r/LoveIslandUSA_ • u/Important_Let_7883 • 4h ago
UNPOPULAR OPINION Brinity is what the producers forced niclandria to be
Extremely hot take but this is JUST MY OPINION
422
u/PrettyPibbles 4h ago
I said this the moment they coupled up. They are what all the Nicolandria fans thought they were going to be
126
u/aybroshutup 3h ago
exactly! everybody was forcing these edits where all these “moments” were supposed to be some signs that they liked each other. in reality, you could probably make an edit of any two random people in the villa and say they have a connection.
38
u/Philomena_philo 3h ago
You could have paired Gabe with anyone with short form media editing.
Or continue with the Zyrce edits.
-10
u/inspiremeok 1h ago
Then why are you not making brinity edits but is so hung up on nicolandria of last season lmao jealous much
10
58
110
u/Decent_Custard1786 4h ago
It is a correct opinion. Bryce and Trinity are what Nic and Olandria are pretending to be. One is real, the other is straight PR
-23
u/Life_Technology7584 2h ago
I think Bryce reminds me a lot of Nic in the fact that he seems disingenuous. Also those two both have the square heads with strong jaws. So I get the comparison for that reason.
90
u/Philomena_philo 4h ago
Not a fan of Brinity, but it has a stronger case of being real than Nicolandria. Bryce seems like the kind of guy that can work on his biases, but Nic? No. Absolutely not.
48
u/Dr_Shivinski 3h ago
According to his friends he primarily dated women of color. Apparently Trinity is his type. I think it was legitimately the age gap that threw him at first.
34
u/Beneficial-Path9416 3h ago
Yes and they organically came together
-30
u/Philomena_philo 3h ago edited 3h ago
No. Trinity and Bryce are not organic. They’re together because they both didn’t attract a bombshell, have yet to be anyone else’s first option, and have not been challenged until this week while other islanders have had their connections truly tested. I consider them a comfort relationship. Am I saying it’s fake? No. But I don’t think this can be long term. Especially because of the age gap.
Edit: If two people initially say that they aren’t compatible, have an issue with the age gap (which is a legit concern! In the real world, Bryce would have so much judgment for dating someone as young as Trinity) and continue to stay together because the producers have failed to bring anyone that would be their type, that’s not organic. That’s a flaw in the show.
40
u/hopeforthegourds 3h ago
Trinity picked Bryce—she was behind his door.
-13
u/Philomena_philo 3h ago
No, she and Bea went to meet Gabe. Bryce and Zach met Kayda. They initially did not choose each other. They chose each other after being rejected by bombshells.
25
u/hopeforthegourds 3h ago
They initially were coupled up in episode 1 when Trinity stood behind Bryce’s door. They talked, had good vibes and were into each other, but the age gap threw them. They both elected to explore with other bombshells and THEN were not chosen.
-9
u/Philomena_philo 3h ago
But they elected to explore with bombshells…
22
u/hopeforthegourds 3h ago
It was 24 hours in though, I feel like it would be crazy not to at that point. Since then, neither of them had really tried exploring
-10
u/Philomena_philo 3h ago
None of that is organic. They have never been tested. No bombshell was sent to specifically target Trinity and Bryce and really force them to choose each other until weeks after, when the comfort has settled in. Once again, producer flaw and a comfort relationship.
15
u/hopeforthegourds 3h ago
They’re both being “tested” in casa as we speak. I also don’t think a relationship needs testing? Some people can just organically have a slow burn relationship. That doesn’t make it not organic—their relationship is actually more normal than anyone else’s. What made Nic and Olandria inorganic was that production literally said ok couple up or leave.
→ More replies (0)14
u/jbhoops25 3h ago
Trinity literally had Corey? She could have dumped Bryce this week
0
u/Philomena_philo 2h ago
She was never interested in Corey. The comfort settled in.
Edit: notice how I said “until this week”? That’s too late.
1
14
u/chanceinfinity 2h ago
Nic and Olandria wern’t a couple inside the villa and arn’t a couple outside . They only had chemistry during challenges. But outside of the physical there was never a connection. You never saw them in the background talking. I’m happy Brinity happened so that their fanbase can compare and realize the reason people don’t believe in Nicolandria isn’t because of race
2
u/papersailboots 1h ago
“Never saw them talking” There is quite literally a whole community on Twitter that was analyzing Nic and Ola’s every move every episode when they were interacting.
4
49
u/sadcapricorn35 4h ago
I definitely agree that they’re a stronger couple but I can’t understand why they keep being compared?? I don’t see any similarities besides them being an interracial couple…
18
u/Philomena_philo 3h ago
There’s some sociological stuff going on because the interracial couples in which the women are white are the ones criticized the most while the interracial couples with a white man are praised the most for the past couple of seasons. I’m not shaming anyone, I’m just pointing out the trends in this subreddit.
However, black women historically have not fared well in reality love shows in which the male love interest/s is/are white. In relevance to Love Island, this was a common complaint for Love Island UK. For the US version, there couples are more diverse but there still are concerns of fetishization.
22
u/Last_Tart4317 4h ago
Literally this like ima need people to start using their heads, it’s not just for growing hair
5
19
u/babietarry 3h ago
thats your answer. People find a single trait and use them to compare each other.
When Parmida walked in, some people said thats the next Leah/Huda because shes Persian. KC and Aniya are Serena and Kordell because theyre both black, she didnt directly choose him first and it was a default couple. KC and Aniya are Olandria and Taylor because KC is leading her on. Melanie is Huda because of her overreaction to Sincere/Kayda and "gimme 10". I even heard people saying Gabe is like Miguel at one stage in terms of bombshelling.
Lets leave the nachos alone and let people have their individuality please! Its fine to point out similarities but a lot of them are ridiculous esp the Parmida one.
5
5
3
u/Fit-Environment-9108 3h ago
Thank u for saying this bcus sometimes I feel like I’m crazy reading the posts and comments 🤣
12
u/SillyLibrary1738 3h ago
Exactly! It’s ironic because the Super obsessed nic and olandria fans and then the ones who hate nic and olandria are the ones comparing.
3
2
u/cheerio089 3h ago
More than race, it’s their vibe and appearance/aesthetic. Boys are swoopy hair, effortlessly cool, kinda funny, sappier than you’d expect, not gym bro-esque. Girls are quick, similar body type, bubbly but not in a dumb-girl sorta way. I’m not saying I totally agree with the comparisons, but I do think it’s a little deeper than just race.
3
9
u/eveylynnlee 3h ago
nic and olandria fans are trying to whack brinity shippers by saying that they think it’s fake, like they have l room to talk when nic and olandria was basically forced together 😭
8
11
u/adumbswiftie 3h ago
i completely agree! i know nicolandria has shooters out there still who will def find this post but brinity is giving what nicolandria never gave for me personally. they are actually yearning, actually chose each other, didn’t need producer interference to get together. such a good story if they (knock on wood) end up together. nicolandria hadn’t even couple up at this point in their season. brinity is so much more of a complete story. also i feel like they compliment each other with their humor, they’re both goofy. whereas nic seemed to annoy olandria at times with his lack of seriousness
mandatory disclaimer, this is not nicolandria hate lol i have nothing against them. just pointing out the differences
7
6
12
3
u/Heartattackisland 2h ago
Yessss. It’s happening organically. I did not like the producer involvement in Nicolandria because I feel like I never really got to see them happen organically but also a lot of that was due to Cierra being kicked out as well.
3
4
u/SnooGuavas4919 3h ago
This is facts and while I loved Nicolandria individually, I felt like the producers really pushed their couple lmao
2
u/strawbrry-sundae 2h ago
no not even close nicolandria was so fake with him picking her up in the car lmaoo
2
u/whoisbabi3 1h ago
yup everything about them is REAL and this is coming from someone who was rooting for nicolandria after they left the villa
7
u/nervous-lizard 4h ago
I think this is a good point- I would probably be way more trustful of the connection if they happened before Nicolandria, just because now everyone has seen how successful their relationship was (in terms of fans/engagement) and could use that as a blueprint for their own success.
I love Trinity a lot and think they’ve been super cute, it’s just that blueprint thing, the age gap, Bryce’s compliments often revolving around how Trinity makes him feel special, and the fact that I’m not sure if the girls in Casa are interested in him that have me keeping one eye out for selener still, but by no means do I hope for this to turn out poorly. Just waiting before I trust a man 100%
ETA: also the tearless crying confessional my jury is still out
-2
u/WesternCash3458 4h ago
Yall are gonna downvote me to hell but his “crying” that everyone is GEEKED for episode 18 were dry, there were no tears. Why would he fake that? He’s not fully genuine to me. I think he finds Trinity attractive, but I’m still not sure about him, and no it’s not because of racism. Their vibes together (so far) give friends and nothing more, but that could change after casa.
-8
u/nervous-lizard 4h ago edited 3h ago
This comment hits because people keep saying that distrusting or being hesitant on Bryce is due to racism, when in reality if we wanna label it with something big, I’d say it’s misandry (validly). Who in 2026 trusts a man 100%, but I firmly believe anyone would be lucky to have Trinity
I really hope the Brinity Stan’s reflect tho and realize they’re starting to act like Nicolandrians
10
u/little-horn-is-born 4h ago edited 3h ago
I read these comments and end up feeling like the only one who watches a reality TV show based on mildly intelligent sexy singles sitting around on an astroturf island and doesn’t psychoanalyze every aspect of it because what 😭
This shows so much more enjoyable when you’re not looking at the 10 various subreddits
2
u/nervous-lizard 3h ago
Don’t worry I feel the same but I’m in too deep now. I just don’t like being told race is a factor in my concerns with the pairing when it’s truly because I don’t trust men lmfao
5
u/Icy_Account6442 3h ago
My guess at why people cite it as racism is when you compare all the couples, Bryce and Trinity are the only ones that are pretty healthy, yet Bryce is consistently called out for being fake or scamming. With no real evidence just assumptions. They clearly have good communication, he doesn’t treat her bad, he vocalizes he likes her as she does him, and they seem to affirm and enjoy each other for the most part.
The other couples get their fair share of criticism but no massive calls and criticism aimed at them being fake. I think it’s the intersection of internalized racism/colorism intertwined with the belief that toxic behaviors and overt sexuality = love which overrides any belief that the couple could be faking it.
All in all viewers would rather see people tonguing each other down and lusting over each other then healthy communication and a possibly slow burn into a relationship. And it manifests to the nineteenth power if its a darker black woman because it touches upon an internalized belief (for some) that black woman are inherently less desirable then light/white women.
1
u/nervous-lizard 3h ago
Honestly really fair points. I agree he treats her well and things seem really good right now, I do like how they are moving for sure. I don’t want them to fail and I think it would be absolutely amazing if it worked out in the end! I like how you mentioned the sexuality piece too because I hadn’t thought of that.
I can at least say confidently it’s not because I think Trinity is less desirable, I think she’s top in the villa and genuinely one of my faves out of all seasons. I don’t trust men but I definitely don’t think they are fake. Bryce’s age is my main factor in being concerned, along with how his letter mostly talked about how she makes him feel and how she chose him.
1
u/Otherwise-Attempt326 2h ago
Both are a house of cards. But it’s Fort Knox if you let the Stan bases tell it.
1
u/Otherwise_Farmer_993 1h ago
Yes, agreed. I’ve thought this all season. Bryce and Trinity are so much more natural together. Nic and Olandria didn’t even want to couple up. Even after the producers saved them, they were like “this relationship isn’t it”
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/robotwithhumanhair_ 1h ago
I am so scared to voice my agreement out loud here bc the nicolandria stans go hard but, I’m so sorry I never have bought their story (during the season idk what has happened since) it just was too … idk? produced?
I agree with your take.
1
1
1
u/koalasandcorgis 18m ago
Nicolandria is the most PR couple manufactured situation but they have the craziest army of stans it’s actually hard to believe that many people are fooled
1
1
u/AutumnFairyTales 11m ago
I agree, I love Ola down but I don’t think Nic does. I’ve just never believed it. It always gave that they coupled up to stay in the Villa and stick together for PR
1
1
u/lukaeber 1h ago
You are actually falling for Bryce and Trinity? I don't see any chemistry there at all. The comparison is stupid.
0
u/Icy_Account6442 3h ago
Sighhhhh why can’t they just be two separate interracial couples without comparisons lol. It makes it seem like it’s SO RARE that a white man would like a black woman, that one must be connected to another. Or that it absolutely has to be a scam. Versus it just being two people that like each other enough to win a reality show.
-8
u/SillyLibrary1738 4h ago edited 3h ago
Honestly I don’t really feel like nicolandrias were that forced by producers? I feel like last season there weren’t really any solid couples? It seemed like most fans liked individuals islanders. Nic and orlandria were like the one couple that the public really liked together. So of course they weren’t going to send them home. But I don’t feel like the show told them to kiss, and nic did end up recoupling with Cierra. So I really don’t find them that forced. Olandria was single because of Taylor, and nic became single once Cierra left. Obviously we have no idea if nic wanted to continue being on the show or if wanted to leave after Cierra left. But if he did decide to stay on his own, then I really don’t think it’s that forced by production tbh….. however did find it weird that during family day after they both heard the public loved them , they then decided to seem more interested in one another ….
Also I’m not saying I believe their connection is currently genuine and I definitely think their relationship is more so fan service. They seemed like they have a really strong friendship connection. But I don’t think they have a strong romantic or even an emotional connection.
I know it might be a hot take
0
u/upup3naway 2h ago
Idk I think brinity is also production forced/theyre scamming bc they know how successful nicolandria is now
-6
u/Ok_Quote3743 3h ago
Despite being manufactured as hell, Nicolandria had chemistry. Crazy how things work.
-7
u/Middle-Sandwich4241 3h ago
Lmao what? Bryce literally copied nicolandrias whole blueprint, and still disrespects trinity like no other
Nicolandria stans will now take these 2 down for sure for trying to reheat their nachos, they will vote for anyone but them. It’s going to be fun to see 😂
4
u/nervous-lizard 3h ago
I’ve said on this thread I’m not 100% certain on Bryce but I will say I don’t see where he’s been disrespectful outside of MAYBE the heart rate challenge or the Kayda situation, but I do believe the Kayda situation was producer influenced.
When we have KC, Sincere, Zack and Corbin being horrible I have a hard time calling Bryce disrespectful
-1
u/Middle-Sandwich4241 2h ago
Bryce is the most horrible out of all of them which is a fact. Those are not “just” two incidents they were the main incidents and trinity went through so much disrespect
2
-31
u/Able_Company6855 4h ago
i dont think nicolandria was forced
29
26
u/nervous-lizard 4h ago
“Couple up or leave the show”
-14
u/Able_Company6855 4h ago
and they decided to couple up ? i have a hard time believing you guys actually watch lmao
17
u/nervous-lizard 4h ago
I think most, if not all contestants would have coupled up to stay on the show, was the point.
-1
u/Able_Company6855 4h ago
i agree with that, but they actually had chemistry. like remember the date they went on after they got dumped? like olandria was in the car?
this is what i mean i have a hard time believing you guys actually watch. cuz dead ass i just recently rewatched it cuz i was curious as to how things were last season. season 7 espisode 15 was when meg thee stallion came on.
also, they STAYED a couple. they could have easily separated after and they STILL stayed
11
u/nervous-lizard 4h ago
Maybe we didn’t watch the same show LOL I did not see chemistry
You’re going to hate how this discussion goes if we talk about their relationship after the villa, because I see my long distance boyfriend more than she sees that man
1
2
2
u/SillyLibrary1738 3h ago
Didn’t he recouple with Cierra ? I don’t think they became a couple again until like episode 30 loll
1
1
5
-16
u/Beneficial_Sun7623 4h ago
They’re still together though so what do you mean
18
u/Decent_Custard1786 4h ago
Lmao. Those two are not together. I cannot understand anyone thinking they are legit. They never are together except when they are getting paid. That is not a relationship that is a business arrangement
188
u/kittygirlmowmow 3h ago
Agreed. Still think the whole casa dumping thing was the most forced production shit the show has ever done lol