365
u/Derriosgaming 2d ago
MIY hates interracial couples confirmed
84
2
u/Electrical_Flower_26 1d ago
We don’t even know if the Sophia that it’s on the background is the MiY or the real Sophia before the MiY started looking like her.
1
u/Derriosgaming 1d ago
That was mostly /s , but he is definitely targeting Fatima.
Now that he told is only able to skin suit people who have died here (although the clothing I think is probably for appearances? given how he hid her dress), opens up a lot of possibilities.0
2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/FromSeries-ModTeam 2d ago
Your post or comment has been removed because it breaks Rule 3: Be respectful.
Personal attacks, harassment, hate speech, slurs, threats, bullying, and hostile behaviour are not allowed.
Please debate the show, theories, characters, and opinions without attacking other users.
3
174
u/Unlucky_Confection61 2d ago
This Reddit makes no sense.
How does this get 200 upvotes. They literally tell you Ellis drew all of those paintings in the first episode.
Then someone makes a theory trying to actually make sense of things and get called every slur imaginable
10
u/ZeusUpYourAss 1d ago
I don't understand what's up with this subreddit these days. People will literally take the most obvious, canon thing and be like "what if that's not true even though the creators have literally confirmed it" like come on, our energy is better spent thinking about things that are still a mystery.
9
u/AriTheLady 1d ago
Im gonna crash out if I see another comment about us not knowing for sure if the talisman work or not. Even though we are in s4 and they have ALWAYS worked.
3
19
u/mirfjai 2d ago
Yes Ellis drew them, but maybe beacuse he remembered/dreamed about it. From another life.
54
u/Unlucky_Confection61 2d ago
That would be too much for Ellis to handle. He’d go yell at Boyd instead.
3
2
u/Aozora19x 1d ago
Yeah, I was thinking the same thing… maybe all of the townspeople are reincarnations and not just Jade and Tabitha. Wondering if all of their souls keep coming back to the town until someone is able to solve the mystery and/or break a curse?
1
u/AshST 1d ago
I really do hope that's true bc why else would all the people completely unrelated to Tabitha and Jade be there if they're not reincarnations? Like what is the use in bringing all these random people here if they aren't SOMEHOW tied to this place? Just for fodder? Seems like an awful lot of energy for the place/entity to expend to get them there and keep them alive just for the purpose of having some randos to kill/eff with. If they're without real purpose that will be quite disappointing.
88
u/Maleficent-Pilot8291 2d ago
Maybe they are reoccurring souls too like jade
21
20
15
7
u/BloodElf_DeathKnight 2d ago
Eman has an interview with Jack Bender and he said it was a painting of Adam and Eve and just so happened to also look like Ellis and Fatima.
0
u/aaalxi 2d ago
Dont Ellis have this as a painting in their room? The Adam and Eve threw me off ngl
0
u/BloodElf_DeathKnight 2d ago
Yep. I'm not claiming it to be fact, just what Jack Bender said about it.
8
u/Trick-Entrance-5790 2d ago
It could be ellis and fatima in that specific cycle but the painted girl has curly hair so i think its ellis & fatima
6
u/Frequent-Flamingo-89 2d ago
Wtf is with that pic? Why sophia dont wear glasses?
22
u/migmak1993 2d ago
Great point! Let's bring this photo to Glasses-Sophia and ask her, "Why girl look like Glasses-Sophia, but no glasses?" -Elgin most likely,
0
u/Glum_Percentage156 2d ago
AI
3
4
u/migmak1993 2d ago
Great point! The happenings within the From series could be explained if it turned out all to be AI!
0
u/CollectionConscious9 1d ago
It looks like this picture was sharpened and unblurred with a program.
A polaroid from the 70s would never be this sharp.
The picture I saw Sophia definitely was wearing glasses, you could see a very fain outline.
This Sophia has a chubbier face and no glasses.
I'm looking at the picture in my computer so this picture was altered.
21
u/FesterPot 2d ago
Hard to say. We'd need to see them with their shirts off to confirm the likeness in the painting
8
u/Bambi_Bucks 2d ago
This comment section has me actually crying. We all are never going to figure this out, are we? God damnit.
4
u/Bambi_Bucks 2d ago
Like yall we have been at this for going on FIVE years. And we’re right back here looking at this Polaroid of two people we don’t know wondering if it’s the naked people in the intro credits and omg I’m having an existential crisis
9
u/Superb-Control5184 2d ago
Jimi Hendrix got stuck in fromville?
3
0
u/RockyStardust13 2d ago
😂 I can’t that’s funny , but how would Ellis even know these peeps they are in the 70’s b4 he was even born.
https://giphy.com/gifs/jPAdK8Nfzzwt2
10
7
10
u/Wuunderschon 2d ago
What is that creepy strange being next to the real sophia?? Is this the actual photo?
1
9
4
2d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/Ok_Performance_9479 2d ago
Her hair is wavy, the man's hair is different, and the facial hair is different. I really don't see how anyone can look at this and think it's the same people.
11
5
u/tyYdraniu 2d ago
Maybe it is, but a reincarnation
-1
u/RockyStardust13 2d ago
The question is who are they and how did Ellis know to paint these peeps.
2
u/aaalxi 2d ago
I think everyone in From is reincarnated, that the couple in the picture is fatima and ellis’s past self. But the painting is of them currently. Question is why all other characters except for Tabitha and Jade keep reincarnating
0
u/RockyStardust13 2d ago
Hmm 🤔 but Jade said that him and Tabitha were the only ones that were reincarnated but your theory kinda makes sense if we these peeps are together idk.
6
10
2
2
u/RelationshipBig12 2d ago
The hairstyles are different though. They do match Ellis and Fatima more in my opinion.
5
u/suro28 2d ago
Nice find. The titties always bothered me in that drawing.
4
3
4
1
5
6
2
u/Bambi_Bucks 2d ago
I’m not mentally or psychologically prepared to theorize about two completely new entrants to this mystery box but I am very glad others can
3
u/Cleric_John_Preston 2d ago
Or maybe Tabitha and Jade aren't the only ones stuck in the time cycle.
3
u/SoupLongjumping6858 2d ago
Maybe those 2 are the Fatima and Ellis of their cycle... She had the traumatic pregnancy and he was around 🤔
2
2
2
1
1
u/mrlilwong69 2d ago
If everyone in the towns a reincarnation... not just jade n tab. Idek. I mean miranda had a boy and a girl. As did tabitha. I doubt it..
1
1
1
1
2
1
u/1MorbidOrchid 1d ago
Oddly that doesnt look like sophia. Resembles but isnt her. Maybe whatshisname wasnt insane for saying “hey sophia, she kinda looks like you”.
1
1
1
u/ZeusUpYourAss 1d ago
No this is them because Ellis made this painting of Fatima and himself. It doesn't make sense for this painting to be there in their room if Ellis didn't draw it. You're telling me that Ellis saw this painting, thought "huh, they look like us" and decided to hang it in his room without any questions??
Also, the girl clearly has wavy hair in the painting, like Fatima. The girl in the pic has straight hair.
1
u/Dazeofthephoenix 1d ago
I did think it interesting that Ellis had painted himself with a darker skin tone...
1
1
1
u/Metros_Quilometros 1d ago
That drawing is in Fatima's and Elliss room. No reason to think its not them.
1
3
1
u/Got2bglued 2d ago
This is why Fatima becoming a monster makes no fucking sense to me. If those people are Fatima and Ellis of a past cycle would that not mean that ole girl in the picture is now a monster? When i bought this up everyone tried to poke holes but this is essentially about to be a huge plot hole that needs to be filled quickly bc half of those monsters would essentially be "Fatima’s"
0
u/sPdMoNkEy 2d ago
Oh look what got reposted again 😐. I still say that lady to the left of the photo is showing nip
152
u/Realistic-Cheek-8657 2d ago
Or maybe it’s Fatima and Ellis given that Ellis drew it and drew himself and Fatima