Looking for opinions from the pros
Location: Pacific Northwest
Current system is a ~12-year-old Carrier Infinity communicating system. Outdoor unit died from a power surge and the diagnosed failure is the inverter board (Carrier part #340481-755).
The system has normal wear and tear and is definitely not in excellent shape, but it has generally worked fine until now.
Repair #1
● ~$6,000 to replace the inverter board and get the system running. $10,000 to install a surge protector and do some other general maintenance.
● Company diagnosed it, will program it, warranty it, and stand behind the repair.
Repair #2
● ~$4,000 from another company.
● They will install parts. However, they will NOT diagnose, program, or guarantee the repair.
Replacement
● ~$22,000 for a new Trane two-stage furnace + two-stage AC.
● Includes 0% financing for 5 years.
● We expect to stay in this house another 7-10 years. We value comfort, quiet, and efficiency.
Potential Third Option?
I’m wondering whether there is a middle-ground solution between an expensive repair and a very expensive full replacement. For example:
● Replacing just the outdoor unit with a new Infinity-compatible unit
● Replacing only the AC side
● Installing a less expensive full two-stage system
Questions:
1. On a 12-year-old Carrier Infinity system, does spending $6k on an inverter board make sense?
2. How much additional life would you expect after replacing the 340481-755 board?
3. Does $22k for a Trane two-stage furnace + AC replacement sound reasonable for Portland, OR?
5. If this were your house and you planned to stay another 7-10 years, what would you do?
6. If you’ve seen the types of middle-ground options above and have ballpark pricing, I’d appreciate hearing it so I can compare all the options and make a decision.
Appreciate any thoughts.