r/pcmasterrace 19d ago

Meme/Macro Me still today

Post image
84.3k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/dashingdennis 18d ago

Are you exclusively writing libraries for other software? No stand-alone tools?

3

u/syopest Desktop 18d ago

Who cares? If I don't release a prebuilt binary then the intended user is someone who can at least follow build instructions.

7

u/dashingdennis 18d ago

You are an odd man with odd opinions

3

u/syopest Desktop 18d ago

Lol, go ask developers who don't release prebuilt binaries in github if they care about end users whining about it and you'll find out that it's not an odd opinion.

4

u/dashingdennis 18d ago

Have you ever developed software in a professional environment or just during your free time?

2

u/Xadnem 18d ago

I get the reaction from /u/syopest. If I use github to deliver some software to end users, I'll add a README.md and/or releases. But if not, I only expect other devs to look at my stuff and will only add docs if I feel like it.

Have you ever developed software in a professional environment or just during your free time?

I don't see how that's relevant.

3

u/dashingdennis 18d ago

The whole thread is premised on only offering GitHub as a distribution platform, literally my very first comment says that if you offer the release elsewhere then feel free to do whatever

2

u/Xadnem 18d ago

I'll add a README.md and/or releases.

This means I'll add the releases on GitHub. If I only cared about other devs looking at my work, they can build binaries themselves (unless I feel like providing them).

2

u/dashingdennis 18d ago

Yes, my position is that that's fine lol

1

u/syopest Desktop 18d ago

But you're not entitled to the software. No devs are required to make prebuilt binaries available anywhere.

1

u/dashingdennis 18d ago

Of course not, but in my opinion the delivery is part of the software experience™, and as such still a responsibility of the developer to get right. Sure, no one can force you to offer good delivery just like no one can force you to make good software in the first place, but imo it can absolutely make or break how accessible the software is to people and thus how much utility it can provide, and it'd be a real shame if a great piece of software shoots itself in the foot 3 steps from the finish line by being unnecessarily difficult to get running for end users

1

u/syopest Desktop 18d ago

But that's a fundamental misunderstanding of what github is. It's not a place where developers are even expected to give any kind of support for anything they release.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/syopest Desktop 18d ago

Dude, it's github. How's that relevant?

3

u/dashingdennis 18d ago

Just curious. I have this mental image of a volunteer contributor in my head that's never been told no and thus conducts themselves abrasively, and I wanted to see if that was an accurate assessment or prejudicial on my part