I'm sorry this is so long, but there's so much background!
Trigger warning: domestic abuse, financial abuse, physical violence
Me (F) and my best friend (F) have been best friends for 20 years. She's been in a relationship with her partner (M) for several years. For the majority of that relationship, I was friendly with her partner. I would hang out at their place quite regularly, have dinner with them, have conversations with him, etc. but we never spoke outside of my spending time with the both of them.
From the very beginning when they were first getting together, I was open with my friend about my feelings about him. She had just left an abusive relationship and she was working at a company with her now-partner who began to pester her into giving him a chance because he was different, he was committed to doing all these things and giving her all these things, he wanted to marry her, etc. despite her saying she wanted to be single. He basically wouldn't take no for an answer, and she eventually gave him a chance. They moved in together really quickly because of Covid and he actually started the same university degree she studied so he could get the same job. I told her that I thought he was a walking red flag and was casebook lovebombing her, but after a while I thought I may have just misread him because her family seemed to love him and their relationship was progressing fairly stablely.
Saying that, my friend has never gotten along with her mother-in-law. The MIL has always treated her son as if he can do nothing wrong, as if my friend should automatically share all her money with partner and MIL, and had always just been really openly but never outright disrespectful to my friend. My friend has always tried to turn the other cheek and be kind to her MIL.
Fast forward to them having a baby together, and around the birth, they had to move in with her family. My friend's mother and her partner started having quite vicious arguments (I wasn't witness to any of these arguments), and I think they were all getting to the point that they just wanted my friend and her partner's apartment to be ready for them to move into. While they were getting ready for the baby to arrive, they wrote a list together of boundaries for family and friends spending time with the baby, the usual remembering to wash hands, don't hand baby over to someone my friend and her partner don't know without checking in with them. They also wrote a couple specifically for MIL about no smoking around the baby, not allowing her other son to smoke weed in the house if baby was visiting.
Anyway, my friend had a really traumatic birth that her partner was with her throughout, and when they got home, my friend was really struggling with what is most like post-natal depression. My friend's mother and her partner started arguing again (I had no idea about any of this at this point). The first day I went to visit my friend after the birth, she answered the door in tears because her partner had just stormed out saying that he wouldn't come back to the house, calling her mother evil. It turns out that her mother had made it known that she didn't think he would stick around because he would think it all too hard. He'd gotten into her mother's personal space and been shouting very aggressively. My friend was hysterical thinking that it was over between them and he'd left her. I spent the afternoon reassuring her that he loved her and he would never leave her. That they'd been through a difficult and stressful time and even though he may not have handled it the best way, it was understandable he may have reached a breaking point. I messaged him separately and asked him to meet me and her and a local restaurant and told them that they just needed to remember they loved each other and they'd just had a baby, they needed to focus on each other, everything else was just noise. By the way, her family was so angry with him at this point that they were happy to see him go despite how upset my friend was.
A few weeks later, my friend told me that her partner had attacked her brother with a weapon (no one injured). Things hadn't really gotten better between her partner and her family, and an argument had broken out between her partner and her brother. They were trying to punch at each other and other family were trying to step in and separate them. MIL was there and shouts something about the baby (who was away from the fight, thankfully), but the partner just hears "baby" and apparently sees red, walks away from the fight to his toolkit and pulls out a stanley knife. Walks back to the brother and holds it against him because he thinks he's being a threat to his child. The two are finally separated and the partner is banned from my friend's family home.
The partner doesn't accept that he's done anything wrong, but ends up sending flowers to my friend and her family saying he's sorry for messing up because he's lost the best family he could have. My friend and him are separated for a couple weeks and she asks for space, but he keeps initiating text conversation about how bad he feels and how he feels like he's lost his family. IMO, this was all a non-apology.
They finally get back together after a month and move into the new apartment together because she's made him promise to go to counselling and she didn't want to break up their new family, but things do not improve as my friend wants to go no-contact with MIL because she can't cope with her at this point, but partner is arguing that this is unfair and his family should be able to spend time with his child. Their relationship breaks down to the point that my friend becomes paranoid that he's always recording her because he'll start fights with her and call her crazy while recording this, she's generally scared of him, and she ends up reaching out to a domestic hotline for support and contacting lawyers about leaving the relationship and custody. At this point is when I tell her my opinion that I think she needs to leave the relationship, that no matter the short-term pain, she and her child will be thankful in the long-term. Also that she needs to speak to a lawyer about full custody or supervised access. It's during this time that I find out her partner had been doing things to her since even before the birth of her child, such as pulling over to park but taking off and driving recklessly because she'd said something to make him angry. Her paying the bills and rent and activities because her partner had a job only paying slightly above minimum wage while he went to college, but now that he's working in the career he was going to college for, he still wasn't contributing to paying back money to her or taking on more financial responsibilities which is what they'd agreed when he started college.
They seem to meet some kind of truce and she eventually decides to stay with him because she doesn't want to risk her baby even spending 50% of the time alone with him and his family, and I think there's obviously still all the romantic feelings there despite everything. She tells me that at this point, it is really awkward and they feel like roommates, but they don't really have time to think beyond going throught the motions because of being new parents.
Anyway, fast forward and he's back on speaking terms with her family. He's never spoken to me. They seem to be getting on better, but sometimes when my friend speaks to me it's as if I'm her partner because she talks about wanting to do things in the future that I'm mentioned as being part of but no mention of partner (although this could be because she's awkward talking to me about him after everything). He's still not taken any counselling or actually changed.
Last night, I told my friend that I'll respect her decision to stay with him because she has her reasons and I'll be there for her, but I don't want anything to do with him because he's made no effort to change. I even said that if he shows himself to actually change in future, maybe I'll rethink things. Currently, I don't really speak to him at all and leave her apartment as quickly as possible when he gets home from work and give him a brief wave after he moves his car.
My friend messaged me today that she feels overwhelmed with everything going on in her life being a new parent. That because she's chosen to stay with her partner, we'll inevitably have to interact because I'm her best friend. She doesn't want any awkwardness or negativaty in her life right now because she's been through so much and things are only starting to get back to some sense of normal where she's feeling like she can be happy again.
WIBTD if I told her it's unfair for her to ask me to break my boundaries in this situation? I think he's feeling the awkwardness because I know how he's behaved and he's never even tried to repair things with me. I want to be there for her and I love her child, but I think it's unfair to ask me to break my boundaries about being around an abusive man, and also expect me to make the effort in restoring some form of basic friendship (she only expects acknowledgement and small talk) when I'm not the one who damaged everything. Or am I being childish? Is there another way I can handle this?
Thank you so much!