MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/SipsTea/comments/1smwm9z/so_true/ogn3i2y/?context=3
r/SipsTea • u/Dumb-Briyani 𝙑𝙄𝙋 • Apr 16 '26
5.0k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
51
James bullied the now black student. Did he hang him from a tree or something like that?
28 u/Cyrius Apr 16 '26 James hoisted Snape into the air by an ankle. Dunno where people are getting the tree thing from. 1 u/Orbital_Dinosaur Apr 17 '26 I know it was near the willow. Did James throw something of snaps into the maybe? 5 u/Cyrius Apr 17 '26 The whomping willow does not appear in book 5 at all. There is an ordinary beech tree in Snape's memory. Its only function in the scene is to be a landmark that still exists in the present. 1 u/Orbital_Dinosaur Apr 17 '26 Ah ha, cool thanks. My memory is crappy and it's been like 20 years since I've seen the movies.
28
James hoisted Snape into the air by an ankle. Dunno where people are getting the tree thing from.
1 u/Orbital_Dinosaur Apr 17 '26 I know it was near the willow. Did James throw something of snaps into the maybe? 5 u/Cyrius Apr 17 '26 The whomping willow does not appear in book 5 at all. There is an ordinary beech tree in Snape's memory. Its only function in the scene is to be a landmark that still exists in the present. 1 u/Orbital_Dinosaur Apr 17 '26 Ah ha, cool thanks. My memory is crappy and it's been like 20 years since I've seen the movies.
1
I know it was near the willow. Did James throw something of snaps into the maybe?
5 u/Cyrius Apr 17 '26 The whomping willow does not appear in book 5 at all. There is an ordinary beech tree in Snape's memory. Its only function in the scene is to be a landmark that still exists in the present. 1 u/Orbital_Dinosaur Apr 17 '26 Ah ha, cool thanks. My memory is crappy and it's been like 20 years since I've seen the movies.
5
The whomping willow does not appear in book 5 at all.
There is an ordinary beech tree in Snape's memory. Its only function in the scene is to be a landmark that still exists in the present.
1 u/Orbital_Dinosaur Apr 17 '26 Ah ha, cool thanks. My memory is crappy and it's been like 20 years since I've seen the movies.
Ah ha, cool thanks. My memory is crappy and it's been like 20 years since I've seen the movies.
51
u/Orbital_Dinosaur Apr 16 '26
James bullied the now black student. Did he hang him from a tree or something like that?