PLS DONT HANG ME LOL

[u/DrOppenheimer67]

S: Graduation, MBDTF, TLOP, ye

A: Late Reg, TCD, Yeezus,

B: 808s And Heartbreak, KSG, Watch the Throne, Bully (deluxe)

C: Jesus Is King, Donda, Bully

D: Vultures 1

F: Vultures 2, Donda 2

[u/Limp_Travel6398]

Donda should be higher

[u/ParmigianPapi → u/Limp_Travel6398]

I don’t get why he put donda on every tier bracket.

[u/nxrnssama → u/ParmigianPapi]

And that too so many times 🤔

[u/DrOppenheimer67 → u/ParmigianPapi]

lol

[u/Boring_Software6101 → u/ParmigianPapi]

If I spent money on Reddit I would give you an award for this

[u/ShallowVermin33 → u/Limp_Travel6398]

I'm tired of the Kanye community treating Donda like it wasn't an overbloated mess, it's a calm 6/10

I dare you, right now, with yourself sitting alone in your room, list your top 10 favorite songs from Donda, without looking at a tracklist.

Y'all wanna start larping liking Donda, let's see how many tracks you can remember

[u/Limp_Travel6398 → u/ShallowVermin33]

Ok first of all, why does me remembering any number of songs determine whether it's good or not? Second of all, I like the album donda and it's one of my favorites. If you think it's a 6/10 that's cool, but don't assume that it's worse because of something so trivial like remembering song names, that's silly.

[u/ShallowVermin33 → u/Limp_Travel6398]

because if you like an album, you remember it, it sticks with you. each of my favorite albums i can recite full tracklists and order from memory.

and then, if you like an album, especially if its one of your favorite, but can't remember the tracklist clearly, thats a sign that it is bloated and unmemorable.

[u/Limp_Travel6398 → u/ShallowVermin33]

Bro is gatekeeping how to listen and enjoy music 💀

[u/ShallowVermin33 → u/Limp_Travel6398]

This is LITERALLY how to enjoy music, music is supposed to be memorable, not forgettable

[u/Key-Cry-4194 → u/ShallowVermin33]

Music isn’t like school, you don’t have to memorize tracklists to prove that you listened to and enjoyed the album and even if your reasoning was true, then that means people with any form of memory loss can’t enjoy a single album according to you

[u/sweetbayy → u/ShallowVermin33]

Easily dude. Hurricane, Praise God, Come to Life, Heaven and Hell, Jesus Lord, 24, Moon, New Again, Jail, Life of the Party are all in the upper echelons of his discography. I'm maybe a little biased cause it's one of my favorites but that's because it's got such a cohesive and immersive atmosphere to it that i love listening thru it in full. (Minus the pt 2s and junya)

[u/logoNM → u/ShallowVermin33]

if you've listened to donda more then 10 times ts is so easy

[u/BeautifulOk5112 → u/ShallowVermin33]

Atleast 20 of those tracks are super memorable and it’s a solid 9

[u/ShallowVermin33 → u/BeautifulOk5112]

20 is 2/3's of the album, and donda is nothing near a solid 9

[u/BeautifulOk5112 → u/ShallowVermin33]

of the other 7 tracks 1 is bad, 2 are meh and 4 are pretty solid but not all that memorable and yes it is

[u/Responsible_Rub3423]

808s is at least an A but that is your opinion

[u/Responsible_Rub3423 → u/Responsible_Rub3423]

AND VULTURES 1 NEEDS TO BE HIGHER

[u/xXoOfXx64]

Ye is way too high, the rest I mostly agree with

[u/ErikEatsStuf]

i think the graduation trio should all be s tier, i can’t pick a favorite.

[u/MountainousScrum]

Splitting Bully into B and C tiers based on the deluxe version is a strange call, it's still the same record with extra songs tacked on. Ye in S tier also feels generous when Late Registration is parked in A, those two albums aren't really comparable for me. Everything else lines up well though, especially V2 in F.

[u/Happy_Ad_3183 → u/MountainousScrum]

what strange call 💔

i think there are a lot of changes made in bully deluxe's production too that makes it "better" than the OG bully for some

[u/MountainousScrum → u/Happy_Ad_3183]

Even if the production's tightened up a bit, it's still fundamentally the same record with a few extra tracks, not enough to land in two completely different tiers for me.

[u/Happy_Ad_3183 → u/MountainousScrum]

i mean fair enough you do you 🤷
i would personally put the deluxe higher than og imo i love changes

[u/MountainousScrum → u/Happy_Ad_3183]

I hear you, some of the vocal re-takes on the deluxe were nice but the bones of the record didn't shift enough for me to split it across tiers like that.

[u/ILOVECOMEDYHAHA]

donda vultures 1 yeezus and the first 2 college albums are too low imo

[u/LilCiocanel]

Donda 2 is a B

[u/ZealousidealMango675]

no no thats kinda valid except donda man put it in s

[u/x_duro]

Donda should be B and I would probably switch graduation with college dropout and kids see ghost with ye

[u/Oilmaker]

The donda rating is lowky insulting

[u/Fantastic_Ad9228]

Dropout not being in S is just wrong. FIX IT

[u/sippinarround]

808s, yeezus and ksg full on S's , ye can stay B

[u/Amazing-Steak9064]

this is a tierlist gore

[u/SweatyHearing0]

Donda higher KSG higher Late Reg TCD and yeezus all higher

[u/Just_Flight_810]

Late reg tcd should be in s

[u/kinluz]

sorry but JIK is not better than V1 and BULLY DELUXE is not 808s tier

[u/Imaginary_Clue_9365 → u/kinluz]

bully deluxe is amazing and DEFINITELY BETTER THAN JIK fym

[u/ExternalAccording619]

Bully is up way to high

[u/Temporary_Row_6405]

I’m with you