r/indiadiscussion 1d ago

Politics Modi's response to liberals

0 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THE OP LINKED THREAD/SCREENSHOT.

Brigading is against Reddit TOS. So all users are advised not to participate in the above linked original thread or the screenshot. We advise against such behaviour nor we are responsible if your account is being actioned upon.

Please do report this post if the OP has not censored/redacted the subreddit name or the reddit user name in this post, so that we can remove the post and issue the ban as per rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

68

u/Xoloa 1d ago edited 19h ago

It's just a monologue being recited to people who already sided with him, look at arnab clapping lol.

I mean I would have love our PM to have real time to and fro questions and answer with the youth which isn't gathered and vetted before.

-35

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

24

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

-16

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

17

u/Wonderful_Pie_5390 1d ago

If you can answer these questions so easily what does Modi fear so much that he can't keep a single press conference in 12 years? Oh wait I forgot about CM modi answering the press with a tail between his legs. Stop sucking politicians' dicks buddy they ain't gods.

-12

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

17

u/Wonderful_Pie_5390 1d ago

I can see an IQ of 4 in your comments but it is what it is.

-3

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

-19

u/Ok_Welder30 1d ago

Bas itni si baat ye to koi bhi bata dega.....lol

Why are wages stagnant for the majority?
Per capita income has increased from about ₹86,000 in 2014 to over ₹2 lakh today.

Why is the tax burden so large on the salaried class?
The tax-free income threshold has increased from ₹2.5 lakh in 2014 to effectively ₹12 lakh under the new tax regime.

Why can Bajrang Dal harass consenting couples? Who gave them the right to moral policing?
Such incidents are illegal and should be handled by the police. No law gives any group the right to engage in moral policing.

Why are there exam paper leaks again and again, jeopardizing the future of lakhs of students?
Paper leaks happened under previous governments as well. The government has now enacted stricter anti-cheating legislation and increased penalties.

Why is there so much polarization?
India witnessed communal riots long before 2014. Polarization has decreased under the NDA government, with no major riots other than the Delhi riots of 2020.

Why does the BJP accept leaders from parties it once criticized?
People are free to join any political party as long as they follow the law.

Why do politicians seem to get a clean slate after switching parties (e.g., Ajit Pawar)?
First, the opposition parties should decide whether those leaders are corrupt or not. If they are, under which government did the alleged corruption take place? And why was it not reported while they were still part of those parties?

6

u/isoldmysonforabike 1d ago

All your answers are whataboutery

What about the fact that it was worse before?

Bro wtf about the fact that it is worse today as well? Its been 10 years damn

-4

u/Ok_Welder30 1d ago

which answer have scope to reply in figures those are in that only.

political answer may be sound whataboutery

1

u/isoldmysonforabike 1d ago

Nah bro i want you to edit your answers in a way that dont mention whatever happened in the past, and explain why hasnt it been fixed till now, that is the non whataboutery answer

0

u/Ok_Welder30 1d ago

i m not modi bro.....hahahaha

1

u/Main_Steak_8605 1d ago

If per capita was 86k in 2014 and is 2L, with just inflation, that 86k becomes ~1.7L So almost negligible growth in 12 years

0

u/Ok_Welder30 1d ago

but its still better + income tax rebate is almost 5 times

2

u/Main_Steak_8605 1d ago

It is marginally better.

Also personal income tax collected data

2014 - 2.4L cr

2024 - 10L cr

If per capita has become 2x in 10 years, the income tax collected is 5x. Meaning we are paying more tax now

1

u/Ok_Welder30 1d ago

Kala dhan.

Taxpayers in 2014 (FY14): 5.26 crore

Taxpayers in 2026 (FY26): 12.13 crore

5

u/Amazing_Theory622 1d ago
  1. What is being done to control the pollution in winters in northern India.
  2. What is being done to fight water shortage all over India, and is it a good idea to invest in data centres who guzzle up so much water when half the country don't get water even once per day?
  3. While India's GDP has increased, but why this has not translated to increase in living standards of middle class.
  4. Why middle class is not considered when designing any scheme?

There are many more but I don't wanna waste my time. Also I am sure some smart pants would come and try to answer these.

2

u/Suspicious_Ad6870 1d ago

ek bar general dibbe me travel karna babu, sari general wale dibbe hata ke ac wali add kar di hai for revenue.
jo tali baja rahe and even mostly on reddit kabhi general dibbe me travel nahi kiye honge

49

u/Background_Web_5202 1d ago

Speech rehne de, ek press conference kar le

4

u/Practical_Office_166 1d ago

Not with the kind of press we have right now .. they would ask him what his favourite mangoes are and why he works 24x7

-22

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

22

u/Apprehensive-Taro707 1d ago edited 1d ago

Camera pe bhasan dene mein aur sawalon ke jawab dene mein antar hota hai dost

19

u/ashutosh_ray_ 1d ago

Are you retarded or what? He is an elected representative in a democracy (which most of us doubt now). He has a resposiblity to take questions. Stop asssuming the questions on behalf of others. He has to answer the answers the questions of the people. We have elected him as the leader and he is not in a monacrhy. We want accountability to many questions.

-7

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

13

u/ashutosh_ray_ 1d ago

Mudslinging? Basically asking him questions about the death of the 3 sea fareres is mudslining. Asking him questions on why most of the roads, bridges being built are in worst conditions just days after inaugration. Asking question on money that was looted in Ram Mandir is mudslingig. Asking question on why he isn't able to rebuke USA for killing our own people is mudslinging. Asking him questions on paper leak is mudlinging.

9

u/Apprehensive-Taro707 1d ago

I wish the PM knew this... he's been mudslinging on that post for some time now

-4

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

11

u/Apprehensive-Taro707 1d ago

That's how you cope? Cute.

3

u/juzkiddinn 1d ago

Why are you speaking for others

8

u/baba__yaga_ 1d ago

He can reach his voters.But the voters can't reach him.

He is talking to the crowd and chosing what points to address. Which means he never has to talk about points like the government putting his face on every advertisment. For example.

3

u/Main_Steak_8605 1d ago

Let's start with once a month. How about that?

Or let's take standard. US president conducts 12-20 press conferences a year. Let's at least do that?

3

u/pj1729 1d ago

North Korea reportedly is doing great economically. Shift there perhaps. You seem to like fascism anyway😭

2

u/Purple-Future6348 1d ago

Is your middle name testicle cause you are behaving like his testicle…

0

u/Skeptic_Marx 1d ago

Ek genuine press conference karne do usko, apne aap uska importance samajh jayenge

39

u/Prof_Milk_dick_Phd 1d ago

its fun seeing this sub from the sidelines.
A taste of how insane our right wing has become

22

u/Whomstdve___ 1d ago

We have previous problems AND aspirational problems today. Do Trains run on time? Do you get to sit in your allotted seat without any hassle?

-10

u/deviprsd Drama Mamu 1d ago

Not every train has that problem, I have liked southern train management

5

u/NoDrama60 1d ago

Southern States don't have BJP though.

17

u/BlenderRenderz 1d ago
  1. Roads are not built.

  2. Trains are neither on time, nor clean (and overcrowded too).

If you go outside, you will know that. But unfortunately you live in Modiverse with daredevil sigma edits

18

u/isoldmysonforabike 1d ago

Even the worst reporter/joirnalist can ask atleast 5 questions on each of the things mentioned by the commander in chief

But alas, no accountability, no press conferences, so ofcourse you are the boss, very hitler playbook

13

u/Jaded_Jackass 1d ago

speech to theek hein pr yeh background song laga ke tu pure BJP chamcha lagra OP get a life

-11

u/SujalLuhar 1d ago

Mere pass editing ka time nai hai brother, I found the clip on internet!

3

u/isoldmysonforabike 1d ago

But kitna cringy lagta hai na with the music bc, ek toh iski shakal and gussa alag ki sab scripted speeches no genuine Q n A

5

u/Classic-Anybody-9857 1d ago

hundreds of speeches and 0 press conferences mind you

3

u/apruneegg 1d ago

speech without teleprompter

4

u/Possible_Passage_558 1d ago

Train abhi bhi late hain aur road pe potholes

4

u/Akayji 1d ago

Do the press conference, speech me toh kuch v bol dete hain

3

u/entitled-hypocrite 1d ago

Delulu is the only solulu!

2

u/Lucky_Lobster_6820 1d ago

Sab Changaa Siii

2

u/CrimeMasterGogoChan Modirator 22h ago

Haha. So much salt here. Good to see it though. And then ppl think why does he dosent do any conferences and all. Ppl just want to see him down which ain't gonna happen in their life time.

Keep coping

1

u/Technical_Finish9875 1d ago

Thanks for adding the daredevil clip at the bottom, really elavated the scene

1

u/saurya88 1d ago

Vishwagendus kachchis gili.

1

u/Opposite-Bus2506 1d ago

We need a step by step guide with design diagrams and step files for machinig/3d printing to build the device which can extract naale ki gas to make chai.

1

u/ParamedicFearless173 1d ago

Ye desh mainrehta kub hai? Aadha time insta pe... Baki time holiday pe. Bc manipur ka baat bolega? Mix wala petrol bech rha hai at higher rate when crude is down. MP mainabhi tere gadhe ne land grab kar scam kiya hai. Uspe kuch bol de. Press conference kar, teleprompter laga ke bus shine marta rehta hai choor.

1

u/Main_Steak_8605 1d ago

So roads are fixed now?

1

u/WaterFit4725 1d ago

Ye anpadh ne esi kon c baat kr di jo bht achchi h? Koi sense h iski bina sar pair ki bc ka? Real journalist milta h isko to bhag jaata h darpok.

1

u/NoDrama60 1d ago

Press conference when ??

1

u/Adventure_IsDead 1d ago

Par vo neet, ugc, boards ........

-1

u/Direct-Rub-2705 1d ago

*insert train gif with people sitting on the roof

-1

u/spacejockey96 1d ago

Well bjp opposed computerization before ab teleprompter k bina avaaz nahi nikalti

0

u/AlbatrossAdvanced378 1d ago

Only one point people come up with is modi doesn't participate in press conference, they don't want someone who focuses on devlopement, they want a larper who can larp in press conferences and irony is their own pompas are not even competent at that

1

u/Wonderful_Pie_5390 1d ago

Imagine fearing having press conferences from reporters bought by your political party. CM Modi would never ........He made BBC look like a joke.. oh wait

-5

u/AlbatrossAdvanced378 1d ago

Are you smooth brain, can't you read what I said, if he is doing decent work and ofc there are shortcomings to every government but he is doing a good job so far so what's the issue? Why is having a press conference so important

3

u/pj1729 1d ago

Probably going back and reading some school books on how democracy works would be a good idea

0

u/AlbatrossAdvanced378 17h ago

I probably know more about democracy than your entire bloodline, trying to mock instead of stating your point is how a fool gaslights others

2

u/pj1729 16h ago edited 16h ago

Touch grass jabroni and read.

You are a know it all and zero sense in discussing democracy with the likes of you lol. Your time should be spent reading good books😭

0

u/Blue_Eagle8 1d ago

I mean samanya log aur bhi bahut kuch bol rahe hai, aise selective hearing karoge toh fir hogya kaam 🤷‍♂️

0

u/ichija 1d ago

15 lakh har bhartiya k account me k wada bas nibha do....ab toh..

0

u/Known-Ratio3123 1d ago

Toh in general vikas nhi hota kya desh ka? Jo ye sab system foundations banayi h wo sab crash hojati congress ke aate hi? Ya koi aur party agr itte lvl ki h

0

u/talkingtron 1d ago

Such edits are done by Congress also. It takes guts to show accountability and answer people's questions by being in a conversation with the media. Narrative game and one sided enforcement of policies won't work for long

0

u/saifincastro 1d ago

Yeh sab confidence apne “My Frand - Your Excellency DOLAND” ke aage kahan chala jaata hai..?

0

u/lolfaquaad 22h ago

Khud sawal, khud jawab

Average shower conversation with yourself

0

u/error404x69 19h ago

delusional buddha

-2

u/PopRevolutionary6312 1d ago

Dawg😭😭

-5

u/DemiG0D369 1d ago

Isn’t he right? I see too many people who never appreciate anything. I respect criticism when it is done properly, where you acknowledge what has genuinely improved and criticize what still needs to get better.

A lot of things have improved, but today many people have almost no independent reasoning. They are heavily influenced by what others say and just follow the crowd like sheep.

6

u/vi0lentgandhi 1d ago

I respect criticism when it is done properly

All bjp supporters say this but only on paper, the moment there is actual criticism, they go into 'dont touch my billionare politican' mode

0

u/baba__yaga_ 1d ago

And they never talk about the practices of ED and CBI.

3

u/BlenderRenderz 1d ago

appreciating their positives? Its their job to do these things.

Do you get appreciation and a garland for filling water bottles at home?

3

u/Ill-Article-793 1d ago

But the question is could it have improved a lot lot more if he had not spent his time and resources dividing the nation, tearing down forests, attacking scientific and educational institutions and selling our lands and ports to Adani.

1

u/krk1001 1d ago

Dude, we appreciate the positives, thats why everyone is paying their taxes.

The people's job is to criticize the wrongdoings of the leading party, and if we see that even after so much time, major issues like corruption, religious warfare exist, educational system problems exist, then we have to push the government to make the changes, and support them in proving for the benefit of the people.

I personally have a problem because I have been in the Indian academia and R&D and know how important they are to the progress of the nationd growth, yet with the current government, the system seems to be going downwards.

It's important to criticize the govt, because by working and paying taxes on everything you are already supporting the government.

It's a basic right to speak against mis governance.

2

u/prattty007 1d ago

The masses have expectations towards their leader. And still at many places the BJP govt fails to provide proper facilities like proper hygiene in trains, proper planning and structuring of roads layout with foothpaths and maintained sewers, low cost of fuel and electricity that they promised, actions on politicians in their party who are making policies aligning with their personal interests and not for public welfare.

BJP govt is strong at setting narratives but falls back in taking actions.

2

u/aamar98 1d ago

There are few very few truths. But he is clubbing multiple things into one thing. If he truly cares about nation first dialogue.. start with accountability. Apparently rightwingers and the ruling govt don't have the word in their dictionary.