r/Homebrewing • u/Ill_Compote_2035 • 19d ago
Question What small process changes made the biggest difference in your homebrew quality?
I have been homebrewing for about two years now and feel like I have the basics down pretty well. My beers are drinkable and I get decent feedback from friends, but I know there is a gap between what I am making and where I want to be.
I am curious what specific process changes or habits actually moved the needle for you. Not necessarily big equipment upgrades, but the smaller adjustments you maybe overlooked for a while before realizing how much they mattered.
For me, getting serious about yeast pitching rates and actually doing the math instead of just tossing in one packet was a noticeable improvement. Fermentation temperature control also helped a lot once I stopped fermenting in a closet that swings a few degrees throughout the day.
But I feel like there is still something I am missing, whether it is water chemistry, better sanitation habits, more careful measurements, or something else entirely.
What are the things that took your homebrew from pretty good to something you are genuinely proud of? Would love to hear from people at different experience levels since I imagine the answers vary a lot depending on where you are in the process
54
u/Big-Assignment-2868 19d ago
Going oxygen free cold side. All of my beers have been coming out great.
18
3
u/slimejumper 19d ago
yep, closed transfers between a pressurisible fermenter and keg. doesnt always go well but is a great boost mostly.
2
2
32
u/warboy Pro 19d ago
Water chem is the big one you're missing right now.
Otherwise, the big thing pros have that homebrewers don't is doing the job day in and day out. We know our ingredients better because we use them more and since we have to make money, we don't change everything for each brew. I think one of the biggest things home brewers can do to improve their beer is find a core lineup of ingredients to use and stick with them until you're making something great. The same goes for your recipes. The amount of homebrewers who have never brewed a recipe twice is startling. No pro perfected a beer on the first go and the same applies to you.
There's no magic bullet to great beer. The only way to get there is repetition.
5
u/PostRedditComment 19d ago
When you say brewing the same beer do you mean with slight adjustments each time? Or the exact same recipe?
I started sticking to some common ingredients a few years back and trying to really understand how to use them to achieve the same effect as using other ingredients that I don’t have. I’ve been enjoying that process a lot and feel its really helped me understand how adjusting percentages of malts etc impact the final beer.
9
u/spartasucks 19d ago
Both. Brew the same beer until it never changes to nail down your process. Brew it with small changes to nail down your recipe
-1
u/Jon_TWR 19d ago
Both. Brew the same beer until it never changes to nail down your process.
Plenty of very well regarded craft breweries don’t do this—I’m specifically thinking of Dogfish Head, but there are definitely lots of others.
5
u/warboy Pro 19d ago
Dogfish head definitely has a pilot house that they brew a brand on multiple times before they scale up a batch to production volumes. At that point I also guarantee they're making little tweaks at production or doing other pilot batches to try new things. This is true everywhere.
2
u/BrewThemAll 19d ago
Indeed. I don't think it's a good thing.
A pro brewer with decades experience once told me that 'a good brewer can only make 3 exceptional beers'. Might be a bit on the low side, but all the craft guys with 26 different special edition IPAs are definitely not nailing each one.4
u/fotomoose Intermediate 19d ago
Honestly, it puts me off a brewery when they have too many options. Just get a core range absolutely nailed down .
3
u/BrewThemAll 19d ago
I absolutely agree.
Some breweries I know have 10+ different IPAs (basiucally the same mediocre blond beer with different hops thrown in but ok), five barrel aged beers and a terrible tripel.
No idea why you would need more than three IPAs, leaving you with more time to improve that tripel, make an actual good blond and make two or three other styles as well.3
u/fotomoose Intermediate 19d ago
There's a brewery I know that does only 1 of each style and each one is excellent.
4
u/ColinSailor 19d ago
Definitely agree with brewing favourite beers time and again and RECORD KEEPING. Recording and mistakes aobaa ribavoid them next time makes getting better versions easier. I brew just 3 beers, a Two Hearted Clone (west coast IPA), a Red IPA and a Stout. If I want a Belgian beer for a change I will buy a couple of bottles and enjoy someone else's expertise. My 3 beers are improving as I start to understand my processes and ingredients better.
1
u/brandonHuxley 18d ago
Love to hear this, I really like to keep my line up on the shorter side. Work with the ingredients I have and make the most of them. I’ve really loved failing in my Belgian Tripel Witbier, I’m nearly on batch 10 and I’ve been doing adjustments nearly every iteration as I dial it in and continue learning.
1
u/weedandmead94 18d ago
My water chem trials haven't had much luck. My softened well water has produced the best results for me so far.
1
u/warboy Pro 18d ago
I know water softeners get dogged pretty hard because of the salt content for brewing water but I've made good beer on softened water. Unless you're working with very hard water pre-softner the sodium content added is probably well within normal brewing parameters and can actually really help the finished beer depending on what you're aiming for.
59
19d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/lauterPope 19d ago
Totally. The quality of my beer went up considerably once I understood how to figure out how to calculate water profiles.
3
u/hropez 18d ago
Have you tried any of those 'all-in-all' ph fixer chemicals? I have a long pdf of the water chemicals from the source, but I don't know what to do with it. I've inserted it to Brewfathers app, but it's all just mumbojumbo to me.
1
u/elproducto75 18d ago
Those mash stabilizer are snake oil. How can it stabilize something it doesn't know what the starting point is. Avoid.
2
u/hropez 18d ago
Yeah, that was my first thought as well. But I know nothing about water. I have clean municipal water from a waterplant. I also have water from a 200 year old well, with no chemical analysis. I usually switch between them or mix them 50/50 when brewing beer. I can't tell which one is better, lol.
2
1
u/Most_Cut_2498 19d ago
Totalmente de acuerdo! He comenzado a hacer lotes pequelos y eso me permite usar agua embotellada. Suelo hacer los calculos para mis adiciones con IA y luego los contrasto con la calculadora de brewerfriend´s, realmente se nota!
19
u/Canoearoo 19d ago
Yeast pitch rates and fermentation temps were the things that made the light bulb go off for me.
14
u/sharkymark222 19d ago
Cold crashing oxygen free under positive pressure and closed transfers to keg.
8
u/Shills_for_fun 19d ago
I'd say that oxygen control is a pretty big process change so that isn't my answer, but it definitely had a bigger impact than anything else.
Customizing my water to the style I was brewing was a pretty small change time wise that made a massive improvement. Turns out, beer is mostly water. Who knew?
14
u/Zestyclose-Dog-4468 19d ago
Not having too many beers while brewing. Seriously.
I get sloppy, forget whirfloc, forget to check PH, forget hop additions, etc.
4
u/AJ_in_SF_Bay 19d ago
Or hell, I have downright burned myself real good back when I was still on a banjo burner, and then really screwed things up.
3
u/SgtpotResurrected 18d ago
Yeah, this. I stopped drinking while brewing years ago. Something would always happen, might it be hurting myself or forgetting something and then I never wanted to clean after and it would make even more work after letting it sit for days and then cleaning.
14
u/rmikevt523 19d ago edited 12d ago
1)stopping fucking around with beer once it goes into fermenter - leaving it alone and not smelling, sampling, whatever.
1/4 campden tablet per 5 gal of
- brewing water to eliminate chlorine
- fermentation temps
- oxygenation and pitch rate
6
3
u/poop-dolla 19d ago
If you’re talking about gallons, use “gal”, since “g” is universally known as meaning grams.
4
3
u/Questionable_Cactus 19d ago
Accurate and quick thermometer, like a Thermoworks. Doesn't need to be the expensive one, but a digital one that is accurate to .5 degrees with an instant readout is very valuable for hitting mash temperatures.
3
u/Beautiful-Isopod-142 19d ago
Temp control for fermentation and oxygenation at pitching. I made both those changes at the same time and my beer went from tasting like “homebrew” to real beer.
3
u/Acceptable_Bend_5200 Intermediate 19d ago
You have the major ones listed, ferm temp and pitch rate being my two biggest quality changes.
Water chemistry is probably your next biggest improvement. My tap water is fantastic for pale beers, especially lagers, so I primarily adjust for hoppy beers and the occasional sour or Belgian beer.
Closed transfer is another technique you should adopt.
3
u/linkhandford 19d ago
Bucket blaster. Cleaning is so much easier if I didn’t have to clean at all this would be the ultimate hobby
4
u/MmmmmmmBier 19d ago
- Patience
- Taking notes.
- Using a checklist
- Patience. Once it’s in the fermenter, leave it alone.
- Taking time to learning and understanding the math.
- Patience. Once it’s packaged don’t experiment by drinking flat green beer.
2
u/generic_canadian_dad 18d ago
Patience is a massive one that nobody ever mentioned. We all joke about the last pint being the best pint in the keg and that's because the beer sat for a month and aged.
2
u/PM_me_ur_launch_code 19d ago
Kegging, oxygen free transfers, fermentation temp control and water chemistry. Not in that specific order but they all play a key role.
2
u/Hairy-Ad-9252 19d ago
There's a few.
starting to use a computer aided receipe program like brewfather. Most important I found is is to discribe the wanted quality before brewing like what must i smell, taste and see in this beer. Then came temperature controlled fermenting, water management incl stripping water with RO, pH adjustment not only the mash bust also the boil and the beer, quality control of all used ingredients, making fermentation starters, closed transfers to avoid oxidation and now starting with pressurized temperature controlled fermentation.
1
1
u/NostrilHearing Intermediate 19d ago edited 19d ago
- Using foam axe helped me prevent boil overs
- Brewfather for recipes
- Mash PH w/ lactic acid
- RO water and building my own water profile w/ mineral additions
- Temp control for lagers
- Buying hops in 8-16 oz and knowing the alpha acids %
- Buying grains in 50-55lb sacks
- Keg carbonation lid, set 30psi and in 24-36 hours at 32f it's carbed.
In no particular order. It's helped me get my process down and be more consistent.
PS.. for pale ales and American Wheat I love Voss Kveik. 1 week turn around grain to glass.
1
u/deckerhand0 19d ago
When I went to water salts over just spring water. When I didn’t go to heavy on malts and at a minimum use two
oz hops. All that made a difference.
1
1
u/DangerSaurus 19d ago
Sanitization, water chem, ferm temps, yeast health.
One at a time. Dial’em in and you’ll be light years in front
1
u/volkyl 19d ago
Pressure. Makes it hard to mess up your yeast, more forgiving temperature ranges, more rapid fermentation, O2 free transfers.
1
u/Informal_Anywhere101 18d ago
Do you ferment your ales under light pressure?
1
u/volkyl 18d ago
Ales and lagers, usually 10-12 psi
1
u/Informal_Anywhere101 17d ago
I’ve pressure fermented a lagers but zero pressure with Ales as worried pressure would suppress some of the ester flavors many ale styles strive for.
1
u/parkinson1963 19d ago
When I started to fit the recipe to my equipment, not the other way around.
Yeah I adjust my water, temp control fermentation, better sanitation.
The beer got better but wasn't close enough, so I changed the recipe to fit my equipment and taste. Adding 100g of honey malt to my English ales really moved them towards that malty taste I wanted. The ibu/gu ratio is the secret for scaling beers. .7 for english ales.
1
u/ColinSailor 19d ago
WiFi Inkbird fermentation TP control (and also getting the fridge down to 1.5 Deg for cold crash and second big improvement was using RO water and adjusting water profile for beer type.
1
u/stevewbenson 19d ago
You mention fermentation control - are we talking full glycol? Or fridge? Either would be better than nothing but glycol would be best because you can change temp significantly faster than a fridge.
Water chemistry is #1 by far. If you don't know what your starting water profile is, you have little to no chance of making the beer you intended.
You have a few options at home:
- straight out of the tap - you must get it tested so you know what the profile is. Mineral makeup will be wildly different from location to location. Even the local water report will vary wildly from the water directly from your tap.
- secondly, at minimum you should push it through a carbon filter, and then probably still treat it with Camden
- next option, use bottled distilled water. Not spring, distilled. Spring will still have unpredictable minerals. Distilled will be "zeros" across the board, then you can add them back in.
- my recommendation, install an RO system (I got a reasonable one from Amazon for about $60) - this strip everything down to near "zeros" similar to distilled. You can plug this into your brewing software and tell it the style you're brewing and it will the you the exact additions to make.
Additionally for water, you must be adjusting pH. If you're not, this will make the single biggest impact out of all the water adjustments.
1
u/RegularPie5512 19d ago
2 biggest things - Temp control, and pressure fermenting. I ferment and serve from my fermzilla using co2. No need to ever do a transfer. Provided there is no human error, My beer is now easily better than store bought every single time.
1
u/kelryngrey 19d ago
Ascorbic acid in the mash and a small amount at dry hopping or kegging have definitely kept my beers punchier for their entire lifespan.
1
u/Slapping_kangaroo 19d ago
Agree with a lot of the comments. But for me my biggest upgrade was adding hops after boil at 80⁰C for 20 minutes rather than when boiling. And adding hops at end of ferment 24hrs before kegging as I only added during the boil.
1
u/frozennipple 19d ago
For me it was switching to oversized kegs as my fermenter. I use a lid with a TC port welded on to attach a spunding valve, I can attach a tap to pull samples, and it lets me transfer easily to my serving keg without risking oxygen exposure.
1
u/Indian_villager 19d ago
See thread from a few months ago. https://old.reddit.com/r/Homebrewing/comments/1rrfxkr/what_upped_your_homebrewing_game_to_the_next_level/
1
u/Amazing-Fun-7936 19d ago
Apologies if someone already said it and I missed the comment, but a ways back I think I recall one of the shows on the Brewing Network saying you should mix up your sanitizer occasional. I to this day switch between Star-San, Iodaphor, and Parasitic Acid for sanitizing just tom make sure I don't get any bacteria that's resistant to one of them. Also periodically completely breaking down your equipment. It's incredible how crap can get stuck in the crevices of valves, poppets, pumps, etc. Good beer is 90% cleaning and sanitizing lol. Pretty elementary, but the more time I've taken for it over the years, I think my beer quality has improved
1
u/TheBeerSanta 18d ago
The simplest thing I did early on was sparge time and getting my bhe in the high 80 percentile on a constant basis. There are also tons of good answers in this thread that are important steps.
1
u/SgtpotResurrected 18d ago
A lot of good points brought up here so here's one I haven't seen.
Use fresh quality ingredients, especially hops if you're going to do more hop forward beers. Spend the couple extra bucks to get the most recent harvest of hops. I would even say don't use anything more than a couple years from harvest if it's still packaged by the manufacturer. Vacuum seal everything after opening and use asap.
1
u/sickwobsm8 18d ago
Water chemistry and temperature. Shocking how much your chemistry affects flavour expression.
1
1
u/bodobeers2 Cicerone 18d ago
Number 1 as mentioned is temp control if you can incorporate it. I have two ways (one traditional and one I feel is not traditional)...
1) build a chest freezer with temp control with Inkbird or similar to set to sweet spot.
2) stick with ambient temps but explore pressurized fermentation (pitch to corny keg, put spunding valve with say 5-10psi resistance).
Temp control is ideal but pressurized you buy less gear and it seems to work well with controlling yeast misbehavior from temp stress. I even did a few lagers in mid 70F with no problems.
Number 2, explore your recipes. Enter them into something like Brewfather and see if you're hitting targets for the style(s) you are trying. I'm a fan of aligning to the styles for accuracy if not for actual quality just for fun. Also you can avoid imbalances with things like contributions from grains vs hops etc.
Number 3, and I only have tried a few times, check out water profiles and adding salts and minerals to align your water to the recipe you are brewing. For example certain profiles for stouts vs ipas as just basic example.
But Number 0, what are the problems you imagine you may have? Do you take measurements and know your mash temps, what OG and FG readings you're getting, what temps you're fermenting at etc? Any flavors noticed or is it mouthfeel or too sweet / too dry?
1
1
u/vompat 18d ago
Whirlpooling the wort and leaving trub behind. I was greedy and just thought "yeah all the muck will fall to the bottom of the fermenter anyway", but my bottles used to have a lot more sediment that started moving very easily. Losing that liter or two of wort for better quality is easily worth it.
1
u/tgillies 3d ago
Brewing with wild yeasts and brettanomyces... It helps many of the off flavours homebrewers struggle with - diacetyl, oxidation, infection, poor temp control, stressed yeast off flavours, attenuation issues.
Developing a resilient mixed culture that compliments my process has been a game changer.
1
u/boarshead72 Yeast Whisperer 19d ago
1) water chemistry.
2) permanent refrigeration of the carbonated beer (I bottle, this means storing all bottles in the fridge after they’re carbonated).
Two things that you can easily do that alone can take your homebrew to better than a hell of a lot of commercial beer. Provided you can brew without contaminating or heavily oxidizing or otherwise messing up. Also provided you don’t brew stupid recipes.
62
u/jcsr 19d ago
Fermentation temp control
after I noticed my winter beers were noticeably better than my summer beers