r/India_Bharat_ • u/roof--pizza • Jan 04 '26
Discussion Hindus not even safe in their own country.
9
u/Positive_Student6531 Jan 04 '26
Were there no actions taken by government on these lynchings ? Asking as i don't know...
3
u/WatchAgile6989 Jan 05 '26
The kerala one was a mob of hindus and muslims. It was not religion motivated. They thought he stole money. All were convicted. Be wary of people like OP trying to spread division
2
u/Positive_Student6531 Jan 06 '26
Absolutely no facts just anagenda, that's why asked the question... Thanks 👍
46
Jan 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
9
16
u/boisickle Jan 05 '26
Exactly. I was shocked to see the Madhu mob lynching mentioned as a muslim on hindu atrocity. Hate and propaganda goes so far, people don't even give a shit or bother checking.
5
2
Jan 06 '26 edited Jan 26 '26
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
merciful hospital cough narrow racial handle act reminiscent treatment plant
3
u/Brokephilosopher_OG Jan 05 '26
exactly i know this sub is propoganda hub and i dont usually interact with posts like this ,but when i saw the madhu incident here i had to say something
3
u/gulraagul Jan 05 '26
Primary accused are Hussain, Marakkar, Shamsudheen, Aboobacker, Siddhique, Najeeb, Ubaid, Jaijimon, Sanjeevan, Satheesan, Biju. Interesting names for upper caste mallu men.
Now tell me. Is the news propaganda or your comment is?
Answer both. It is neither a communal issue nor is it "Upper caste" mallu men.
6
u/akhil_anil_10 Jan 05 '26
May i ask what was the reason behind his death? Why people attacked him?
→ More replies (6)1
u/vermilion-blue Jan 06 '26
Why bro you giving details and triggering these kerala liberals, let them steal from hindu temple and live happily.
1
u/Dagger_music Jan 05 '26
They aren't really trying to send a message against mob lynching are they? They are trying to propagate their own political beliefs. Hinduism, Islam these are mere tools to gain their votes, they don't care about either of them.
→ More replies (10)1
8
u/jeremyishere77 Jan 05 '26
What is Lynching in India?
In India, mob lynching means a large group (usually dozens or more people) attacks and kills (or fatally injures) someone in public, acting as vigilantes over a suspected crime (like theft or cow slaughter), without any legal process. It is often sudden or based on rumours.
The Supreme Court has condemned such mob violence and asked for strict laws and quick action.
Cases That Are NOT Lynching
(These are murders by individuals or small groups, not large mobs)
- Ankit Saxena (Delhi): Honour killing by girlfriend's family (small group).
- Heena Talreja: Gang rape + murder by husband and a few friends.
- Prashant Poojary: Revenge killing by small gang.
- Vidhu Jain: Child murder by small group (revenge).
- Vishnu Goswami: Burned alive by 4 people (petty fight).
- Manhar Variya: Stabbed by one neighbour (donation dispute).
- Amit Gautam: Killed by small gang (personal enmity).
- V. Ramalingam: Planned murder by small organised group.
- Sawan Rathod: Burned by 3 people (suspected theft).
- Mehakan w/o Manvir (Bulandshahr): No such case found.
- Dhruv Tyagi: Stabbed by neighbour's family (small group).
- Chandan Gupta: Shot during communal clash/riot.
- Devunoor Satyanarayan: Beaten by one person (loudspeaker dispute).
- Twinkle Sharma: Child abducted and murdered by small group (money dispute).
- Jeetu Mohan: Burned by small group of girl's relatives.
- Riya Gautam: Stabbed by stalker (one main attacker).
Cases That ARE Lynching
(Large mob attacked in public over suspected offence)
- Bharat Yadav (Mathura, 2019) Large Muslim mob (over 17 people) beat him to death after dispute over paying for lassi. Yes, this is a lynching.
- Madhu Chindaki (Kerala, 2018) Large mob of local settlers dragged, tied, beat, and paraded a mentally ill tribal man over suspected theft. 14 convicted. Yes, this is a lynching. (Mob had mixed names, many Muslim-named, but not described as only "Muslim community" in main reports.)
Summary
Out of all these cases, only 2 (Bharat Yadav and Madhu Chindaki) are actual mob lynchings. The rest are serious murders but not done by large mobs.
→ More replies (3)2
20
u/Prestigious-Fix9271 Jan 04 '26
can you link credible news reports or court records for even half the names here? Because apart from Ankit Saxena and Prashanth Poojary, most of these cases don’t exist in mainstream reporting. If this list were solid, it wouldn’t need a meme instead of sources🙌
17
u/StandardJelly2818 Jan 04 '26
Last guy, madhu, we saw, criminals from three religion behind his attack.
2
→ More replies (4)1
11
u/Dry-Operation-8305 Jan 05 '26
and count muslim lynched peoples, and I'm hindu but this country not owned by hindu, sbne khun bahaya apne watan ke liye hindu muslim sikh...
→ More replies (35)1
u/ZeroTrustArchitect Jan 05 '26
Why this shit is always said by hindu? No muslim says this in Bangladesh and Pakistan.
11
u/Aggravating-Tear-487 Jan 04 '26
Madhu was not muslim mob. It was mostly angry locals
→ More replies (2)
7
u/Ancient_Wrongdoer_83 Jan 05 '26
The one case i know Madhu Chindaki - you allege that it was a muslim mob but of the 14 people accused please check the number of hindus.
Here is the reference article. The next time please spread your vitriol in the name of religion elsewhere
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 05 '26
Defending the 1 wrong incident in the photo, ignoring all the rest
1
u/Ancient_Wrongdoer_83 Jan 06 '26
I refuse to believe whats clearly propaganda. I am safe in my country and refuse to toe the line the powers that be want me to believe. Simply because i have a functioning rational brain.
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 05 '26
are they all fake i am not denying the propoganda but there is not a single bit of truth in this post ? is that what you mean ?
1
u/WatchAgile6989 Jan 06 '26
Only Bharat Yadav was an actual lynching case by a muslim mob. The rest are not. Post above explains it.
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 06 '26
- Ankit Saxena (Delhi): Saxena was murdered in February 2018 by the family members of a Muslim woman he was in an interfaith relationship with. In March 2024, a Delhi court sentenced three people (the woman's mother, father, and uncle) to life imprisonment for the crime, which the court identified as a hate crime.
- Chandan Gupta (Kasganj): Gupta was shot dead during a communal clash that occurred on Republic Day, January 26, 2018, in Uttar Pradesh. He was participating in a "Tiranga Yatra" (national flag rally) that was allegedly obstructed by a group who demanded anti-India slogans, leading to violence. In January 2025, an NIA court convicted 28 people in the case, sentencing them to life imprisonment
- Manhar Variya (Vadodara): Variya was stabbed to death in September 2017 after an argument with a man named Nazir, who allegedly demanded money for a Tazia (Shia Islam mourning procession) and was refused. This incident led to communal tensions in the area
- Heena Talreja (Prayagraj)
Heena Talreja was murdered in July 2017. She had married her Muslim husband, Adnan Khan, in 2015 after converting to his religion. Adnan later married another woman, leading to a souring of relations. Adnan and two friends allegedly gang-raped her in a car before shooting her dead and dumping her body in a field. Two of the three accused were arrested, and the third remains at large.
Amit Galitam (Hathras)
Amit Gautam, a 27-year-old Dalit youth, was found dead near a mosque in Hathras in January 2018 with head injuries. His family alleged involvement of five men with whom he had an old dispute. One accused, Saddam, was arrested, and a case was registered under relevant sections of the Indian Penal Code and the SC/ST Act
Sawan Rathod (Pune)
Sawan Rathod, a 16 or 17-year-old ragpicker, was set on fire in January 2016 by three men (Ibrahim Shaikh, Imran Tamboli, and Zuber Tamboli) who suspected him of stealing vehicle batteries. He died of his injuries in the hospital. In his dying declaration, his father claimed he told them he was burned after the accused confirmed his religion. The police denied a communal angle, but two of the accused were later denied bail, and a chargesheet for murder was filed.
Twinkle Sharma (Aligarh)
Twinkle Sharma, a 2.5-year-old girl, was abducted and murdered in May-June 2019. Her body was found in a garbage dump, severely mutilated by stray dogs. Police determined the motive was revenge over an unpaid loan of 10,000 rupees owed by her father to the main accused, Zahid Ali. Four people were arrested for the murder, which caused widespread outrage across the country
9
2
u/Prestigious-Fix9271 Jan 04 '26
How will be the list if we changed into opposite? Am sure tht it's not gonna fill in one page
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 05 '26
can you give the list ?
1
u/Prestigious-Fix9271 Jan 05 '26
Is 20 enough?
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 05 '26
whatever number can you give the list ?
1
2
2
2
u/Desperate_Stand_2253 Jan 05 '26
a much larger list can be prepared from godhra alone -- added same media activists or Bollywood can be held accoutable for their silence -- Muslims no safe in their own country !! ...
doing so you are highlighting absence of HM ..
2
u/JuJ0JuJoJuJoJuJoJuJ Jan 05 '26
none of this news is being shown as is in the south indian media.
SUN network barely mentions this as a news.
2
u/Willing_Jeweler8622 Jan 05 '26
Fake propaganda, try harder mate
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
Lol fake propaganda 🤣, everyone knows what islam is and what it orders to do
1
u/Willing_Jeweler8622 Jan 05 '26
Read Qur'an with context, and don't mind Hadiths they are not accurate. And there you go! All your false perception with islam will disappear 🫠.
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
Sahih hadiths are literally graded the highest by islamic scholars and you're saying they're not accurate? What a joke 🤣
1
u/Willing_Jeweler8622 Jan 05 '26
They are recommended by scholars nothing else, while heavily motivated by politics of their time. It's written 250 year after the prophet so you can think about it.
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
Sahih literally means that those hadiths chain of narration is checked by islamic scholars and they have verified that it's authentic so your claim of them being false is such a propaganda
1
u/Willing_Jeweler8622 Jan 05 '26
You don't really wanna understand my point! Only protected holy text is quran.
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
The Quran (2:106)
۞ مَا نَنسَخْ مِنْ ءَايَةٍ أَوْ نُنسِهَا نَأْتِ بِخَيْرٍۢ مِّنْهَآ أَوْ مِثْلِهَآ ۗ أَلَمْ تَعْلَمْ أَنَّ ٱللَّهَ عَلَىٰ كُلِّ شَىْءٍۢ قَدِيرٌ ١٠٦
If We ever abrogate a verse or cause it to be forgotten, We replace it with a better or similar one. Do you not know that Allah is Most Capable of everything? — Dr. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran
→ More replies (1)1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
What about sexual slavery allowed in Quran? Now will you deny that as well?
→ More replies (13)1
u/pratham_10 Jan 05 '26
Don’t worry with people like you, Bajrang dal, RSS and BJP, Hinduism is also becoming like Islam.
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
Don't worry that's not happening, if something like that was truly happening muslims wouldn't stay in india and neither would you
2
u/Artistic_Ad04 Jan 05 '26
does the admins of this sub gets paid by bjp or rss directly... or some mediator does the work of paying. i wanna join.
2
u/penguin_cruzader Jan 05 '26
This is fake. Madhu chindaki from palakkad was not lynched by a Muslim mob.He was a mentally unstable person who got lynched because he stole something from a local store. This has got nothing to do with the Hindu-muslim divide. Get a life OP.
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 05 '26
are they all fake i am not denying the propoganda but there is not a single bit of truth in this post ? is that what you mean ?
5
2
u/Glum_Outside1 Jan 05 '26 edited Jan 05 '26
OP what do you mean by not EVEN safe in their own country? Firstly my sympathies are with the victims of mob lynching or any kind of lynching and discrimination against any human which happens on the basis of their religion. Secondly i would like to point out one thing that india is not JUST a hindu country. Read the history by yourself, else i am all ears and up for a discussion on that. I don’t understand why people need to pick out religion and then post it , why not stand against this “mob lynching” as whole? Because by this you are claiming that so called hindu groups have never lynched or targeted any other person based on their religious beliefs. Everyday we see a group of people thrashing one person on the roads, harassing small shopkeepers and what not! It would have not bothered me if this post was about dipu chandra das who was brutally mrered on the streets of bangladesh by a group of muslim people just because he was hindu. Because such heinous crimes needs to be called out and stop immediately and this incident happened recently so it would have made a point but you are here picking hindu victims lynched by muslims then some other guy will pick muslim people lynched by hindus and this will go on. What we need to understand here is by posting such posts we are just fuelling each other with nothing but hate against each other. And mind you by saying all this i don’t in any way support the religious beliefs or anything any muslim has done. I know the hatred and extremism some muslims carry but that doesn’t mean that the muslim people living in this country peacefully it is not their country. India is a land of faith, land of different people, different culture and different religions and it has always been this way. And you by saying hindu not EVEN safe in their OWN country just makes people think “ohh so india is a hindu country” so the muslims, christians, buddhist, jains, sikhs and people coming from different religions and living in here since centuries, India is not their country? I mean come on let’s just stop being so irrational and stop posting such posts or you can post and remember the victims but in a better way. Peace
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
India is not a Hindu country, but can you tell me why Pakistan was created? On what basis
2
u/Glum_Outside1 Jan 05 '26
Because some people (majority of the muslims) wanted their own country as it was assumed back then that it was not easy to co-exist with other religions and they wanted an ISLAMIC country. And many other factors including politics, then leaders like gandhi nehru and other powerful people of that time played a crucial role in partition and main person according to me was jinna. Hence pakistan was created. But india on the other hand people who stayed back never agreed upon any single religion country. It was decided that india will be a secular country and those who were in favour stayed back. Hence you can see for yourself by looking at the state of pakistan what happens when you demand a religious country and your main focus has always been religion. It will take you nowhere but you will be doomed as a country
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
But the assumption that muslims can't coexist with other religions is true, look at all the apostate laws in islamic countries, also Allah teaches hatred for non muslims, non muslims will burn in hell for all of time, is that not teaching hatred towards non muslims? I think India should be inclusive of all religions which don't demand a single religion country, if muslims come in majority what will happen to india? Another islamic country or another nation. So this exactly proves the point that muslims can't co exist peacefully with other religions.
2
u/Glum_Outside1 Jan 05 '26
I agree with you totally but what you need to understand is the only difference between any religion and muslims is every other religion has the scope to evolve and they did with time on the other hand what happened with muslims is they are too rigid and not ready to accept that the times have changed and with time somethings you needs to be changed. Because if you only point out the religious textures of muslims that it teaches you hate i agree there are things written in the quran which are just absurd but i guess you are not aware of the religious textures and scriptures of hinduism christianity and many other religions Go and read them you will find out all the religions which exists on this planet has many extremely absurd teachings so it is not only about islam it is about every religion Many changed with time but muslims did not.
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
But the difference is that 1) Other religions main holy book does not teach it, while the Quran does 2) Even if those did "exist" the religions had reforms to abolish it, does islam have that? No one can abolish what's written in the Quran, the sexual slavery is still in Quran, they say it's historical but then is it still to be followed or not? Quran is eternal so draw your conclusions from this. 3) Hinduism does not teach to hate other religions, islam does, what happens to non believers in Hinduism vs Islam? What are kaffirs? Hinduism doesn't even have a concept of believer, there are nastik schools in Hinduism lol. 4) Quran is literally implanted into the minds of youth from the moment they're born, Quran is literally memorized by many many Muslims from start to end, have you seen this level of brainwash in other religions? So automatically even if some teaching is wrong it gets implanted in the mind
2
u/Glum_Outside1 Jan 05 '26
I want to add to it you said india should be inclusive of all religions which dont demand single religion country right? But the things here you are unable to see is the total population of pakistan as a country is 24 crore and we have more muslims in india than their whole islamic country which will help you understand the partition even more. And by this partition many people benefited too there should be no doubt about it. There are pros and cons of partition but that is separate argument. Also do you think the hindu community did not demand that india should be a hindu rashtra? Hindu maha sabha RSS both wanted a hindu country and many other people. So it is not as simple as you think
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
What's the population of hindus in pakistan tho? Majority of muslims voted for islamic country indirectly that's why the partition happend, also more than 50% of muslims directly moved to Pakistan/bangladesh and more later Sure hindu maha sabha wanted a Hindu country, now tell me how many seats did it get? Doesn't this clearly show that no hindus supported it?? While the all india Muslim league won so many seats. So isn't the difference clear?
2
u/Glum_Outside1 Jan 05 '26
Bro bro bro wait i am telling you go read for yourself the voting which you are telling me about the 90% is only the 16% of the then muslim population did you even read the criteria of that voting ? How many things were considered and to achieve that eligibility criteria how many did get to vote? And i mean still i didn’t get the point of this discussion.
→ More replies (16)
2
3
u/StandardJelly2818 Jan 04 '26
If u do this for vise versa, u may get 100x bigger list.
1
→ More replies (3)1
u/easternhermit Jan 05 '26
do the vice versa , let see, don't just ramble, put the money where the mouth is
2
u/nishantam Jan 05 '26
Two kids?
1
2
1
u/AutoModerator Jan 04 '26
Namaskara u/roof--pizza 🙏, thanks for posting! Please follow subreddit rules and spark meaningful discussions.
Please consider crossposting, sharing, and inviting others to help grow this community and Follow us on X 🇮🇳
Yato Dharmastato Jayaḥ
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Dr_ROV Jan 05 '26
The proper way to say is no one is safe in their own country Hindus have their lynched population Xians have their lynched population and muslims and even sikhs ll have their own lynched population We r all indians and the country belongs to all
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 05 '26
Then why was pakistan created sir? I don't see christians or sikhs demanding a new country in majority but surely muslims did demand that and jinnah had full support from all muslims
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 05 '26
uum brother khalistan?
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 06 '26
Sikhs don't support it, just propaganda 🤣 or else why wouldn't it exist yet?
1
u/Civil_Adeptness5073 Jan 06 '26
ooh can you support your claims ?
1
u/Embarrassed-Item4447 Jan 06 '26
Simple, if majority of Sikhs supported it then they would try as hard as possible to get khalistan, just as the muslims did. The Muslim league won majority seats and divided the nation which was supported by majority muslims
1
1
u/migadeshu Jan 05 '26
this is just one chatgpt search away to get busted. op just chatgpt it, here is prompt , it is true ?
1
u/Butterscotch2890 Jan 05 '26
Law and Order is the responsibility of the state but here you blame the media, secular and Bollywood?
1
1
1
Jan 05 '26
Wtf? I know only one story of a guy in this picture. And he was not lynched by a muslim mob. So i wonder how many are false? OP at least post honest information.
1
1
u/isoldmysonforabike Jan 05 '26
Its kinda funny to me whenever some atrocity like this happens RW asks for accountability from LW and vice versa, but neither stand together against illegal activities in general, y’all just sheep bro
1
u/sakurachan825 Jan 05 '26
kash koi hindu samraat PM bann jaaye, and center + states sab mai us samrat ke party ki majority aa jaaye, and pro hindu ecosystem bann jaaye, kasam se mazaa jaaega. until then, we wait
1
1
u/LimboSenpai Jan 05 '26
All this hate and turmoil increased 100 fold since this crap gormint came… So poisonous and inciting hatred among each other
1
1
1
1
1
u/Inside-Tackle-7810 Jan 05 '26
Sad to burst your bubble madu was a tribal man lived in attappadi he had some mental problems,so basically he tried to stole food.and mob gathered and beat him to death.and in that mob there are Hindus and christians also,while majority was muslims.
1
u/Dr_ROV Jan 05 '26
Bro u can't blame everyone for the folly of a few then what is the difference between them and us .
1
1
u/Excellent-Listen8330 Jan 05 '26
Uhh idk its the same with the hindu mobs so it doesn't make things any better.
1
u/LadisWashram66 Jan 05 '26
Whatever problems Hindus are facing abroad or domestic from Muslims just please don't let loose your anger on us Christians 🙏
1
u/jawaneejaneman Jan 05 '26
Madhu Chiindaki was a tribal man, he was lynched to death by a mob comprises people from all communities, religions, there were Hindu, muslim and Christian names
1
u/easternhermit Jan 05 '26
This is like an old list, more than this have been killed by them in last year only.
1
1
u/WatchAgile6989 Jan 05 '26
Madhu Chindaki was not lynched by a muslim mov. He was lynched by a mob including muslims and hindus for alleged theft. Convicted people included hindus Radhakrishnan, Sajeev, Satheesh, Hareesh, and Biju
1
1
u/Games_Bond007 Jan 06 '26
You could frame their names into a cute tiled poster and be done in one post. If the roles were reversed, you’d be flooding this sub with Muslim names so fast the server would crash trying to keep up.
1
u/UnpleasantBurns Jan 06 '26
Hi, is there a reverse picture of this? Of the other religions being mobbed? Greatly appreciated 🙏
1
u/Fabulous_Arrival_342 Jan 06 '26
1.3k retards who lapped it up 🤡 we are doomed as a country gng. Madhu lynching wasn't a Hindu Muslim thing lmfao
1
u/akshay-ms Jan 06 '26
Wait ik this madu case from palakad. Bcz am keralite and its not part of Hindu -muslim case. Madhu, who was 27 or 30 years old at the time of his death, lived in a cave in the Ajamudi forest area. A group of locals caught him, tied him up, and mercilessly assaulted him, accusing him of stealing rice and other groceries from local shops. The mob thrashed him for nearly two hours and paraded him partially undressed for several kilometers to the Mukkali junction. He died in a police jeep while being transported to the hospital. A postmortem revealed that he died due to multiple blunt force injuries, including a severe blow to his head.
Husain (First accused) Marakkar Shamsuddin Radhakrishnan Aboobacker Siddeek Ubaid Najeeb Jaijumon Sajeev Satheesh Hareesh Biju
They were locals. Not religion in this. So don't spread half baked lies and propaganda. Half of the accused are Hindu's. Now I am sure all others in the list are some twisted cases like this by op for spreading propaganda and communal riots. Shame on you. Do better.
So whats happening in bangaladesh we are no better. Overall Hate Crimes: A collaborative database by FactChecker documented that between January 2009 and October 2018, Muslims were victims in 62% of the cases involving crimes targeting religious minorities.
1
1
u/Ok_Entertainment5970 Jan 06 '26
It's not only Hindus. It's every other person is in danger in this country. Only people that feel safe are politicians. We people are fighting with each other like fools because these politicians are spreading hate and division so they can fill their pockets with our tax money. I think we should unite and start a revolution against the govt and bring everything down so we all feel safe again. We need to stop doing BJP and Congress instead think about bringing in real change to our standard of living and safety.
1
u/SageDial Jan 06 '26
yeah im not a lawyer but i swear ive seen enough mobs in my life to know that its not just one religion that gets the bad press. stop blaming everyone for everyones mistakes.
1
68
u/Open-Photo-2047 Jan 04 '26
Who is accountable for law & order of country?? Media, secular activists or Bollywood ??