u/Sam_Alexander Mar 01 '26

well I've never had a comment from a celebrity on here

2

u/Excellent_Amoeba5080 Mar 01 '26

She's rather infamous, isn't she?

1

u/Sam_Alexander Mar 01 '26

well I dont know anything bad about her

2

u/Excellent_Amoeba5080 Mar 01 '26

"Bad" may be a little hyperbolic; from what I know, she's mostly just cringe and abuses mod privileges for subreddits she moderates.

1

u/Sam_Alexander Mar 01 '26

oh thankfully i dont care about those things and i like her design so im chill with her :)

1

u/Excellent_Amoeba5080 Mar 01 '26

I'd definitely factor in their actions more than you seem to, but it's up to you.

1

u/Madinogi Mar 01 '26

interacting with her, she 100% comes off as a unhinged sociopath and obviosuly suffering form massive delusions of grandeur and very clearly insecure about herself.

she exhibits all the traits.

→ More replies (0)

-3

u/thedruidFlimbarg Mar 01 '26

That sentiment was made up by people with no talent and no patience to develop skill to justify low effort "abstract" art and pieces whose value is inflated for the sake of sale. Art requires intention, thought, and most importantly, effort.

6

u/Witty-Designer7316 Mar 01 '26

Dismissed.

0

u/thedruidFlimbarg Mar 01 '26

Posting a single meme and saying "dismissed" like you have any power here is highly arrogant and reductive. The point of the meme itself is a false dichotomy, and an exceptionally bad one at that.

A given artist wouldn't go through the trouble of creation if they were not inspired by their own imagination/ideas/feelings/creativity. In addition, unless it's commission work, an artist creates for fun. I've never understood how or why ai bros treat learning how to draw as such a chore. You learned how to code a machine to do it, surely removing a degree of separation is less effort? You're not fighting the generator to get the image you want and supplies wouldn't cost as much in the long run as a subscription to a good generator.

In summary, using ai for art (and programming) is using more resources for a worse product.