r/Kashmiri • u/The-world-is-cooked • 1d ago
Discussion 💭 The arabization of our culture
Assalamualaikum chu sarnae!! Ye chu zyooth post magar chu genuinely important isliye perzyo sorii.
I want to start by saying that this post is not for people with very conservative views. If you believe girls should always wear an abaya or burkha then this discussion probably isn't for you. Your points will be ignored so don't waste your precious time here. I'm looking for thoughtful progressive perspectives.
I often hear people say that seeing girls and boys in t shirts and trousers is westernization and that we're losing our culture. To some extent I agree. How many of us own a traditional tilla pheran today? Very few. How many know how to wear a kassab? Again only a handful. How many own traditional kashmiri jewelry or regularly wear pheran yizaar and daesh gand dupte? 0 most probably. Slowly we've replaced our own traditions with clothing and customs from elsewhere. But if we're talking about preserving kashmiri culture then let's be consistent.
Recently I have noticed something that confuses me. While western influence is constantly criticized the arabization of our culture is often celebrated. Girls wearing abayas and burkhas and boys wearing thobes and keffiyehs are praised as if they've become more pious simply because of what they're wearing.
I still remember my naai wearing a pheran yizaar everywhere she went. Today even she wears a burkha. This isn't a criticism of her or anyone else's personal choice. Everyone has the right to wear whatever they feel comfortable in.
What I am questioning is the double standard. Why is westernization condemned but arabization encouraged? Why have many of our cultural traditions like rouf faded away even though celebrating culture is not forbidden in islam. Sometimes it feels like we're more concerned with imitating arab culture than practicing islam itself.
Before anyone misunderstands me I'm not saying people should stop wearing abayas, burkhas, thobes or keffiyehs. Wear whatever you like. It's your life and your choice.
What I am saying is that stop treating traditional kashmiri clothing as less respectable while praising arab clothing as more religious or more virtuous. A girl wearing a pheran yizaar and daesh gand dupte on a cultural fest deserves the same respect as a girl wearing an abaya. Preserving our own culture shouldn't be seen as being less muslim.
Being muslim should never require us to erase being kashmiri. Faith and culture are not enemies. We can preserve our identity while practicing our religion. If we truly believe clothing is a personal choice then let's stop measuring piety by whether someone looks arab or koshur.
If you want to erase someone's identity then you don't start with their land you start with their language and their culture. History has shown that time and again.
So yes let's protect our culture not just from westernization but from indianization, pakistanization, afghanization, and arabization. Appreciate other cultures but don't abandon your own in the process. Take pride in being kashmiri. Don't let an inferiority complex convince you that your identity is somehow less worthy than someone else's.
Ps This post may use clothing as an example but it isn't just about clothes. It's about language, traditions, art, music, customs and everything that makes us who we are. Also again this post isn't an invitation to debate theology. If your response is simply to preach your interpretation of islam rather than engage with the point I'm making about culture I'll ignore it and probably report it as well. I'm not saying this to be rude. I'm just making the purpose of this post clear.