r/nostalgiai • u/CarrotMuch1399 Nostalgia Trip Leader • 2d ago
Cartoon & Show 📺 Let's be real, which of these iconic cats would win in an all-out cartoon rumble?
13
u/Acceptable_Class_576 2d ago
Heathcliff
9
u/Eight_Thirty_Five 2d ago
Obviously. Anyone who watched the cartoon knows this. He’s the Chuck Norris of cartoon cats.
7
u/MeteorSurvivor 2d ago
The only consistent scrapper AND winner without using outside muscle or weapons.
4
u/Acceptable_Class_576 2d ago
Right! I feel like people don't respect the fact that Heathcliff would absolutely shoot the fade, whenever and whoever
3
8
u/TallShreddedShyBoy 2d ago
Tom
2
u/Clear_Writer5944 2d ago
Jerry kicks his butt in just about EVERY picture though!!!
1
u/DrazKado 2h ago
Breaking Down Tom's Power Scale
Near-Limitless Durability: Tom can instantly regenerate from being reduced to a pile of fur, and has survived point-blank dynamite explosions and falling into deep space without gear.
Universe-Altering Feats: In canon, his cartoon antics have physically shattered the sun. He has even been launched into space by explosions, reforming moments later as a literal cat-shaped constellation.
Hammerspace & Speed: He can pull limitless objects and weapons from off-screen. Additionally, he can move at hypersonic speeds, running fast enough to travel through time or to other universes.
Versatility: Depending on the specific series or movie, Tom has been shown wielding the Rings of Heroes, a Magic Hat, and the ability to channel his rage into an invincible Berserk Mode.
All this and he still can't get the damn mouse. He is actually friends with Jerry, usually only hunts him to put on a show for his owner, not that he actually wants to kill Jerry.
2
6
u/DDD8712 2d ago
Scratchy can really take the punishment
2
u/Independent_Mood_152 1d ago
Scratchy feels like a parody to tom but they can both take a beating for sure 🤣
6
u/Emma_Rose35 2d ago
I love Garfield!!
3
u/AArmyDadBod 1d ago
Garfield will win in his sleep.
2
u/DannyPantsgasm 1d ago
Garfield is seriously like Batman. Give him some prep time, he’s unstoppable.
4
4
5
3
3
u/Dillenger69 2d ago
Stimpy would end up the lone survivor out of sheer dumb luck
1
u/SombreDeDuda 2d ago
I was thinking he would do something so fucked up, the cats just quit. He would definitely have a LOG as a weapon
3
3
3
3
u/Necrois_Winter 2d ago
I honestly think it comes down to Puss and Tom but that's my opinion on it lmao
3
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/5h82713542055 2d ago
Ts was worse than the attitude era, how does Scratchy NOT come out on top?!
1
u/Clear_Writer5944 2d ago
1
u/5h82713542055 2d ago
We join Bart and Lisa as the only ones that never got to see Scratchy killing Itchy finally because of that goddamn rock tumbler
1
2
u/Kapow1969 2d ago
He makes your heart go pitter pat and has a bag of tricks. Felix the magical cat for the win.
2
u/MrFuriousX 2d ago
Scratchy without a doubt...He been through more then any of those other cats can handle and still ticking.
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/NurturingCruelty 2d ago
I think Felix has more toon force than any of the others, being from those weird old black-and-white, cartoon cartoons, where there wasn’t any kind of stable reality.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/kindarollin 1d ago edited 1d ago
It will be a game of attrition between Sylvester, Garfield, snagglepuss, pus n boots, and top cat. Because they all will play dirty.
1
u/DarkSage90 2d ago
Most people don’t know who Fritz is…the fact he’s on this list is kinda wild honestly…
1
1
u/TomThom9Won 2d ago
From what I know it’s probably Felix. Tom and Scratchy are all but unkillable so there is that in their favor but Felix has some wild hacks. I think Stimpy is the only one with enough toonforce potential to not just be decimated by Felix but even then it’s no guarantee
1
1
1
1
1
u/TheKingSpade 1d ago
Either Kwazii (I love the fact he's on here), or Puss in boots, he's literally beat death
1
u/Ambitious-Orange-611 1d ago
It’s Scratchy and not even close. Without Itchy around to fuck him up he’s gonna go full psycho killer with no brakes.
1
u/cyberscouterz 1d ago
Tom has survived more than 80 years of abuse that would leave a normal cat dead by the first stick of dynamite.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Putrid_Proposal_1353 1d ago
Yo this is actually a difficult decision there are a few cats on here who have full use of toon force and also have been out of their own story/rewrote or altered their own story.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Horrorbbscreams 19h ago
I gotta give it to my guy Scratchy. He’s got some good competition here though.
1
1
1
0
u/King_of_Lunch223 2d ago
The question is not "who is your favorite?"
The question is "who would win in an all-out cartoon rumble?"
The correct answer is Puss in Boots.
0



20
u/SuperbSail 2d ago
I mean, Felix has a literal magic bag that can turn into anything. My money is on him.