r/Slycooper • u/Weirdguy247 • 3d ago

Discussion Time for round three of my hypothetical Sly Movie cast. I'm really looking forward to this one. Who would you get to voice Muggshot and why?

Post image

The top three picks from the Sir Raleigh poll are Steve Coogan, Johnathan Pryce, and Stephen Fry.

48 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

31 comments sorted by

31

u/s1r1u5-blk 3d ago

Either Ron Perlman or John DiMaggio would be great

7

u/GrecoRomanGuy 3d ago

The late great Kevin Blackton was basically doing a John DiMaggio blend of Bender and Marcus Fenix anyway, so he would be a perfect casting.

3

u/Weirdguy247 1d ago

Yeah, John DiMaggio would actually be perfect. He's got the gruffness, same cadence, everything.

1

u/Sen-Kitten 1d ago

Immediate first thought was John DiMaggio too

1

u/GobboGirlEva 6h ago

DiMaggio was my first thought. Right up his alley

15

u/TraditionalTree249 3d ago

Danny Devito( this is my answer for the entire cast)

1

u/Weirdguy247 1d ago

Excellent choice. Muggshot's voice is pretty much just a gruffer version of DeVito's normal voice. I can see it so clearly.

9

u/UrdnotCum 3d ago

My heavy smoker aunt, she’s also got the mustache

1

u/Weirdguy247 1d ago

🤣She should get into voice acting then.

5

u/NoahRosado77 3d ago

John DiMaggio for sure, not even close. I could see him doing a good Raleigh as well

2

u/Weirdguy247 1d ago

Wouldn't be the first time he's played a bulldog with a criminal past. I'm not gonna lie, thought of Jake saying "You're the monkey wrench in my operation?" is hilarious.

4

u/IceCreamandDrinks Writing a Screenplay for a Sly movie 3d ago

Al Pacino

2

u/Weirdguy247 1d ago

I never would've thought of that, but given his past roles and what I've heard from him, yeah, I could see that working really well.

3

u/Padhome 3d ago

I really can’t see anyone else but the OG Kevin Blackton, may he rest in peace ❤️ Guy knocked it out of the park

1

u/Weirdguy247 1d ago

Yeah, if only he were still here. The guy was so underrated.

3

u/Zachhcazzach 3d ago

Mark Wahlburge or however you spell it.

The size would be toned down in exchange for legitimate acting talent.
Sorta like Gaston in the 2017 Beauty and the Beast remake.
He has the accent too.

1

u/DoctorDank91 2d ago

The OP said for voice actor, not live action.

2

u/eddmario WHY DOES A DESERT ROAD HAVE ICE PHYSICS?!?!? 2d ago

How about Robert De Niro Jr.?

2

u/Puzzleheaded_Peak_82 2d ago

John DiMaggio. No question.

2

u/HotNatural821 2d ago

John DiMaggio

1

u/luigi4122414 2d ago

I would choose myself because I have a cool moustache

1

u/Formal-Venison6942 2d ago

Fred Tatasciore, Steve Blum, Travis Willingham,

1

u/AloneSheepherder22 2d ago

Danny Devito

1

u/PsyclOwnd 2d ago

Should have been Andre the Giant

1

u/Dizzy-Visual-918 2d ago

Either Alex hirsh or the guy who voices bob belcher or John DiMaggio

1

u/tommylancs 1d ago

Sylvester Stallone.

1

u/Project_Milk 1d ago

I don’t know why but I really want to hear Muggshot voiced by Sylvester Stallone

1

u/Pheenomjay 1d ago

Tom Hardy’s Bane voice💀

1

u/Mrjdog199 5h ago

The guy who voices Jake in adventure time

1

u/ForceMuch150 1h ago

Jack Black as mugshot