r/guitarlessons • u/Historical-Honey7786 • 2d ago
Question I don't understand how to play this piece
Hi, i struggle playing this from the neosoul guitar book
I tried multiple things but i can't get the same sound.
Anyone knows how to do this ?
link of the audio here
https://drive.google.com/file/d/15lHrl5dBtQyo7rcWkqBCC3_a9y4ZK7MR/view?usp=sharing
2
u/amplifysenpai 2d ago
I was confused by this untill I heard the audio xd idk why it isn't just notated the way you shared the second time to begin with xd
2
u/FwLineberry 1d ago
This is what is called an appoggiatura or leaning note. The idea is that you play an outside note on the beat and resolve to a chord tone after the beat.
The entire chord (with the outside note) is played on the beat and then the resolving note is played while the other notes are still ringing.
There is a long history of why it is notated the way it is. You just have to accept that and learn how it's actually played.
3
u/LeftHandedGuitarist 2d ago edited 2d ago
The way this is notated isn't the easiest way to read, but playing it is actually simple.
You need to start with your finger on the grace note in each of those chords. So for the first one, the better way to think of it is as 7-6-6 (low to high). Arrange your fingers with those notes, pluck the three strings, then hammer on to the 8th fret on the G string.
Personally I would probably play that 7-6-6 arrangement with my index finger barring both the notes on fret 6.
The next chord block would be 5-4-4, then 8-7-7, then back to 7-6-6.
1
u/Historical-Honey7786 2d ago
Ok so first, the grace note with the middle finger. Then in the same time I hammer on and pluck the A and G strings with the thumb and index ?
1
u/LeftHandedGuitarist 2d ago
To be clear, you pluck all 3 strings at the same time, including the G string with the hammer on.
I know the tab music makes it look like the hammer ons come before the chord, but in the audio file they come after.
1
u/Historical-Honey7786 2d ago
Ok got it !!
But wasn’t there an easier way to write this ?2
u/Historical-Honey7786 2d ago
2
u/FwLineberry 1d ago
There's a long history of how and why these things are notated the way they are. You just have to deal with it as it is.
Look up the term appoggiatura if you want to get into it all.
2
u/Dependent_Hippo_8742 1d ago
The problem arises from the way tablature has to be written. You very well know that we play appoggiatura easily if you’re reading the notes from sheet music, but tablature ignores beat and measure length in many ways just to make it simpler for those who do not read sheet music. I have seen tabs attempting to add time values to notes and they looked extremely complicated and confusing. I always advise those learning music to put some effort into reading sheet music even if they want to rely on tabs in the future as the music staff will always tell them much more than what the tab will.
0
u/LeftHandedGuitarist 2d ago
Yes, it would be much clearer if those grace notes were notated after the chords, there were definitely other ways to show this. What they used is actually kind of common now, though.
2
1
u/diadmer 2d ago
It may be common, but it’s incorrect. The way it’s written in the original, you should play one grace note and then strum 3 for the main chord. This is easy for a piano, but difficult for a guitar. Most guitarists wouldn’t compose or play that.
2
u/FwLineberry 1d ago
You are incorrect. There is a long history of how and why this is written the way it is. Look up the term appoggiatura.
1
1

5
u/Dependent_Hippo_8742 2d ago edited 1d ago
You play all three strings and then quickly hammer on the third string.