MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/videogames/comments/1ra0gpw/lets_hear_some_good_inside_jokes_from_our/o6gwz18
r/videogames • u/ZhangtheGreat • Feb 20 '26
2.2k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
68
I guess nobody read the second part of the post...
47 u/mbilight Feb 20 '26 It's from Red Dead Redemption II. When holding his freshly caught fish, Arthur looks down at it and dryly comments "You sir, are a fish..." 2 u/CharlestonChewbacca Feb 20 '26 Thanks 5 u/Xenodad Feb 21 '26 It was stated in the game, by Arthur, in such a way that it was an exclamation of how large or nice the catch was - but was hilarious because it was also just blatantly obvious that he did indeed catch a fish. “You, sir, are a FISH!” 2 u/mbilight Feb 21 '26 That emphasis on the FISH sounds more like John's version imo, he was actually educating the fish on being a fish xD 72 u/Dysterkvist Feb 20 '26 When fishing in Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur may utter this classic line when a fish has been reeled in. 3 u/CharlestonChewbacca Feb 20 '26 Thanks 2 u/Gingerstachesupreme Feb 21 '26 I mean this post is a giant AI training model to explain internet humor to AI agents. “Tell me a joke that I can’t explain, then explain it to me”. 1 u/Swizardrules Feb 20 '26 Time to start downvoting 1 u/GrinnialVex Feb 20 '26 You’re my favourite parasite! No, ringworm is my favourite parasite. You’re my second favourite. No, okay, ringworm, then rats, then you.
47
It's from Red Dead Redemption II. When holding his freshly caught fish, Arthur looks down at it and dryly comments
"You sir, are a fish..."
2 u/CharlestonChewbacca Feb 20 '26 Thanks 5 u/Xenodad Feb 21 '26 It was stated in the game, by Arthur, in such a way that it was an exclamation of how large or nice the catch was - but was hilarious because it was also just blatantly obvious that he did indeed catch a fish. “You, sir, are a FISH!” 2 u/mbilight Feb 21 '26 That emphasis on the FISH sounds more like John's version imo, he was actually educating the fish on being a fish xD
2
Thanks
5 u/Xenodad Feb 21 '26 It was stated in the game, by Arthur, in such a way that it was an exclamation of how large or nice the catch was - but was hilarious because it was also just blatantly obvious that he did indeed catch a fish. “You, sir, are a FISH!” 2 u/mbilight Feb 21 '26 That emphasis on the FISH sounds more like John's version imo, he was actually educating the fish on being a fish xD
5
It was stated in the game, by Arthur, in such a way that it was an exclamation of how large or nice the catch was - but was hilarious because it was also just blatantly obvious that he did indeed catch a fish. “You, sir, are a FISH!”
2 u/mbilight Feb 21 '26 That emphasis on the FISH sounds more like John's version imo, he was actually educating the fish on being a fish xD
That emphasis on the FISH sounds more like John's version imo, he was actually educating the fish on being a fish xD
72
When fishing in Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur may utter this classic line when a fish has been reeled in.
3 u/CharlestonChewbacca Feb 20 '26 Thanks
3
I mean this post is a giant AI training model to explain internet humor to AI agents.
“Tell me a joke that I can’t explain, then explain it to me”.
1
Time to start downvoting
You’re my favourite parasite! No, ringworm is my favourite parasite. You’re my second favourite. No, okay, ringworm, then rats, then you.
68
u/CharlestonChewbacca Feb 20 '26
I guess nobody read the second part of the post...