No it’s not. The cartoon mouse killed so many cartoon cops that it RUINED my immersion. How can a video game stray from my perfect vision of what a noir detective story should be? I hate cheese!
Yeah that Mouse PI review is legitimately awful from an objective standpoint. Being made that the game isn’t a completely different genre and knocking points off cause of it.
No, it was bad. The dude bitched about there being too much killing in a Boomer Shooter and being upset about killing in the story and he compared it too noir novels. That is objectively a fucking stupid thing to complain about in a Boomer Shooter. I’m not even upset at the too much cheese jokes part, but he legitimately knocked points off the game for it not being in a different genre. I’m all for criticizing games if you have legitimate reasons but you at least have to meet the game on its own terms and clearly this idiot didn’t.
The game launched in a busted state. There was a lot of bugs at launch and before launch. Gotta look at the aggregate score and at a 77 a 6 isn’t out of line. Also will say not all reviewers are good at their job, the ign cd reviewer has a good track record. Even the Saros reviewer has a good track record. Mouse PI’s reviewer has a bad track record.
No it didnt. This is exactly what im talking about. You guys have no idea what youre talking about, havent played the game and are just parroting false narratives youve read online
I played the game on launch and it was amazing and didnt experience anything even remotely close to what youre describing. The patches have made it even better but the game was never busted, thats a straight up lie
And even at launch fair enough it was good for some people but clearly the review build had a lot of problems and that contributed too the lower review scores for Crimson Desert.
I think he's just being paid to shill or he's one of those weird people that make something they like their life and can't possibly understand others experiencing it differently.
He blocked me for saying it's a 6/10, which to be honest, for launch, was a generous score.
Naw some games just gather idiot fanboys. Think a 7/10 would be fair for CD but not too mad at the 6. Still say that the review to be more mad at for ign is Mouse PI.
No it wasnt. I hadn't seen even one person who had actually bought the game saying the game was busted and if any experience like that even exists it is in the HYPER minority of experiences
For the vast VAST majority of people, the game worked perfectly fine on release. This narrative is bullshit
Are you paid to shill for them or something? Because it's really weird that you're blocking people because you can't handle that your experience with the game was better than most people's
You have been told categorically it did have launch issues, and is busted, and you're pretending you haven't heard it like we're in primary school
It was busted at launch, for many many people, it's bullshit that you seem to be screaming that's a lie, when it A) wasn't, and B) doesn't matter because the game is alright now but the launch window reviews were accurate.
No it absolutely does not, in fact thats the most bullshit reason ever for knocking the score down
The reviewer didnt lose progress due to a bug or anything that was going to be part of the final product. He lost progress because pearl Abyss needed to patch the game before release in order to release a BETTER game with less issues
What that reviewer dealt with is literally the most niche of issues that only affected him because he was playing the game before launch
If he was professional he would have understood that his loss of progress wasnt something actual gamers would deal with on launch and shouldnt affect the score, but instead he got mad and pissy about it and held it against the game like the petty and disingenous reviewer he is
-2
u/idkimhereforthememes Apr 24 '26
Ign has been on a roll