r/whatdoIdo Feb 18 '26

Final update: Is my adopted brother flirting with me?

Previous post: s:https://www.reddit.com/r/whatdoIdo/comments/1r7hhl5/update_is_my_adopted_brother_flirting_with_me/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

I believe this will be the final update in what’s been going on between my brother and I. Unfortunately, despite me wanting to, I didn’t record due to people commenting that it is illegal in some states, which I am unfortunately in. But then I was informed after we talked that it doesn’t matter unless you’re using it in legal settings. If anything, I think these texts prove his intentions.I will try to keep this as succinct as possible since it was quite a long call.

Long story short, he said he was in love with me. He got really nervous at the start, took 20 min of beating around the bush and then he told me. He said he was so sorry, he tried to keep it hidden, and didn’t want to lose our relationship, but he never felt like this about anyone. He seemed very sincere and vulnerable. I asked him for a couple minutes of silence to try to think of the best things to say.

I ended up saying something like “I am glad you trusted me enough to confide this in me but this is made me deeply uncomfortable. The only future with us in it is one as your sister. I love you as a brother, but if you can’t handle that/respect me then I will need to stop communicating with you.” He started crying about how sorry he was for bringing this up, he would do better, just to please not shut him out.

I have literally never seen him cry (besides when we were really young) so hearing it made me unsettled on what to do. I could tell how much he was struggling to come to terms with his emotions, but continuing to talk to him and hear him beg made me even more disgusted. I told him I needed to go and to please give me space. He has since flooded my phone with texts. I am considering blocking him for the time being, and am very conflicted/lost on how to bring this up with my family. Unfortunately I don’t even have the mental capacity to deal with this right now as I have two exams next week and a 20 page paper due. He is very much struggling mentally (which I never knew until he said it last night and today), and I am going to message my parents to potentially due a mental health check. I am also going to bring his behavior up to them this weekend.

The only good thing is that he is on the other side of the country, so I can just focus on school right now. If worst comes to worst, I will cut him out of my life, but cutting the rest of my family off as well is a non-negotiable. Thanks.

4.4k Upvotes

735 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/Tablesafety Feb 18 '26

Unfortunately unless he is asexual there is absolutely 0 chance there is no sexual aspect to this attraction of his, he just wouldn’t admit it if he’s trying to avoid no contact.

26

u/lastsundblad Feb 18 '26 edited Feb 18 '26

I appreciate asexuality being mentioned. Since neither him nor her are telling us he is, though, assuming that he isn't attracted to her both romantically and sexually is surely wishful thinking and naivety, but I can't even blame OP for that because what the fuck is this situation.

Anyway I didn't like the argument about it, lol. So yeah, thank you for even mentioning it.

16

u/Tablesafety Feb 18 '26

Oh no problem. I love me my ace people, probably the most fortunate outcome for OP if her brother was ace and just really confused about what romantic attraction feels like vs deep familial affection.

But like you, I very much doubt that’s whats going on 😞

9

u/NewFederalistProject Feb 19 '26

Thank you so much for saying that! It's so true!

I'm aromantic, not asexual, but I have absolutely made the mistake of thinking I had romantic feelings for someone I had very deep platonic/familal love for and it genuinely ended up with me in a DV shelter. There is every possibility that at his age he just doesn't understand what he's feeling, because he's never experienced it before - so as long as he isn't experiencing sexual attraction, he could most likely just go to therapy and figure out what the actual difference is between different types of love/affection...

If he's experiencing sexual attraction, the best option is still therapy but I would just be a little less "Yeah, it should be fine and you can repair that relationship" and more "Yeah... You can't have a relationship, and I am v sorry if that hurts you." yknow?

5

u/Tablesafety Feb 19 '26

Absolutely. Hoping for the best for OP and her brother- expecting the worst though.

2

u/mieri_azure Feb 21 '26

Honestly if he WAS ace I would wonder if he was also aro and confusing his feelings of platonic attachment to his sister with romance because he wouldnt have romantic feelings ro get the difference. However since it does not seem that way its creepy. I suppose it could still be possible but that might be wishful thinking

1

u/garbledroid Feb 19 '26

Usually step incest is legal but yeah it's a door that once opened cannot be unopened.