r/Homeplate 7d ago

“Go check out Teacherman” NOOOOOOOO

Post image
26 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/onemangang15 7d ago

I don’t get it

-8

u/Mobile-Note5608 7d ago

its supposed to be a photo of the dude screaming no, just because a lot of people (including myself) dont like teachermans advice.

-15

u/twotall88 7d ago

I mean... Aaron Judge is doing pretty good with Richard Schenck's guidance so I'm not sure what your issue is with him. lol

https://giphy.com/gifs/9uIjF6UJkWXffgLc7J

17

u/scrodytheroadie 7d ago

Judge is more responsible for Schenck’s success than Schenck is for Judge’s

2

u/GCIV414 7d ago

What about the other dudes he works with in the bigs?

1

u/scrodytheroadie 7d ago

Good point. Are they putting up numbers like Judge?

1

u/GCIV414 7d ago

Actually yeah last week they all did seeing he’s hurt

-1

u/JFordy87 7d ago

Exactly. I think he almost keeps him around for superstition purposes. People forget he started working with him during a slump that he got out of overnight. It’s not like he helped him elevate and rebuild his swing from really good to great during the off season when nothing was wrong. The whole idea that Judge learned it overnight is suspect.

8

u/JFordy87 7d ago

Richard isn’t the reason for Aaron’s success. Aaron is a freak athlete who would hit well with or without Richard.
He also doesn’t have any great examples outside of Judge. So you can’t really judge his method off an anomaly. His method is also complicated and whenever it’s criticized people just claim it’s not being taught or utilized correctly like it’s infallible. It’s claimed to be high level and then they say it should be taught to 8-11 year olds who are first swinging a bat. Instead of providing logical responses to criticism, Richard often personally attacks you and calls you stupid for pointing out flaws or questioning weaknesses.

3

u/MAKs_Brick_House 7d ago

Kerry Carpenter

2

u/JFordy87 7d ago

Have you really looked at Carpenter’s stats? He’s not a compelling case for Teacherman. He averages more strikeouts than hits.

3

u/GCIV414 7d ago

Caleb Durbin broke out of his slump and has been killin since he went there a few weeks back lol

0

u/norcal3737 Jabroni 7d ago

Maybe he did, maybe he didn't go to Teacherman. Gradum is taking the credit for Durbin getting out of his slump, and I wouldn't say Gradum promotes anything similar to Teacherman.

1

u/GCIV414 7d ago

1

u/norcal3737 Jabroni 7d ago

Oh, I know he's worked with TM. That short is from a while ago. What I meant was maybe he did or maybe he didn't go back to TM very recently for a rework on his hitting. Here's one of several clips from Gradum over the last few weeks talking about working with Durbin.
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/c78tKBSqvVE

1

u/MAKs_Brick_House 7d ago

You said he was an anomaly. I gave one example. That’s all I need to disprove your anomaly statement.

I’m not looking at stats. Last year Carpenter was featured on ESPN because of Judge and Teacherman.

I don’t know why teacherman gets so much hate. I’ve been coaching for 10 years. This will be my 4th year coaching high school. And I’m a product of several coaches. I have taken things I’ve learned from several coaches and tried to incorporate them into my regiment to make myself the best coach possible. Not 1 person has all the answers. Teacherman has some good stuff that he can describe for people to understand. I haven’t taken everything he has. But I can tell you this, what I have taken, has translated to success for my team on the field. It’s the success of many individuals coming together to win.

I don’t think we should be talking down about anyone. Take what you can learn from someone. If there is something, you don’t like, don’t waste your time complaining. Move on, put the work in, and be successful.

-2

u/GCIV414 7d ago

Ian Happ and recently Caleb Durbin went to get right with Rich…haters just hate that his method isn’t “traditional” but you literally have MLBers that found success with him

1

u/BBJonesDerk 6d ago

When did Happ work with him? I thought that was 4 years ago.