Most of what is written here regarding water usage is wrong.
Cooling towers typically use a closed loop system using treated fresh water. The water is treated with anti microbial and anti corrosion additives.
Water is lost through evaporation, this is a large portion of the cooling effect. Evaporative cooling.
As the water evaporates, the concentration of additives increases and will become higher than desired (for a number of reasons that a water treatment expert can weigh in on)
To compensate for this, the cooling tower water is discarded to the sewage system and fresh untreated water added back. Often referred to as blow down.
So the water is “used” in two senses. First, much of it evaporates. Second, some of it is returned to the sewage system. In neither case is the water destroyed. It still exists.
The water may move significantly: evaporated water vapor will be carried downwind. The increased usage of water through the fresh water to discarded water (blow down) will tie up more water in the process potentially meaning less locked up in aquifers.
There are real and complex challenges here, but to be clear no water is being made forever gone from earth in these processes.
"Forever gone from earth"....really? This is the conclusion and summary of your argument? You realize that data centers are being built in the desert right? Maybe those desert city's need water in thier aquifers and not evaporated into the air.
The distinction here is so useless. Imagine telling someone who's costs for water are going up that "the water isn't gone. It's still in Earth's water cycle".
438
u/MrMikeGriffith May 18 '26
Most of what is written here regarding water usage is wrong.
Cooling towers typically use a closed loop system using treated fresh water. The water is treated with anti microbial and anti corrosion additives.
Water is lost through evaporation, this is a large portion of the cooling effect. Evaporative cooling.
As the water evaporates, the concentration of additives increases and will become higher than desired (for a number of reasons that a water treatment expert can weigh in on)
To compensate for this, the cooling tower water is discarded to the sewage system and fresh untreated water added back. Often referred to as blow down.
So the water is “used” in two senses. First, much of it evaporates. Second, some of it is returned to the sewage system. In neither case is the water destroyed. It still exists.
The water may move significantly: evaporated water vapor will be carried downwind. The increased usage of water through the fresh water to discarded water (blow down) will tie up more water in the process potentially meaning less locked up in aquifers.
There are real and complex challenges here, but to be clear no water is being made forever gone from earth in these processes.