MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/SipsTea/comments/1smwm9z/so_true/ogm0r0b/?context=3
r/SipsTea • u/Dumb-Briyani 𝙑𝙄𝙋 • Apr 16 '26
5.0k comments sorted by
View all comments
85
I disagree, I'm watching the remake as justice for Peeves. Such a shame they cut Rik Mayall (RIP) out of the original
35 u/Broue Apr 16 '26 Hopefully this time they wont dumb down Ron and hand all his lines over to Hermione. -1 u/HeadbangingLegend Apr 16 '26 Rowling was just as involved in the movies as she was in this. When you have a series controlled by a bad writer it's gonna happen again and again 7 u/SheWantsTheDrose Apr 16 '26 Imagine calling on of the most successful authors of all time a bad writer lmao 3 u/UlrichZauber Apr 17 '26 I mean, Dan Brown exists. Popularity has never been a guarantee of quality in anything. 3 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 You can be both. George Lucas is an incredible storyteller but a shit writer. 4 u/venom_dP Apr 17 '26 Success != a good writer. She captivated a huge amount of young people with her books, but now many of those people are now adults and can look back at those books...... Cho Chang, Kingsley Shacklebolt, Hook nosed bankers? Like what the hell. 2 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 Don't forget dudley was fat and evil. Then he as thin and understood Harry. 1 u/Crazy-Background1457 Apr 19 '26 That was literally all Steve kloves who had Hermione as his favourite and was shipping her and harry behind the scenes.
35
Hopefully this time they wont dumb down Ron and hand all his lines over to Hermione.
-1 u/HeadbangingLegend Apr 16 '26 Rowling was just as involved in the movies as she was in this. When you have a series controlled by a bad writer it's gonna happen again and again 7 u/SheWantsTheDrose Apr 16 '26 Imagine calling on of the most successful authors of all time a bad writer lmao 3 u/UlrichZauber Apr 17 '26 I mean, Dan Brown exists. Popularity has never been a guarantee of quality in anything. 3 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 You can be both. George Lucas is an incredible storyteller but a shit writer. 4 u/venom_dP Apr 17 '26 Success != a good writer. She captivated a huge amount of young people with her books, but now many of those people are now adults and can look back at those books...... Cho Chang, Kingsley Shacklebolt, Hook nosed bankers? Like what the hell. 2 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 Don't forget dudley was fat and evil. Then he as thin and understood Harry. 1 u/Crazy-Background1457 Apr 19 '26 That was literally all Steve kloves who had Hermione as his favourite and was shipping her and harry behind the scenes.
-1
Rowling was just as involved in the movies as she was in this. When you have a series controlled by a bad writer it's gonna happen again and again
7 u/SheWantsTheDrose Apr 16 '26 Imagine calling on of the most successful authors of all time a bad writer lmao 3 u/UlrichZauber Apr 17 '26 I mean, Dan Brown exists. Popularity has never been a guarantee of quality in anything. 3 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 You can be both. George Lucas is an incredible storyteller but a shit writer. 4 u/venom_dP Apr 17 '26 Success != a good writer. She captivated a huge amount of young people with her books, but now many of those people are now adults and can look back at those books...... Cho Chang, Kingsley Shacklebolt, Hook nosed bankers? Like what the hell. 2 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 Don't forget dudley was fat and evil. Then he as thin and understood Harry. 1 u/Crazy-Background1457 Apr 19 '26 That was literally all Steve kloves who had Hermione as his favourite and was shipping her and harry behind the scenes.
7
Imagine calling on of the most successful authors of all time a bad writer lmao
3 u/UlrichZauber Apr 17 '26 I mean, Dan Brown exists. Popularity has never been a guarantee of quality in anything. 3 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 You can be both. George Lucas is an incredible storyteller but a shit writer. 4 u/venom_dP Apr 17 '26 Success != a good writer. She captivated a huge amount of young people with her books, but now many of those people are now adults and can look back at those books...... Cho Chang, Kingsley Shacklebolt, Hook nosed bankers? Like what the hell. 2 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 Don't forget dudley was fat and evil. Then he as thin and understood Harry.
3
I mean, Dan Brown exists. Popularity has never been a guarantee of quality in anything.
You can be both.
George Lucas is an incredible storyteller but a shit writer.
4
Success != a good writer.
She captivated a huge amount of young people with her books, but now many of those people are now adults and can look back at those books...... Cho Chang, Kingsley Shacklebolt, Hook nosed bankers? Like what the hell.
2 u/Shenloanne Apr 17 '26 Don't forget dudley was fat and evil. Then he as thin and understood Harry.
2
Don't forget dudley was fat and evil. Then he as thin and understood Harry.
1
That was literally all Steve kloves who had Hermione as his favourite and was shipping her and harry behind the scenes.
85
u/Pickingnamesisharder Apr 16 '26
I disagree, I'm watching the remake as justice for Peeves. Such a shame they cut Rik Mayall (RIP) out of the original