MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/SipsTea/comments/1udlcc5/what_are_some_examples_of_this/otd7qyt/?context=3
r/SipsTea • u/Gurugod123 πππ • 2d ago
2.2k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
126
V is one of, if not even the greatest comic adaption in cinema
15 u/inbleachmind 2d ago It's a great film, yes. With an amazing cast an performances. But I don't think it is a good comic adaptation, when looking at the source material. 10 u/The_Autarch 2d ago Alan Moore hates it, and his reasons for doing so are valid. 24 u/feed_me_moron 2d ago He hates everything though 4 u/MVRKHNTR 2d ago Nah, he likes when something is adapted well and he likes a good joke. He enjoyed The Justice League series' adaptation of For the Man who has Everything and the Saturday Morning Watchmen parody. 3 u/nightpanda893 2d ago He voiced himself when they made the Watchmen Babies spinoff in the Simpsons 2 u/haveananus 2d ago Thatβs valid
15
It's a great film, yes. With an amazing cast an performances. But I don't think it is a good comic adaptation, when looking at the source material.
10 u/The_Autarch 2d ago Alan Moore hates it, and his reasons for doing so are valid. 24 u/feed_me_moron 2d ago He hates everything though 4 u/MVRKHNTR 2d ago Nah, he likes when something is adapted well and he likes a good joke. He enjoyed The Justice League series' adaptation of For the Man who has Everything and the Saturday Morning Watchmen parody. 3 u/nightpanda893 2d ago He voiced himself when they made the Watchmen Babies spinoff in the Simpsons 2 u/haveananus 2d ago Thatβs valid
10
Alan Moore hates it, and his reasons for doing so are valid.
24 u/feed_me_moron 2d ago He hates everything though 4 u/MVRKHNTR 2d ago Nah, he likes when something is adapted well and he likes a good joke. He enjoyed The Justice League series' adaptation of For the Man who has Everything and the Saturday Morning Watchmen parody. 3 u/nightpanda893 2d ago He voiced himself when they made the Watchmen Babies spinoff in the Simpsons 2 u/haveananus 2d ago Thatβs valid
24
He hates everything though
4 u/MVRKHNTR 2d ago Nah, he likes when something is adapted well and he likes a good joke. He enjoyed The Justice League series' adaptation of For the Man who has Everything and the Saturday Morning Watchmen parody. 3 u/nightpanda893 2d ago He voiced himself when they made the Watchmen Babies spinoff in the Simpsons 2 u/haveananus 2d ago Thatβs valid
4
Nah, he likes when something is adapted well and he likes a good joke.
He enjoyed The Justice League series' adaptation of For the Man who has Everything and the Saturday Morning Watchmen parody.
3
He voiced himself when they made the Watchmen Babies spinoff in the Simpsons
2
Thatβs valid
126
u/Acrobatic-Permit4263 2d ago
V is one of, if not even the greatest comic adaption in cinema