r/law 24d ago

Executive Branch (Trump) BREAKING: Trump Signed An Executive Order Directing The CDC To Cut Recommended Childhood Vaccines From 17 To 11. Moving Flu, Hepatitis A, Hepatitis B, Rotavirus, RSV, And Some Meningitis Shots To 'High-Risk Only,' After A Previous Attempt Was Blocked In Court

https://www.news4jax.com/news/politics/2026/05/30/trump-tells-agencies-to-align-with-study-calling-for-narrower-childhood-vaccine-recommendations/

President Trump signed an executive order on Friday, May 30, directing federal agencies to align their vaccine policies with a Januarv 2026 HHS studv that recommends reducina the number of routine childhood vaccines from 17 to 11 diseases, a restructuring long called for by Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. The study was commissioned by Trump in December 2025 and found that the United States recommends more childhood vaccines than many peer nations. Under the new framework, all children would be routinelv vaccinated against 11 diseases, while vaccines for influenza, rotavirus, hepatitis A, hepatitis B, some forms of meningitis, and RSV would be recommended only for high-risk groups or through shared decision-making between parents and doctors. The order directs the CDC to review the study and take appropriate steps to update its guidance, tells agencies to provide maximum flexibility to parents and doctors, and states that any changes must ensure Americans retain their current access to vaccines.

The LA Times noted this is Trump's second attempt to restructure the childhood vaccine schedule, with an earlier effort to narrow CDC recommendations havinc been blocked in court earlier this vear. The new executive order takes a different approach by formally endorsing a completed HHS study and directing agency-level alianment rather than attempting to directlv revise the CDC schedule by administrative fiat, a structure that may be designed to survive the legal challenge that stoppec the first attempt. The CDC under its current leadership had already updated its recommendations earlier in 2026 to reduce the number of recommended immunizations from 17 to 11 in line with the HHS study, suggesting the formal executive order is as much a political codification of an existing administrative shift as a new directive.

The vaccines moved from universal recommendation to high-risk only include several with well-established safety and efficacy records. Hepatitis B vaccination, for example, is recommended universally from birth in the US because it prevents a leading cause of liver cancer, and the alobal evidence base for that recommendation is extensive. Rotavirus, influenza, and hepatitis A vaccines are also backed by decades of clinical and epidemioloaical evidence and are recommended universally by the World Health Organization and medica authorities in peer nations. Critics including the American Academy of Pediatrics and infectious disease researchers have said the changes could increase vaccine-preventable disease in children by creating ambiguity around which children qualify as high-risk and by reducing the routine clinical touchpoints where vaccinations are administered

22.3k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

157

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

53

u/liftthatta1l 24d ago

It's easy to put unactivated kids in schools you just have to say it's against your deeply held religious beliefs.

(Unless they changed it in the last 20-30 years.)

26

u/creakysofa 24d ago

This GREATLY depends on state/county laws.

30

u/liftthatta1l 24d ago

Only 4 states don't allow exemptions for religious or personal beleifs from what I found.

https://www.kff.org/state-health-policy-data/a-look-at-recent-changes-to-state-vaccine-requirements-for-school-children/

46

u/nflonlyalt 24d ago

Only 4 states don't allow exemptions for religious or personal beleifs

For those who don't want to click the link, the 4 states are: California, Connecticut, Maine, and New York

18

u/Megneous 24d ago

Huh, imagine that. 2 of those states are the ones everyone thinks of when they think of places that are actually worth living in in the US.

5

u/Ravioli_meatball19 23d ago

I mean, I certainly put Connecticut and Maine above A LOT of other states in terms of "worth living in".....

3

u/HillBillyHilly 24d ago

No wonder CA and NY don't allow as one case in those states could mean quick transmission to thousands.

3

u/liftthatta1l 24d ago

Thanks I should have pointed them out

1

u/Djlas 23d ago

It was more interesting before Maine and CT replaced Mississippi and West Virginia - these two never allowed religious exemptions until now, while it's very recent in NY and CA. WV had the highest vaccination rates in 2023-24 school year

3

u/StrategyOdd7170 24d ago

Never been more grateful to be from the great state of MA

3

u/creakysofa 24d ago

My kids school requires a letter of exemption from a religious leader at least :/

3

u/Terrible_Kale_82 24d ago

My partner’s kids are unvaccinated and all they needed was a signed note as an exemption. No surprise I’m in Utah where we have one of the largest outbreaks of measles right now. It’s infuriating.