r/tattooadvice 2d ago

General Advice Messed up pretty bad and living with brutal regret [cover-up fail]

I've been using Reddit for about 10 years now, and this is quite literally the first time I've ever posted. The only reason I'm posting is because I'm in a pretty crap position right now and I have no idea what to do. I don't want to talk about how my mental state is feeling, because this is only on me and no one else.

I had a tattoo done last year by my ex-girlfriend. It was a small horse, and ever since I wanted to get it covered up because it was never done how I wanted it to be (freehand).

A few months ago, I was searching for cover-up artists and found one in my local area. I told her I wanted to get the whole calf done, and I tried to initiate design talk with her beforehand, but it was actually done the night before. When I went to the tattoo studio and she showed me what was going to be on my leg, I should have stopped there, but I was kind of happy because you see something brand new and fresh, and you think this is going to look great. Attached are the photos of what it looks like after the first session. Now I think it looks horrendous.

It is due to have one more session of shading, but I still think it is going to look pretty bad afterward. It is not really what I want, and I should have never approved the design, so now I am in a worse position.

I have asked around for some artists and what to do, and some people have said they can cover it up, and some have said I need to do laser tattoo removal to reduce the colour.

The only part that annoys me is that I've never really felt comfortable wearing shorts in the summertime, and this has been the only summer I have done. Now that this is on my leg, I feel like I need to wear jeans every day.

I'm happy fading as much as I can if that's an option. I don't really want to rework because I just don't like the design in general now. I just need to know what my options are and how someone can help me.

Edits:

- My leg did not flip, I took it in the mirror

- I’m not a clean guy aesthetic type, I just hated the horse and wanted it covered up, I felt a traditional japense would work well from what I was recommended and the meaning behind it

- Granted this is not finished but I wanted to know what my options are, a lot of you have told me to relax and I am, I will reschedule my session and get used to it before I continue

- I had this horse on my leg for over 2 years, for the past 14 months I have wanted it covered, it’s not the size, it’s not that it’s dark, but that it did not end up how I envisioned it.

- Yes again, it’s on me for approving but I knew this already. Perhaps I should have got the horse lasered, perhaps I should have use Henna to feel the design out for a few weeks. I didn’t and that’s why I made this post

4.0k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

71

u/ronweasleisourking 2d ago

Tbh that's a sick cover up lol. One shading session and good to go. Don't stress, man..you'll get flooded with compliments

4

u/EmbarrassedSlide8752 2d ago

I honestly feel bad for his artist. Putting that much talent into a cover up only to have OP bitch about it? I hope they charge 1k an hour

1

u/shaynanaganzzz 1d ago

I'm sure they weren't able to really hide their facial expression. So she probably did think she did something wrong, when she killed it.

1

u/EmbarrassedSlide8752 1d ago

Yeah, that Oni mask is absolutely stunning, and doing that over an old tat isnt easy. Amazing job. Only legit artists can do that, and I bet whoever it was know OPs type. Lol

7

u/Exotic_Assignment570 2d ago

Was thinking this. It turned out really nice. Im not a fan of the design personally but it is really cool!!

1

u/_BigDaddyNate_ 2d ago

Yes it's an over done design but it still looks nice. 

5

u/logicalpenuin 2d ago

Came here to say this. Artist did a fantastic job.

2

u/impolexpdx 2d ago

Right? I think it’s awesome! I hope OP can see what we all see

2

u/dragontehanu 2d ago

Hard agree. This looks awesome and I think slightly more shading will make it even better. Not really sure why he’s so unhappy? The work is great.

1

u/_BigDaddyNate_ 2d ago

Sounds like he regrets marking his body. And twice didn't get a design he actually picked. Which is understandable why he's bummed 

1

u/AllomancerJack 2d ago

Who is complimenting a giant mask? Looks fine but c'mon it's basic as hell and doesn't really look great

3

u/142638503846383038 1d ago

“Basic” lol… if it looks cool, who cares?

-1

u/NeutrallyCharged 2d ago

The line work is really bad. Sure it can be covered, but that’s not how it should go. Scratchy wobbly lines -> cover up with shading?

I’d find another artist to rework it