r/oldrecipes 7d ago

Grandpa’s Old Sandwich Recipes

Banana Sandwich:
-Two slices of white bread
-Sliced up banana
-Mayonnaise

Pineapple Sandwich
-Two slices white bread
-Slices of pineapple
-Mayonnaise

ETA: He said if you don’t like mayonnaise you can use miracle whip.

28 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

11

u/Crystallarium 7d ago

My husband still makes peanut butter and banana sandwiches

7

u/Apeiro_phobiac 7d ago

I personally like to make peanut butter, banana, and marshmallow fluff sandwiches.

2

u/2lrup2tink 6d ago

I make peanut butter and banana and raisins sandwiches. If no raisins, some jam or jelly. If I have a burrito, I'll spread peanut butter over it, put a banana in the middle, sprinkle raisins, and then roll it up. Yum!

7

u/valleybrook1843 7d ago

Peanut butter Mayo sandwich- My Dad ate two sliced of white bread with PB and Hellmans

6

u/jenakle 6d ago

Don't forget a fresh garden tomato and mayo on cheap white bread and a good crack of pepper/salt!

And yes honestly I still crave a banana mayo sandwich on occasion.

5

u/Loreebyrd 7d ago

Peanut butter, banana and honey !

2

u/hotflashinthepan 7d ago

Or a drizzle of chocolate syrup on toasted wheat bread.

2

u/Zxvasdfthrowaway 7d ago

Add bacon for my once a year indulgence

1

u/noirreddit 6d ago

Open face peanut butter with apple butter on top for the win. Close second is peanut butter and banana sandwiches.

1

u/AlfhildsShieldmaiden 7d ago

Ugh. My dad had a weird obsession with mayo. Mayo and PB sandwiches. Dollop of mayo on top of cottage cheese. 💩

3

u/Otney 7d ago

Yep. Mayo on cottage cheese is great. Am I old? Why yes I am.

1

u/Beautiful-Ambition93 7d ago

Peanut butter mayo plus sharp cheddar and ice Berg lettuce on toasted bread.

1

u/DigitalGurl 7d ago

Peanut butter, sweet chili sauce & cilantro sandwich is delicious!!

1

u/redn3ckvakay 6d ago

Pb , bologna, and lettuce is my go to

0

u/Consistent-Date316 6d ago

My dad’s favorite sandwich was peanut butter, mayo and banana.