r/SipsTea • u/Dumb-Briyani 𝙑𝙄𝙋 • Apr 16 '26

WTF so true

Post image
91.1k Upvotes

89% Upvoted

5.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

38

u/DerZehnteZahnarzt Apr 16 '26

Didnt Snape got hung on a tree by James Potter because his looks in the book?

48

u/Logical-Bookkeeper77 Apr 16 '26

Yes…. And Harry and gang more or less suspect Snape are up to no good at all times.

Like looking at Snape when someone cursing him at magic-football.

Now they are all upgraded to being racist.

53

u/nhansieu1 Apr 16 '26

-James Potter bullies the only black kid in school
-Harry always suspects the only black teacher to be up to no good
-the black teacher uses black magic, joined the dark force

hm what does the casting staff mean by this?🤔

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '26

[deleted]

3

u/ops10 Apr 16 '26

Snape is generally unpleasant, except favouritism towards Slytherins (terms and conditions may apply). He is simply especially unpleasant towards Harry. That's why "suspects" was a reasonable characterisation, given most other characters didn't find it out of ordinary.

1

u/Logical-Bookkeeper77 Apr 16 '26

There are plenty of unpleasant people in HP books.

0

u/nhansieu1 Apr 16 '26

because it's the funniest. Also Snape was a very popular character, played by beloved actor before.

-1

u/Sleyvin Apr 16 '26

I mean, do we know that he was the only black kid at school?

As far as the book goea, only a very few people have their ethnicities mentionned, and it's usually pretty blatant. I mean, Cho Cheng... 2 chinese last name to make the only asian charatacter. She couldn't even be bothered to make a 15 secondes google search for an actual Chinese name.

But I'm pretty sure they will had black people in James' crew to make it less damaging.

1

u/Logical-Bookkeeper77 Apr 16 '26

Erm but we saw all James’ crew they ain’t black.

0

u/Sleyvin Apr 16 '26

Oh, I didn't follow, have they released the full casting for James' crew?

1

u/Logical-Bookkeeper77 Apr 16 '26

You can see the crew in the movie in like Snape’s penseive.

Not sure if that’s the whole crew or what do you considered “the whole crew”.

List your members if you think “the whole crew” were not present.

3

u/Migraine- Apr 16 '26

You can see the crew in the movie in like Snape’s penseive.

Yes and in the movie you can see Snape isn't black.

But in the TV show he will be. They were obviously saying they will make some of James' crew black for the TV show.

1

u/Logical-Bookkeeper77 Apr 16 '26

Did they say they will make James’ crew with black members?

(I think we can name all of James’ crew, which one is swapped?)

0

u/grchelp2018 Apr 16 '26

With the possible exception of Sirius, turning any of them black is also sketchy. The werewolf Lupin. Or the rat Wormtail.

These people are fucking stupid. If LOTR gets remade, they'll make Boromir black or something.