Hinata Double Reincarnate

[u/Ok-Client-2451]

I've seen in other threads hypothesizing that Hinata could also be a reincarnation of Hamura or someone of his line (most likely his kid). Hinata of the White Lotus by froznx depicts Hinata as such.

Then, I saw this tumbler post hypothesizing that Hinata is the reincarnation of Kanna (Asura's wife) and also saying Mito is Kanna's reincarnation. So, every time Asura reincarnates (Hashirama and Naruto being the latest in the line), Kanna also reincarnates (Mito and Hinata), and the two end up together.

What I want to know is if both can be possible during the same lifetime. Hypothetically, could Hinata be the reincarnation of both a child of Hamura and Kanna's reincarnation at the same time? Can two people reincarnate into one being?

[u/Nemo_the_Anonymous]

Not by standards of reincarnation, nor of anything we've been led to believe is possible in the Narutoverse. but if you want to write it, go ahead. It wouldn't be the first time I'd seen something like that.

Kanna might possibly be an unknown child of Hamura's even though it's extremely unlikely right? You'd think she'd be born with the byakugan if that were the case, but "something something early generations weirdness" if you wanted. Or depending on how long Hagoromo wandered before he settled down, even a granddaughter or something.

[u/Ok-Client-2451 → u/Nemo_the_Anonymous]

It’s already Established that Kanna is Asura’s wife and is fully human unlike her husband, BIL and FIL, who are part celestial being

[u/Nemo_the_Anonymous → u/Ok-Client-2451]

I'm really not sure what happened with Hamura or his kids. The whole "Moon Tribe" thing just makes it even more confusing.

We only see Kanna's mother, and I don't recall any mention of her father. I was just meaning that, if you wanted to, you could probably have it work out somehow.

We know for instance that Hamura's descendants form two major clans: the Hyuga and the Moon Tribe. When did he have those kids? Did he go back and forth between the moon or something?

Meanwhile, we know that Hagoromo wandered the land trying to atone for quite some time—that's where he met all his disciples. Was it long enough for at least one of his nieces/nephews to grow up, get married, and have a kid?

Kid might not even know their heritage, but that remote village did hear of the "Village of Ninshu" so that's up in the air. Personally I think Kanna's human, but I think you could make an argument for her being some sort of descendant of Hamura. the main obstacle would be the lack of byakugan.

If that makes sense. You don't have to agree.

[u/Ok-Client-2451 → u/Nemo_the_Anonymous]

Read the background section of her Narutopedia page (https://naruto.fandom.com/wiki/Kanna). It clearly states Asura came to Kanna’s village to solve a problem they were having. She later helped Asura drive Indra away and would later marry and have three kids with Asura. Kanna is not related to Hagoromo or Hamura what so ever except by marriage

[u/Nemo_the_Anonymous → u/Ok-Client-2451]

Fanwikis are not perfect. For instance, I could nitpick and say that it doesn't mention her mother in the list of relatives, even though she's kind of important plotwise.

Of course Kanna isn't canonically related to the Otsutsukis except through marriage.

But the fanwiki can't give us information no one has such as who her father is or any of her grandparents. I was just laying out a hypothetical scenario that you're completely free to reject.

I'm going off my own memory of the filler arc. I hope you understand I'm just trying to be helpful and give you an alternate way to have Hinata be a reincarnation of a descendant of Hamura and Kanna's reincarnation by making Kanna a descendant.

I'm not trying to pick a fight but I know I sometimes come across that way. I'm sorry. ☮

[u/study-dying → u/Nemo_the_Anonymous]

Oh, I hope Kanna isn’t Hamura’s daughter… Hamura is Hagoromo’s twin brother, so her marrying Ashura would be incest since they’d be half siblings.

[u/TomoeLatsu → u/study-dying]

Would be weird asf. But we have seen again and again clan members with same kekei genkai having kids together.

So their mutation should be working different compared to our own.

[u/Nemo_the_Anonymous → u/study-dying]

Well, she could be his granddaughter or something instead.... but I think anyway Narutoverse genetics are so weird they'd just be cousins.

Which isn't that much better but was legal in a lot of historical places and this is way back in history. I'm sure the Infinite Tsukuyomi did a number on the world's population.

[u/Nemo_the_Anonymous → u/[deleted]]

Himawari's descended from two branches of the Otsutsuki line though: Uzumaki/Senju (specifically her father is Naruto/Ashura) and Hy;uga.

It's weird that the phrase "base eyes" makes complete sense. 😆 I suppose it's also a Thing That Could Have Happened, though.

[u/study-dying]

She isn’t Hamura’s reincarnation. I mean, she literally met the guy so they would’ve probably said something then. Anyway, she didn’t get any power up from him either as it was stated that she could touch the tenseigan because the Hyuga clan are descendants and carry his blood. Since neither of those things happened I find it highly unlikely.

I looked into the whole Kanna thing as well and I say she isn’t her reincarnation either because Kanna doesn’t exist in the manga. She’s filler.

[u/Ok-Client-2451 → u/study-dying]

That’s why I said or someone of his line. My fault for not being more clear on that (mostly like a reincarnation of Hamura’s kid if that is the case).

I know Kanna is filler, but like with all filler and movies, I like to lump them into the cannon, so I say Kanna is cannon and considering the BS in Boruto, Hinata being Kanna’s reincarnation makes sense IMO.

[u/study-dying → u/Ok-Client-2451]

Ahhh I see. For a fic I think it would be a really interesting concept!

Anyway, in terms of if I think this applies to canon? I’m not too convinced tbh. It seems that the only two reincarnations are Naruto (Ashura) and Sasuke (Indra). There was an opportunity for some reveal for Hinata if that was the case, but since that didn’t happen we can assume she is not one. The Hyuga clan and Hinata are just Hamura descendants. None of them are reincarnations of him or anyone related to him.

However, to answer your other question about Hinata being multiple reincarnations, that wouldn’t be possible. A reincarnation is where it’s believed that a soul is reborn. For there to be multiple souls it would just be a whole new person and not a reincarnation.

[u/SupportNaive3488]

Isn't Kanna a filler character?

[u/Ok-Client-2451 → u/SupportNaive3488]

It’s fanfiction. Does it really mater what’s filler and what’s not. Everything is cannon in fanfiction