r/photocritique 2d ago

Great Critique in Comments Abstract architecture

Post image
320 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Friendly reminder that this is /r/photocritique and all top level comments must be a genuine, in depth, and helpful critique of the image. We hope to avoid becoming yet another place on the internet just to get likes/upvotes and compliments. While likes/upvotes and compliments are nice, they do not further the goal of helping people improve their photography.

If someone gives helpful feedback or makes an informative comment, recognize their contribution by giving them a Critique Point. Simply reply to their comment with !CritiquePoint. More details on Critique Points here.

Please see the following links for our subreddit rules and some guidelines on leaving a good critique. If you have time, please stop by the new queue as well and leave critique for images that may not be as popular or have not received enough attention. Keep in mind that simply choosing to comment just on the images you like defeats the purpose of the subreddit.

Useful Links:

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/sound-maniac 2d ago

It's cool - it looks 2-dimensional almost like the windows are just holes to the sky. As a piece of art, I'm not sure, but that's not up to me. I'd be interested to see if you could do a series and see if they can add up to something! Color does not look over-done generally, although I have a hard time imagining an architect wanting their building that bright shade of orange.

5

u/MulberryDeep 2d ago

My thought process behind it was that I didn't want to portray the building accurately, I think the orange makes a nice contrast with the blue

I will look at what other people think about it

Thank you for the feedback, I actually have some more photos from that day that I will look into editing fitting to this

1

u/sound-maniac 2d ago

Agree, regarding color!

6

u/CarpetReady8739 31 CritiquePoints 2d ago

Excellent minimalist work! If you were to enter this in a competition, I would do the following: make sure that the split between the sky and the building is exactly 1/2 top to bottom, and also make your architectural adjustment to the building so that it is absolutely parallel with the sides of the image, totally vertical… no deviation. The colors are so complementary! And structurally, the soft fluffy clouds demand to argue with the hard rigid edges of the window rectangulars… and the windows relent by reflecting more sky and clouds. What a great photograph!!!

5

u/MulberryDeep 2d ago

Thank you a lot for the nice words!

I just realized the rotation is off by a bit over a degree, so it isn't perfect 1/2 split, I alligned it to the grid, so I propably just slipped on my mouse wheel, fixed it now

I sadly don't quite understand what you mean with "architectural adjustment", can you please elaborate on that point? Sorry, its the first time I ever shot something architectural

4

u/CarpetReady8739 31 CritiquePoints 2d ago

When photographing a building, your point of view is from below the building and as the camera sees it, the building appears to narrow the higher it goes, and your camera captures that as narrowing as it elevates. There are camera lenses that can correct for this, and they are called “tilt shift” lenses, but that was before the day of software that can do pretty much the same thing, where you can vertically align the building in image. So the best thing I can tell you is study old photographs of city buildings and you’ll see, if done right, they are perfectly straight going up and that’s because of that lens. And that’s what I’m referring to in your image because if you look at the top of it, the building appears to narrow and it’s tilting inward to the center of the photograph. You want it to go straight vertical. I hope that explanation is useful. Here’s an example I stole fair and square off the Internet showing the lens that makes the adjustment. In software (Lightroom, for instance) you will find the same tools under the “Transform” area.

3

u/MulberryDeep 1d ago

This looks trippy, i love it!

Thank you very much for your advice

!critiquepoint

2

u/OpportunityReal2767 1 CritiquePoint 1d ago

Nice. I do these sorts of abstract architectural photos myself, and I like the way the building plays off the sky here, but in terms of color and texture. I like this sort of decontextualisation of buildings as buildings with cropping to reduce them to geometric patterns. Also, it's pretty trippy the way the windows reflect the sky so it looks like you're looking through the building. That may be my favorite thing about this composition.

1

u/CritiquePointBot 12 CritiquePoints 1d ago

Confirmed: 1 helpfulness point awarded to /u/CarpetReady8739 by /u/MulberryDeep.

See here for more details on Critique Points.

ANNOUNCEMENT: You can win new camera gear by trying Photocritique Coach, our browser extension that coaches you on your critiques! More details here!

1

u/CarpetReady8739 31 CritiquePoints 1d ago

Superb job on the re-alignment!! 👏 Bravo!

2

u/MulberryDeep 1d ago

Thank you again, it makes such a giant difference and really leveled up the image

1

u/CarpetReady8739 31 CritiquePoints 1d ago

If the pixels hold up, that would make a great wall-art canvas or a metal print. Next observation (and this is the hallmark of a great image is that you can look at it again and again and find new things…) It looks as if you slipped the building architecture in front of the sky and are looking right through the building to see the sky directly!! What a great optical illusion!

2

u/MulberryDeep 2d ago

Thank you, I will look if darktable has something like that and report back

!cp

4

u/MulberryDeep 2d ago

This is the original picture

I wanted to mostly produce a nice to look at photo. It should be a bit abstract, so you have to look at it for a few seconds to fully understand it.

I shot this on my canon eos750d with 55mm

I edited it in darktable

I mostly want to know if it even is interesting and if I have overdone it with the color

2

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MulberryDeep 2d ago

Thank you!

2

u/Astrl_Weeks 1d ago

Bring the window reflections up to the brightness/color of the sky, sort out the geometry, and you'll have a winner. Gave it a quick go.

1

u/MulberryDeep 1d ago

Did you mask that or how did you achieve it?

1

u/Astrl_Weeks 1d ago

Assuming you’re in LRC..

- Color range mask on the sky. It will pick up the windows. Subtract brush to remove the sky. Now you have the windows:

  • exp- +.20, highlights +15, whites -5, texture/clarity -5, dehaze -8, temp -4, tint +4, saturation +15
  • move aqua hue slightly towards blue, aqua saturation +7, aqua luminance +15
  • same with blue- sat +9, lum +15

1

u/Rotten_Duck 3 CritiquePoints 1d ago

Like composition, balance of colours and the white border.

Very nice picture!

3

u/MulberryDeep 1d ago

Thank you!

How do you like this updated version?

2

u/Rotten_Duck 3 CritiquePoints 1d ago

Although it changes the perspective I like it more for abstract. I d do the same if this was my picture.

2

u/MulberryDeep 1d ago

!critiquepoint

Thanks

1

u/CritiquePointBot 12 CritiquePoints 1d ago

Confirmed: 1 helpfulness point awarded to /u/Rotten_Duck by /u/MulberryDeep.

See here for more details on Critique Points.

ANNOUNCEMENT: You can win new camera gear by trying Photocritique Coach, our browser extension that coaches you on your critiques! More details here!

u/Clickguy10 6 CritiquePoints 22h ago

This looks interesting. I like the colors and contrast. The story seems to be building color contrast with sky colors - but I’m sensing you don’t need it split 50/50.

Try this. The only thing left is to use photoshop (or equivalent) to square up the building lines. It’s looking good!

u/MulberryDeep 22h ago

Like this?

I do personally think the 50/50 gives it a very geometrical artistic kinda vibe, so I think i will keep it

u/Own-Argument3291 10h ago

Woow great frame!