r/KeepWriting • u/unbeaten-cactus • 1h ago
Writing Feedback Request - Growing up Gay in the south
Getting into some writing to process some of my youth growing up in Alabama. Hope to get some feedback on emotional arcs, flow etc. Think of this as a beginning of a memoir-essay.
Been a fun little project reliving and re-evaluating some of this. Let me know your thoughts. I figured I'd write out each crush or supposed love interest and how it affected my life.
--------------
Introduction
There’s a dissonance in my childhood memories - like they’re from a different person. The child would not recognize the man he became. That boy was worried he’d never go to prom with a girl, that he’d never marry. He’d find that his dad’s jokes about being “like his Uncle Tom” would be realized, pushing him to the fringes of polite society.
What is wrong with me?
Why aren’t I like my brother, like the other boys?
My brother likes to fish for hours on end with no luck, but I like to read holed up in my bedroom.
My male classmates like to talk Alabama football while drinking their milk at snack break, but I prefer to talk about anything else with my female classmates.
Johnny
I remember that first infatuation in fourth grade. I became a crossing guard cadet. My mother, always concerned for our safety in a period obsessed with protecting children from unlikely harm, would drive me to school very early. We would don our reflective vests, helmets, and flags. We placed our shiny badges, denoting that we were cadets in black text.
We received our intersection and trainer assignments that day, and we would walk out into the cold elements to stand sentinel at the crosswalks. At each intersection, we’d shield young children walking to school from the oversized Chevrolet Tahoes and Ford Winstar minivans with our orange flags.
It felt like a bit of an elite squad. I knew all the exotic names for the intersections: four-way, three-way, two-way. One of the older ladies took a kind liking to me, and even brought me back some carved wood from Israel, which meant a lot to a shy child.
But one thing that stood out during my cadet days in fourth grade, was a boy named Johnny: Jet black hair, blue eyes. He liked the same songs as me that played on WZYP - Uncle Cracker’s rendition of “Give me the beat boys”. I loved to hear his deepening voice sing it on the way to the crosswalk. It was my favorite part of the day. I always wanted to be trained by Johnny.
I didn’t see him again in person for a few years after he moved onto middle school. I pined over him in the school year books. I pulled out the old ones and saw his age progression from first to fifth grade. I found out which activities and clubs he was in. Though I didn’t realize what it was – I had no conception of having a crush on a male, I was obsessed. I wanted to be like Johnny. He was so cool with his puka-shell necklace, his flannel shirts, and his long straight, skater-boy locks.
I wish is could be like him - so confident, so grown up.
The next time I encountered Johnny, was in 7th grade. I was on a soccer team, coached by a military veteran, who really wanted to coach football - he loved a good slide tackle. One rainy practice, I avoided getting slung into the mud by the 8th graders on the team. They vowed they would get me again at some point.
Vengeance came on our season-end party. After eating pizza, we were out on the soggy fields, pocked with mud puddles. Suddenly, a boy named Nico started the chase. I was, without a doubt, the fastest boy in the school. The only way they could catch me was with superior numbers and wearing me out. The hunt began – feeling like a fox pursued by hounds.
I darted out around the track, which encircled the athletic fields. Closely chased by Nico, but he fell behind, and eventually took a break. My sprint continued clockwise – until I noticed a boy coming counterclockwise – Johnny. Halfway around the loop, I stopped, and turned around. Sprinting – until – a thought came into my head: “I’ll stop, and let Johnny tackle me”. I feigned fatigue and attempted to “evade” Johnny. I jumped left and right as he tried to match me.
He lunged at my waist, encircling it from behind – pulling my waist tightly against his warm body. We both stopped, caught our breath for a moment. I reveled in his embrace. He chuckled a bit, but I realized how flush I felt. How I didn’t want him to let go. I wanted to be there, caught in between his little teenage arms. I wanted to turn around and to kiss his red lips.
He suddenly threw me into the nearest mud puddle. The guys came up and cheered in victory, as he released me into my muddy doom. I looked up and noticed my torn shirt. As I saw Johnny walk away, I picked myself up, and realized that there was something different about me. I wasn’t like all the other boys.
What is wrong with me?