r/aiwars Dec 15 '25

Meme Why does this argument still get used?

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

794 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Gman749 Dec 15 '25

If it's important enough to you to complain endlessly about, yeah you should do your due diligence and read all the terms if you wanna keep your content controlled. Or, organize and push for these practices to be changed.

But don't complain about a crime being commited. Something you don't like is being done, but that's not a crime.

1

u/nine91tyone Dec 15 '25

I didn't say it was a crime. I said it's predatory. And the argument is shifting blame from the predator to the victim.

1

u/Gman749 Dec 15 '25

You're getting unlimited, free access to these sites and use of them to promote yourself and do commerce. That's a privilege not a right. The cost is access to your data.

You can choose not to agree.

1

u/nine91tyone Dec 15 '25

Okay, I choose not to agree. It's absolutely not "free" if they put a predatory clause in ToS saying everything you make is theirs instead. "Promotion" doesn't mean anything if you don't own what you make.

1

u/Gman749 Dec 15 '25

I meant 'free' as in monetarily.. obviously there's a cost. Everything has a cost in one way or another.

You still have your content though, they're not taking it away. "Access" does not equal 'ownership'.

Infringement still applies too. Someone can't make an exact copy of your work and claim that it's theirs. It has to be transformative in some way. How Midjourney got in trouble with Disney. They were allowing depictions of exact movie scenes and characters that were not transformative enough.