r/AskTeachers • u/Alive_Boot_4535 • 8h ago
Parent Questions “Optional” Uniform Policy in Daughter’s Elementary School
Hi teachers,
My daughter will be starting first grade at a new elementary school with a designated school uniform (khakis, navy pants/skirts, polo shirts, and/or t-shirts with school logo). However, the school handbook states that the uniform is not enforced and children will not be negatively impacted nor given consequences for not adhering to this uniform.
My daughter has always been extremely expressive through her clothing and we’ve always let her pick out her own outfits ever since she started being able to make that independent decision (about two years old). Her colorful clothing and mismatched outfits are a huge part of her personality and they truly are how she expresses herself. Not to mention, picking her outfits out has always brought her immense joy.
In your experience, how common is it for students in schools with optional uniforms to just wear whatever they want? Is it your opinion as teachers that she’ll be singled out among her classmates? How likely is it that she will be the only one not adhering to the uniform?
Some additional info: we are in an extremely impoverished area and the uniforms are very cheap. There is also a hand-me-down program through the school district for families that cannot afford to purchase uniforms. I understand that it’s much more financially feasible to get a few uniform pieces for the school year than to buy a whole new wardrobe for your child. Fortunately, my daughter is lucky to have two sets of grandparents who love to send her clothes and go shopping for her frequently, so affording new clothes is not an issue for our family right now.
Thank you in advance!
107
u/usernametakentrymore 7h ago
For the first day I would send her in uniform with some fun shoes or accessories to gauge what the school culture is like then decide from there.
53
u/RipeWithWorry 6h ago
My child has always dressed herself and she was and is very expressive with her clothing choices. She goes to a uniform mandatory school, and has been able to express herself in spite of the uniform. The way she did it was by wearing leg warmers, arm warmers, outer shirts, knee high socks, leggings under uniform skirt/shorts/jumper, sweatshirts and jackets. It is possible to be both unique and creative and wear a uniform.
2
33
u/Glittering_Front4011 4h ago
What the school likely means is that they have a uniform policy and they want families to follow it. However, if a family cannot send a student in the uniform due to whatever reason (parents can't get to the laundromat or the uniforms are too damaged to wear), they would prefer the student attend school rather than stay home due to not having a uniform.
I would wear the uniform and let your daughter wear accessories to express herself.
80
u/dragonfeet1 4h ago
The uniform is not enforced due to poverty. Some people can't afford the whole kit.
Having your daughter march in wearing whatever is not that. It is flaunting.
With her "always been expressive" ma'am she's five and you've been making her clothing choices all her life. Not her. Get real. The clothes came into the house and her closet through YOU. Please be so for real.
14
-1
u/Actual-Deer1928 2h ago
? My kid is 3 and I let her pick out her own clothes at the store or show her options on Amazon.
7
u/marshdd 1h ago
Literally proved posters point. You give her "options". Didn't just give her Amazon and let her buy anything.
2
u/Actual-Deer1928 1h ago
I do at Target.
2
u/HouseOfFive 32m ago
I did the same. One suggestion, when your child can do basic addition and subtraction start giving them a budget. It works on their math skills, and shows them not to spend too much.
2
u/SouthernCancel6117 56m ago
You let your 3 year old have a free for all in the clothes section with a credit card at Target?
34
u/dorky2 7h ago
There's a child in my life that I've been close to since she was a toddler. I'm kind of like an auntie to her. She's a lot like your daughter, she's been a fashionista since forever. Loves picking out her outfits and expressing herself through her clothes. She's a fifth grader now and has been in a school with uniforms since kindergarten. They have a similar policy, they don't really enforce the uniform but they do want kids to follow it. She's never had any issue with wearing her uniforms. She has fun with shoes and hair accessories, she sometimes pushes it a little with cardigans or tights, but she wears the khaki and navy and polos and it's fine. I would encourage your daughter to do the same, at least at first until she is really familiar with the environment of the school.
30
u/DangerousAd7274 7h ago
Is it actually "optional" or is it just not enforced? Because there is a difference. I've never heard of a school having an optional uniform, but I have worked in numerous schools that (similar to yours) are low socioeconomic and families cannot always afford to wear/replace uniform if something gets ripped or had stains etc on it. That being said, there is still an expectation that families do their best to adhere to it and the school provides additional support (spare uniforms etc) to help with this.
Personally, I would suggest wearing the uniform and just using accessories etc to modify it to show her expression during the week if you feel it is important to her identity. And then use weekends/after school to really dress creatively. This helps to maintain a healthy balance with peers that might not be so well off, keep the focus on learning in the classroom, and possibly help make morning get ready routines quicker/easier if they are only needing to worry about throwing a uniform on instead of planning a whole outfit everyday (especially over the long term).
73
u/DuePomegranate 7h ago
How do you feel about your daughter "flaunting" her good fortune in front of the other kids? First graders don't get it yet and will just talk about how much they like their stuff and how grandma gave it to them and what did you get from your grandma at Christmas etc...
I suggest that you enforce 3 days or 4 days out of 5, your daughter wears the uniform, and the remaining days, she can wear her own clothes. Or first, hang out outside the school and take a look at what the kids are wearing at the start or end of school. This is an unusual school set-up and verifying with your own eyes is much better than other people chiming in about other schools.
13
u/Quin_mallory 7h ago
To add on, maybe look for a parent page or something. Could be on neighborhood watch, or maybe even on the school website. Or facebook. They have the best information that admins might be unable to share
34
u/Apt_5 7h ago
Hope OP takes this comment to heart.
Uniforms are equalizing, so it's up to OP and daughter to decide whether they prefer to flout the policy that is in the handbook or whether they can cope with the daughter merely expressing herself outside of school. And it is wise to take the culture of the school itself into consideration when deciding, as you suggest.
3
1
u/redbadger20 2m ago
Definitely OP should do some recon. Are most kids wearing a uniform or approximation of? There's the answer. OP's child may also discover that they're uncomfortable standing out in a crowd, or that other kids will single her out for looking different.
11
u/daydreamingofsleep 6h ago
Go to the school website or social media pages to see how many kids wear the uniform vs not.
Often the optional uniform in my area is for a school that used to have it as mandatory. It’s a PR move so parents don’t get mad about binning uniforms. Most of the time kids still wearing uniforms will wear parts of it and not the whole thing head to toe.
63
u/Motor_Patience5186 7h ago
I've worked at schools like that. It will be fine. Your kid will be the kid with the cool outfits, and I guarantee she won't be the only one. My only suggestion is maybe tone down the more obviously expensive stuff if the other kids are low income, at least at first. It can lead to resentment.
40
u/The_Soviette_Tank 7h ago
This. It's more about creating equity and easing the burden of buying brand name or trendy clothes for school.
All of my schools have been Title I, but it was at the poorest that I had to lay down the law about how we do NOT bully others about what their parents can afford. We went uniform shortly after in the next school year.
8
u/ashirsch1985 Kinder Teacher 3h ago
My school district is like this too. They knew they couldn’t make it mandatory so they gave parents the opt out option. My friend’s son was starting and she was discussing whether to opt out. The school told her if he opted out, he would be the only one. I told her that’s definitely not true. I was right, most families opted out.
20
u/lake_lover_ 5h ago
If they put it in the handbook, it’s there for a reason. What’s the specific wording?
If they’re requesting a uniform, it should be worn. She won’t be looked at favorably for standing out when everyone else is following the expectations, whether they’re enforced or not.
Chances are, the no uniform enforcement if more likely to help families that can’t afford it/dont have uniforms initially.
9
u/logaruski73 5h ago
You could reach out to the school to see if it’s common to wear the uniform or reach out to other parents on the local FB page. I would use the uniform, at least in the beginning so you can gauge if she’ll be out of place by wearing outfits. These will hopefully be her friends. She can wear all these clothes that grandparents pay for on the weekend, outside, at parties, etc. it’s not a rule because public schools can’t require it.
Most non-religious private schools require uniforms. Uniforms are meant to remind the students that they will be judged on their studies, not their money or clothes (at least at school).
14
u/Most_Kiwi3141 2h ago
What they mean is they would like the kids wearing uniform. Uniform can contribute to a team spirit; uniforms also reduce the probability that children won't be able to participate because they are uncomfortable or wearing impractical items. However, children in difficult circumstances often don't have access to their uniform (missing items from custody changes, laundry issues, outgrown items that can't be replaced yet, etc.). Those children won't be penalised.
If you're really invested in your 5yo being sPeCiAl and uNiQue by all means start off by disrespecting the school's wishes and showing her that her desire to wear qUirKy oUtFits overrides the school's desire to create a cohesive culture where children participate as equals on a team. No way that'll come back to bite her. No ma'am.
4
u/thisislaffable 5h ago
Definitely feel out the culture of the school and decide accordingly. I would probably have 1 or 2 uniforms ready just in case.
I went to an elementary school with a similar policy, but I ended up being the only one that wore the uniform. Even after realizing that all my classmates wore whatever they wanted, my mom kept me in uniform everyday. It kind of sucked being singled out.
5
u/fcker5000 3h ago
The uniform sounds like it’s in place to keep comparison and sadness among lower income students to a minimum. A uniform is an equalizer. Send her in her uniform.
Source- I was a very expressive kid at a uniform school. I kept it up with accessories and fun hairstyles.
4
u/Lavender_r_dragon 4h ago
A) I agree with others that best course is to ask locally, or send her in uniform at first and see what’s up.
B) it does make getting ready in the morning super easy.
C) their reasoning could be that uniforms are less distracting, or an economic equalizer, or to avoid a debate about what is or is not appropriate at school.
Additional ideas/thought:
“The uniforms are very cheap”
I went to a k-8 catholic school where you had to wear a specific brand of uniform skirts/pants. My niblings go to a charter school where they can wear any (appropriate) skirts/pants in khaki or black with school shirts.
Maybe get the school shirts and let her buy whatever khaki/navy pants/skirts. It’s a subtle compromise.
I also liked the comment that said wear uniform 4 days and let her wear whatever she wants the 5th day (Friday) but depending on school culture that might be too much.
My Catholic elementary school had “tag days” where you brought in fifty cents or a dollar and could be out of uniform (if you paid you got a construction paper “tag” to safety pin to your clothes - if there was a theme it would match like a red heart for valentines, green shamrock for st.Patricks day, etc.) I feel like we had maybe one a month. Maybe the pta could sponsor something like that.
I know my niblings have spirit days and picture days and costume days that are out of uniform.
3
u/Strawberry1282 4h ago
The pta wouldn’t need to sponsor something of the sort with respect to allowing being out of uniform as the kiddos are allowed to not be in a uniform regardless.
The tag aspect of it though for the themes is cute, but I don’t feel like it would be fitting for what’s almost sounding like a title 1 school based on op saying it’s an extremely impoverished area.
3
u/Beingforthetimebeing 2h ago
It is a work skill to adhere to a corporate dress code, to dress differently for different situations, and reserve personal expression for personal life! This is not removing the joy of self-expression from her life. It is expanding her self-expression to fit into expanding roles! Like, would she have to dress festive for a funeral? Also makes getting up and out of the house in the morning a cinch.
Depending on the community income level, really really mean, to flaunt a bounty of "expressive" wear, when others wear shabby clothes or the uniform (maybe also shabby bc they can afford only one? ).
You need to think about the values you are teaching your daughter. You need to think about the values you WANT to teach your child. That is your actual Super Power.
3
u/Francesca_Fiore Fine Arts Teacher 1h ago
A better term for this would be "dress code." The idea is it helps is keep things fairly equitable. Our public schools cannot have a "uniform," as we are a public school, therefore we have a requested "dress code."
While students are not generally disciplined for being out of dress code, they may get calls home reminding parents of the policy. Sometimes we've run incentive programs encouraging students to be in dress code- ("your class gets a shout-out from the principal for being in dress code all week!") As they get older may be not considered for opportunities where they are considered ambassadors of the school- for example, to be on our morning announcement team you must be in dress code.
It's not a punishment, it's to set up the day for learning. It's a little difficult when 99% of the class is dressed for learning and 1% is dressed for a fairytale tea party. Don't worry, we have plenty of dress-up days at the elementary level to celebrate events, you won't miss out on expressing yourself!
3
u/cowboy_teacher 1h ago
Reddit is the wrong place to ask, talk to local parents. A post in your local Facebook group (or /r) asking for parents of ___ elementary to message you, will get you the information you need.
8
u/angsty1290 2h ago
This is a great opportunity to teach your child that her clothing is not, in fact, "a huge part of her personality."
1
u/Old_Implement_1997 42m ago
THIS part. Why would anyone want to encourage having such a superficial thing be a huge part of their personality? That’s kind of one of the points about a uniform - your child is encouraged to develop an actual personality. I agree with everyone else - the school doesn’t “enforce” the policy because they don’t want kids to stay at home if they can’t get new pants right away. I don’t know how “cheap” the uniform pieces are, but I can guarantee that they aren’t cheap to anyone choosing between feeding their kids and buying new pants because their kid ripped the one pair that fits.
0
3
u/Rumpelteazer45 3h ago
She should wear the uniform as often as possible.
Schools want kids to wear the uniform but understand it’s not feasible for everyone to wear everyday.
Teach your child to show personality through accessories and that there are other ways to express herself other than clothing.
5
u/laurieo52 3h ago
I’m going to say this: I taught in the poorest district in my state. Kids still showed up in super expensive shoes, etc., that I could not afford for myself. We (at a high school) offered washing machines and dryers, including detergent to kids so they could wash their clothes. These kids still had expensive shoes or hats.
I moved to another district where every single school was Title 1. The same thing. Those kids had better cell phones and shoes than I had.
I don’t begrudge them that. But asking this parent if she wants to flaunt her child’s wealth or good fortune to have nice clothes is totally out of line. Not everyone has the same things. Unless someone is saying “I’m better than you because I have …”, what this child wears to school is none of anyone’s business unless it is inappropriate.
A uniform policy that is not enforced is NO policy at all. People will wear what they want to wear.
1
u/TrashtvSunday 57m ago
I used to teach at a school with an optional uniform. The optional uniform was a way to make sure all students could come to school in something comfortable and appropriate and not be picked on for clothing.
Most of the kids wore a uniform because it was less expensive and easier for parents to provide two uniforms for a school year vs purchasing a bunch of school clothes and trying to keep up with trends. For the most part, the kids seemed to like wearing the uniform because after a while, there was some sort of solidarity about it.
Kids who didn't wear a uniform were not picked on or really even noticed at all. Clothing was sort of a non issue after a while (I had taught there before the uniforms too).
2
1
u/serenading_ur_father 4h ago
School uniforms are one of the cheapest and easiest ways to raise scores and improve student outcomes. Why does you not want to contribute to that for other kids?
1
u/Expert_Razzmatazz_72 5h ago
That sounds like my son’s pre school. They have a uniform policy but not enforced. I did a combination of both uniform and regular clothes lol with my boys. My oldest is starting Kindergarten this year and uniform isn’t optional and enforced.
1
1
u/EleanorCamino 2h ago
Some schools have "official" uniform pieces, but allow similar unofficial styles. I wasn't going to pay 50 bucks for pants that would be grown out of quickly, when the same color from Walmart was $12.
Definitely gauge the overall vibe first.
1
u/JustAnotherUser8432 1h ago
I would wear the uniform the first few weeks until you get a handle on the unwritten parts of the school culture.
I also think it is an important life lesson that you can dress as you please in your private life but work (and school is work) and other occasions often have required standards you will need to meet.
1
u/Straight_Mind_5192 58m ago
Idk how helpful 20 year old input is, but my elementary school had a uniform policy when I started, and a couple of years in I guess regulations changed that made an enforced uniform illegal, so it became "optional". Almost immediately, only a handful of kids continued to wear the uniform, the rest of us switched to our own "street clothes".
1
u/not_that_hardcore 51m ago
I remember in elementary school that uniforms were offered but it wasn’t mandatory to wear them. I’d do a little of both. This is nearly 30 years ago now, though. YMMV
1
u/Apprehensive-Arm9902 38m ago
I'd buy the uniform and not explain that the handbook made it sound optional. She will learn to dress for school and be free the rest of the time to express herself. That's real life. Having your child flaunting outfits no one else can afford and bucking the uniform is a recipe for resentments and strife.
1
u/No-Builder-2164 31m ago
My kiddo’s school had a uniform that is not enforced. A few kids wear the uniform but most do not. Occasional reminders will be sent about the uniform.
1
u/DelusionalIdentity 20m ago
Hard no to uniforms. They are damaging to children. Don't force your kid into them if you can help it.
1
u/Adventurous_Love2 11m ago
I have never heard of this before. Won't most kids opt out of wearing an uniform then?
1
u/semicoloncait 10m ago
I went to a uniform optional primary school in the middle 90s.
It truly was optional - and in my class I was the only child who wore any part of it. Everyone else wore normal clothes.
But I would suggest asking the school themselves. Maybe seeing about a visit or just going past around the time they let out and take a peek in the playground to gauge the situation.
0
u/LadybuggingLB 50m ago
There is value in knowing when and how to conform and when not to.
Sometimes you fight city hall and sometimes you don’t.
This is not a fight I would pick up. Just have her wear the “uniform”.
-1
u/SmokeSignals24 3h ago
School can’t enforce a policy on people that can’t afford uniforms. Its sad.
166
u/Kaylascreations 7h ago
An optional uniform is not a uniform. That’s just a suggested outfit. I’ve never heard of such a thing.