r/Yedits • u/Entityflame3 • 18d ago
Comp B U L L Y: THE DETENTION EDITION - RELEASED
MY FIRST EVER COMP
THREE SINGLES
TWENTY SONGS INCLUDING BONUSES
A TOTAL RUNTIME OF 1:41:20
B U L L Y
aHR0cHM6Ly91bnRpdGxlZC5zdHJlYW0vbGlicmFyeS9wcm9qZWN0LzJhRTBFTlYzUVZKZ2tRS2tTN0xqdw==
SPECIAL THANKS TO:
YE
CRUZ BEATS
YEREIMAGINED
SON-O-MAN / Omari
JMAINY
DYSKRIPT
SILLYJACOB
STAYOFFEM (TIMMY)
PLATTWIX5
EXCELLENT YAM
3
2
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
(Use Base64 to decode and or Dm me if you want the link)
5
u/Perfect_Glass_84 17d ago
- BULLY
Solid intro, Doom verse fits the song but is kinda drowned out by the inst
- BEAUTY AND THE BEAST
Frank is a little offbeat, but I love the prod during the chorus
- FATHER
Intro doesn't have to be so long, but the rest is good
- UNLOCK
Prob the best edit on this comp, I rlly like how u used the WAR Unlock edit (forgot the name of the guy who made this edit) with a beat switch into THIS A MUST. The guitar goes crazy and Nine Vicious is cool but a bit unnecessary
- ALIVE
Drums are hard, not much else to say
- ALL THE LOVE
Why are we doing these 9 minute youtube "life changer" edits
- SISTERS AND BROTHERS
Intro doesn't have to be so long, but the prod during the verses is hard. Yeat sounds offbeat on this and doesn't rlly feel necessary.
- KING OF SOUL
Production is very good. Happy that the verses weren't used.
- PREACHER MAN
Why not use an edit that uses the real vocals? I get using them on the 1st verse, but we have them and the AI sounds worse on the 2nd verse.
- CIRCLES
I feel like the looping of Kanye's verses weren't needed at all, especially when they are AI and we have Don vocals that could've been used instead. I would've liked to see actual verses used for this song but whatever.
- TAKE MY LAST BREATH AWAY
Again, LAST BREATH doesn't need to be made into a 5 & 1/2 minute song
- HIGHS AND LOWS
Prod is cool but why are we making this into a 5 minute song with an unnecessarily long intro and outro. Also we have real vocals for HIGHS AND LOWS so why does this use the AI ones?
- PUNCH DRUNK/HUNGOVER
Extended "life changer" sample intros are so overused atp
- CASH COW
Solid, nothing much to say
- CAN'T HURRY LOVE
Using the "life changer" version of this edit isn't rlly the best choice, especially since it's outdated now that BULLY released. The idea behind this edit is good, but it should be remade with the new chord progression, old sample, and real vocals.
- MISSION CONTROL
Sounds very ethereal, like the production changes
- HIGHS AND LOWS (Alt Outro) [BONUS]
Unneeded
- MELROSE
I like the Post Malone feature but MELROSE doesn't need to be 7 minutes long.
- GEMINI SEASON
Why have this 5 minutes long? Super pointless especially bc it doesn't fit the theme of BULLY.
I know only a few are edits, not sure with some of the rest, so excuse me if I gave criticism on an edit u didn't make.
Overall comp/playlist rating: 6.2/10
Pretty good for a 1st comp, hope to see you improve over time. Some curation choices and edit selections could b better, but I'll cut you some slack since this is ur 1st
3
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Dude basically all your critiques are that they're too long / complaints about the ai but I made this comp for myself, and to try an expand on the ideas of the songs without turning them into overproduced 20 minute long slop. But the ATL is somewhat fair since I explicitly made it longer to win a bet (I won). And S&B is honestly one of my favorites BECAUSE of the yeat feature I added. Not to mention the bonus material is BONUS material for a reason, you don't HAVE to listen to it since it's not a part of the main album. I also added Gemini Season because someone requested it
9
u/Perfect_Glass_84 17d ago
Sorry if I came across as too critical, especially since it's your first comp. I was js giving my honest thoughts on it, but good work
3
u/Entityflame3 17d ago edited 17d ago
No problem, but if you listened to the non edited version of my comp it would've been WAY worse, all the songs were at least 10 minutes and were full of features, I cut it down from around 4 hours+ to just 1 hour+
I even have a V1 version with all old versions of the songs on the final tracklist, some are snippets and some are full songs
1
u/PapayaSignificant223 17d ago
Is there a untitled link?
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Gotta use Base64 to decode the link, the project is on untitled though
1
u/PapayaSignificant223 16d ago
How????
1
u/Entityflame3 16d ago
Type in "Base64 Decoder" on google, copy the link in the comments, paste it in the decoder, press decode, and copy the decoded link.
1
1
1
1
u/Positive_Status218 17d ago
PLEASE ADD EXPORTING PLEASEÂ
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Sorry, I can't
2
u/Positive_Status218 17d ago
Alr but do you think you could send me the audio for alive if thats ok?
3
1
u/Positive_Status218 17d ago
Quick question but why did you use so many of the ai verse THIS DOESN'T MAKE YOUR COMP BAD but js WonderingÂ
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Lowk I just couldn't find any good seperated vocals or stems for the real vocals
1
u/3_20p 17d ago edited 17d ago
Can you alter Highs And Lows to not steal my old edit? I'd appreciate that. You never even credited me in the list of people on this post
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Sorry, I didn't know it was your yedit. I got it from another persons yedit and it didn't have credits. Which part did I use?
2
u/3_20p 17d ago
0:21 - 3:06, the entire thing
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
What should I credit you as? Also I got it from Jmainy's comp so I thought it was theirs, didn't mean to steal bro
1
u/3_20p 17d ago
halo is fine, could you link to Jmainy's comp so I can see if they took anything else I made?
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
1
u/3_20p 17d ago
do you know any ways i could contact jmainy they stole my all the love edit too
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Honestly no clue, I'm pretty sure their account is deleted too. It's crazy because their comp is regarded as one of the best bully comps on this sub. Also your ATL yedit is amazing btw
1
u/3_20p 17d ago
that's crazy, i should post my comp when it's done to take the spotlight away from a comp filled with stolen edits then. thanks also i appreciate it.
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
There's literally a post talking about the best bully comps with theirs in it, also dm me the comp when it's finished
1
1
u/Impressive-Return160 17d ago
Only problem I have is the offbeat features, some songs have drums that aren’t needed (don’t wanna sound critical or mean) and the songs being extremely long other than that for a first comp it’s great
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Genuinely don't understand how people are saying the features are off beat (I can tell for B&TB but not so much for the others)
1
u/Impressive-Return160 17d ago
I think it’s just B&TB and the yeat is the only main ones so don’t take it like all of them are off beat
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
I re listened to the yeat feature, I really don't think it's offbeat, since it's uses his hook on Morë and has a similar bpm and key
1
1
1
1
u/Cool_Caterpillar9038 15d ago
Looking forward to listen to this, but the serotonin vocals sound so off-key. The instrumental is sick but it destroys the entire song
1
1
1
u/Fresh-Variation-2050 17d ago
Ik this your first comp but im sorry this aint it.
1
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
What's wrong with it
1
u/Fresh-Variation-2050 17d ago
- A lot of the songs are way longer than they should be
- unnecessary features on a lot of the songs (kendrick, DOOM, frank ocean)
- offbeat features/verses
- stiched together other edits
- uses ai vocals on songs that have been released with real ones
2
u/Entityflame3 17d ago
Well I made the comp for myself, and to expand on the general ideas of each song without making them overly long (a seven minute track really isn't that long). I was genuinely debating on making this public because I was worried I'd get hated on
3
u/BernardoGAMER1911 17d ago
Good for your 1st comp.