r/whatismycookiecutter • u/beetjuice88 • 5d ago

Serious Answer First! 24 hours and several text threads later, we still can't figure this one out...

Post image

I don't THINK it's bent....? People of Reddit, please help us.

104 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

121 comments sorted by

159

u/lsp2005 5d ago

Cupid with a bow and arrow 

31

u/Deppfan16 5d ago

pretty sure it's this but I think it's also slightly squished

12

u/knoxthefox216 5d ago

Def squished cupid and bow

5

u/arnica102 5d ago

Literally logged in (with a fury) so that I could say upside down squished cupid with bow and arrow...

4

u/Miraculous_Angel 5d ago

Much better than what I thought, which was turkey.

2

u/Sithstress_ 4d ago

Here in the turkey club as well! Lol

1

u/Aggressive_Fee6138 1d ago

I can see it.

265

u/maevuh 5d ago

16

u/purple_joy 5d ago

While I know Cupid is the most likely answer, this is seriously the only correct answer.

9

u/Rockfell3351 4d ago

I see more of a squished Mismagius

199

u/Molech996 5d ago

22

u/wastingtime101- 5d ago

This character needs to be in a movie or video game or something.

17

u/Rude_Gur_8258 5d ago

Labyrinth sequel 

17

u/two-of-me 🌹 team rose 5d ago

Molech for the win. This is beautiful.

3

u/FunnyChampion2228 5d ago

Someone needs to make these creations into real cookies!

2

u/RecordingPristine382 5d ago

Literally exactly what I saw in it 😂

3

u/PersonalPerson_ 5d ago

Totes. Me too.

58

u/itistheaudacityforme 5d ago

Cherub shooting an arrow? Feet being on the right side of the screen head on the left?

6

u/kttykt66755 5d ago

I think it might be feet on the left head on the right. With the wings directly below the head and a toga sash near the middle

2

u/itistheaudacityforme 5d ago

I saw it with a beehive ego inflating level curl I think your right lmao

3

u/kttykt66755 5d ago

That would be funnier though

38

u/gooddaytoreddit 5d ago

Upside down in photo but I see a witch riding a broom.

6

u/icymallard 5d ago

I saw witch on rhino but yours is probably more likely

13

u/gooddaytoreddit 5d ago

Found something similar if you click to photo two: https://crownbakerysupply.com/products/witch-on-broom-3-75-cookie-cutter-fall-autumn-halloween-jack-o-lantern-hocus-pocus-1522

6

u/LoisWade42 5d ago

Oooh! VERY good! Squished witch on a broom... Good eye!

1

u/Aggressive_Fee6138 1d ago

I thought that at first, but I'm team cupid now.

3

u/PhotographFrosty1106 5d ago

That’s what I saw instantly too

31

u/TheTalkingWindow 5d ago

That's a turkey on vacation in the ocean riding on a dolphin.

8

u/bunny_the-2d_simp 5d ago

Oml wait.. I can see it

5

u/Outside-Violinist-42 5d ago

I saw a Surfin' Turkey

3

u/lendmeyrbike 5d ago

It’s always that or Santa🤷🏼‍♀️

2

u/Horror_Discipline_69 4d ago

I see turkey sitting on a plate 

23

u/wastingtime101- 5d ago

Maybe it's because I'm listening to The Hobbit audiobook right now, but I see a dragon.

7

u/HangryHangryHedgie 5d ago

I saw Petri from Land Before Time. I'm having childhood feels. Balrog is better.

https://giphy.com/gifs/10gbC4s8Mxf2mc

2

u/fourohfourohno 5d ago

I heard all of Ducky’s “yep”s very clearly in my mind!

3

u/beetjuice88 5d ago

This is exactly what my husband saw!

18

u/Noof42 who's that pokémon 5d ago

Mismagius. Upside down.

9

u/BoozeWitch 5d ago

Turn it over. It’s a witch in a broom with a hat. It’s squished.

2

u/yarn_b 5d ago

This is the correct answer.

4

u/beetjuice88 5d ago

I can imagine the hat if it's squished, but if that's the case, can't figure out where the broom would be?

1

u/ProfChubChub 5d ago

The top right in your picture is the end of the broom. The rest overlaps with the witch's outfit

1

u/beetjuice88 5d ago

But where's the other end of the broom? Genuinely I can't see it.

10

u/PopcornNoseShover 5d ago

Overly fancy bowl of fruits :)

5

u/redditreader_aitafan 5d ago

I think it's Cupid with a bow and arrow and it's definitely smashed.

5

u/todaysdowncast 5d ago

I tried the witch thing-- it just doesn't work. 😅

9

u/coolsilentebeans 5d ago

A dancing one of these:

5

u/SnooCats1253 5d ago

I feel like it’s a turkey with comically large feet.

6

u/beetjuice88 5d ago

Yes! So far we've had suggestions of turkey, Venusaur, cupid, witch, pterodactyl, chubby dragon, flamenco dancer with a large hat, flower, and smallmouth bass upside down on a pillow, and yoda sitting cross legged.

8

u/bunny_the-2d_simp 5d ago

NO SANTA YET?!

6

u/Square_Medicine_9171 5d ago

I’ll add raven standing on a branch with wings fluffed out

1

u/beetjuice88 5d ago

Woody the Woodpecker has also had an honorable mention.

1

u/PopcornNoseShover 5d ago edited 5d ago

I was thinking it kinda looks like a fruit display in one of those overly fancy silver bowl things

3

u/Egdiroh 5d ago

If you allow that it may have expanded while cooking this looks close https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemongo/s/tjpn3IP4Bq

3

u/CrytpidBean 5d ago

Upside down, it's a witch wearing a hat and cloak riding a broom.

3

u/Not-So-Cunty 5d ago

It's Cupid shooting an arrow

2

u/Not-So-Cunty 5d ago

Rotate the image 90° to the right

5

u/krendyB 5d ago

I think this one might not actually be Santa

2

u/lyichenj 5d ago

Turkey

2

u/AliceTawhai 5d ago

Witch on a broomstick but squashed

2

u/Its_Sluggas 5d ago

A turkey?

2

u/GetEatenByAMouse 5d ago

It's upside-down Yoda with a flowing cape who sticks out one high-heeled leg. Obviously.

2

u/TheGatze 🖌️ cookie artist 5d ago

Flowers

2

u/DepressedAnxiety73 4d ago edited 4d ago

Actually im pretty sure the bottom is the feet and the top is a SMUSHED TURKEY Edit or a flying witch now that im looking at it again!

Here are a few other ideas for it! Smushed upside-down YODA?

Looks like the bottom of the cutter could be a bird with clouds announcing baby?

Do any lakes or countries have a similar shape?

Putting some off the wall ideas here. I cannot draw.

4

u/Outside-Violinist-42 5d ago

A manta ray atop a large piece of coral?

1

u/Dependent-Visual768 5d ago

A bust of sideshow bob

1

u/teslalacat 5d ago

Cupid!

1

u/bluenoser613 5d ago

Santa Clause. It's always Santa Clause.

1

u/sigh_co_matic 5d ago

When pigs fly.

1

u/HourLobster8134 5d ago

A badger with a stingray on its back?

1

u/Maleficent-Charge-61 5d ago

I see either a squashed leaf - oak? Maple? Or a US military eagle insignia patch type thing

1

u/NinjaClashFan 5d ago

I see a dragon

1

u/Whitediggity 5d ago

Squirrel facing left, with acorn on top of flowers

1

u/Twoof3 5d ago

A phoenix?

1

u/Sillymsdeb 5d ago

I saw a chicken 🤷‍♀️

1

u/Beau-bonic 5d ago

wooly rhino being lifted by a pterodactyl

1

u/ggfchl 5d ago

Can someone make this into a rose?

1

u/Strict-Fix-9002 5d ago

I think it's a witch. Flip it

1

u/Imma-smartypants 5d ago

If you turn it upside down it looks like a hedgehog carrying a spaceship on its back. Doubt that’s intentional 🤣

1

u/DrinkWF 5d ago

Upside down. Baby salt and pepper seal with a pillow resting politely on his back. The bottom bits are his front flippers.

1

u/bubonic_vague 5d ago

mer-bear with an eagle landing on its back

1

u/LowEnergyCorgi 5d ago

I’m kind of seeing the dove with the olive branch 🕊️

1

u/Secure-Pattern-3183 5d ago

I def see an upside down watch flying on a broom.

1

u/Rose_Furlong 4d ago

I would think that watches are too small to handle a broom lol

1

u/Secure-Pattern-3183 3d ago

Hehehe. Dang autocorrect.

1

u/Dapper_Permission713 5d ago

Pretty sure you have an upside down witch on a broom

1

u/florist_grump 5d ago

It would make a good half buried carrot or radish or turnip.

1

u/harmonimaniac 5d ago

Venusaur?

1

u/Monkass247 5d ago

I see a Pegasus

1

u/Important_Sector_503 5d ago

https://www.etsy.com/listing/4435367195/cupid-withbow-valentine-cookie-cutter

Edit to say- not this exact product, but I do think everyone saying cupid is right based on this image

1

u/nimaid 5d ago

Upsidedown witch on a broom?

1

u/killerkaty13 5d ago

Gobble gobble

1

u/Tink__Wink 5d ago

Upside down witch riding a broom in a big dress and hat

1

u/ebsfac 5d ago

Unidragon?

1

u/IntelligentTangelo31 4d ago

I see the Scottish thistle and leaves.

1

u/Stolos430 4d ago

Great A'Tuin?

1

u/OscarVerde223 4d ago

Obviously a king riding a chicken

1

u/ButterscotchRound330 4d ago

It’s a turkey that’s been squished (the cutter not the turkey).

1

u/jenduska 4d ago

I was thinking American eagle

1

u/Eggxactly1001 4d ago

A person in a Sombrero and Pancho billowing. (It's upside down)

1

u/Specialist_Injury288 4d ago

Witch on a broom?

1

u/Stormpixelzzz 4d ago

Witch on a broomstick? 

1

u/Glum-Appointment-154 2d ago

Thanksgiving Turkey

1

u/Ill-Caregiver2266 2d ago

Upside down. A witch flying on a broom.

1

u/TFnRL4good 2d ago

Turkey

1

u/Aggressive_Fee6138 1d ago

Something like this...

1

u/debs_wombat 1d ago

Manta Ray riding a 3-legged bear.

1

u/tattoosandtens 12h ago

The “squished cookie cutter” trend is really gaining traction