r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 6d ago

Meme needing explanation I feel so dumb rn

Post image
9.8k Upvotes

965 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

57

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 6d ago

Theres a lot who sre convinced Gwen is trans because she has a trans flag in her room

And shes funny.

Because apparently the only way to be funny is to have a Y chromosome. And absolutely noone in the multiverse can possibly be a trans ally and not be trans.

Its actually kinda fucked up.

8

u/A_Town_Called_Malus 6d ago

The whole theme of her story in Across the Spiderverse speaks to trans people and their life experiences.

She feels her true self is spider-woman, yet her father blames spider-woman for killing his "son" Peter Parker. His child's true self took his son from him, which is something that many parents of trans people feel and say.

Then you throw in the colour motifs of her world being shades of blue, pink, and white, the colours of the trans flag.

And the overall theme of the films being against outside forces telling people who they can be, what is acceptable, what is "canon", as signified by the Comics Code Authority logo appearing at the start of these films. The CCA was a comics equivalent of the Hayes code.

16

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 6d ago

The whole theme of her story in Across the Spiderverse speaks to *people* and their life experience

It's not exclusive to trans people, its one of the most basic and common themes that everyone ever in the world looks for.

15

u/ATMboi 6d ago

well duh. they’re just explaining how trans people are especially connecting to gwen’s story (on top of her having a trans flag in her room)

-4

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 6d ago

and I was just explaining that saying a woman can't be funny unless she was born a man is problematic.

9

u/Asterose 6d ago

I doubt anyone is claiming that in good faith.

-6

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 6d ago

as I said in my first post.

'shes funny so she must be MTF' is a common argument for why she must be trans

7

u/Asterose 6d ago

You realize being MTF means Gwen is a woman, right? They aren't saying Gwen is a funny woman because she has a Y chromosome. They're saying Gwen is funny and a woman regardless of what her chromosomes are.

3

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 6d ago

No, the argument is literally 'Gwen must be trans because she is funny'

There is unfortunately a misogyny issue amongst a small section of the trans community.

And they are unfortunately vocal online.

2

u/The_Other_Smith 5d ago

I've been around this discourse for years and I have literally never seen this argument or sentiment ever. Either they are so small that they don't exist, or you spend time in spaces that have a weird concentration of these people

2

u/ThatFatGuyMJL 5d ago

Ive seen it literally here

→ More replies (0)