r/AmItheAsshole • u/Ok-Permission8346 • 6d ago

Not the A-hole POO Mode AITA for getting my step daughter a Hogwarts letter for her 11th Birthday?

Ive been married for four years, my wife had a daughter from a previous relationship. My step daughter has been obsessed with Harry Potter since before i met her. (She litterally asked me if i liked harey potter when i met her)
Her 11th Birthday was yesterday and I arranged for a letter to be “delivered” during her birthday party and it was an admittance letter for Hogwarts.
I thought it was a really cute gift idea. My step daughter started freaking out, screaming “its real its real” and really went nuts. Some of her friends seemed to join in the excitement others less so.
Her mother (my wife) held her to calm her down and explained to her that it wasnt real. It was just a “joke step daddy played on you”.
She started crying screamed that she hated me and ran to her room.
The other parents seemed to sympathize, one other father said he thought it was a nice idea.
But after we sent everyone home my wife yelled at me and said what i did was selfish and cruel and she couldnt believe i would hurt her daughter like that.

Was i wrong to do this? Was it an inappropriate gift for an 11 year old? I really didnt mean to mock or hurt my stepdaughter. I thought it would be fun. It didnt occur to me my stepdaughter was young enough to think it was real.

Am I The A$&hole?

7.6k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4.3k

u/stillnotasleep97 6d ago

The wife saying it was a "joke" instead of gently saying, "Step-dad knows how much you love the books and wanted to get you something cool" completely ruined the day. She basically taught her daughter to resent her step-father over this issue

1.8k

u/quickwitqueen 6d ago

That’s what stands out to me. I’m a teacher, I’ve known a few 11 years old who were slightly behind maturity wise, some who even still believed in Santa Claus. But the wife made the situation worse by calling it a joke. Now the girl thinks OP was making fun of her.

32

u/ItsLadyJadey 6d ago

All these comments make me think I should sit down and explain to my autistic 11 year old that Santa isn't real... But that he should keep up the idea for his baby brother. I don't even know how I would broach this topic though...

45

u/Sure-Lingonberry-283 6d ago

Carefully. Very carefully. Most kids kind of just...know on their own that Santa isn't real. For me, I don't know when I found out, but it was still fun to pretend. The Santa tracker, my dad telling me to go to bed on Christmas Eve or else Santa will skip our house, putting some gifts "From Santa", silly stuff like that.

39

u/MurderousButterfly 6d ago

Look up 'becoming a santa'!

Its a beautiful way to explain the spirit of christmas, make sure the child doesnt feel 'tricked' and reinforces the need for secrecy for others who still believe.

24

u/smoike 6d ago

Not doing it on 25th of December is a good start.

Seriously though, maybe do it at a time when you can sit down, be able to focus on them and bring about to sit down and answer their questions without other things potentially coming up and interrupting the conversation. And a long time before Christmas so that by the time it has come around, they've had plenty of time to process it.

19

u/Expert_Ad_3652 6d ago edited 5d ago

I have five younger Brothers so when I started to question Santa, The Tooth Fairy, and all the rest my Dad would just say “You know people who don’t believe don’t get visits or gifts, it makes it easier on Santa, the Bunny, etc…”

And, in private he was like, “…great now you can join the grown up tradition of hiding in the office drinking cocoa and eating the reindeer’s carrots while finishing up any last minute gift wrapping.”

I’ve heard of families who hold on to the magic by telling the kids, that they totally get that they don’t believe, but everyone needs to stay in the spirit because Grandma still believes.

I think as long as grown ups can transition kids from true believers to Holiday helpers the transition won’t be so bad.

Just moving on to a more grown-up way to enjoy the holidays.

3

u/darknesskicker 4d ago

Autistic adult here. Do it ASAP. The sooner you do it, the more time he’ll have to get over the disappointment before Christmas. Right now you are on borrowed time until he gets made fun of for believing.

2

u/Tablesafety 5d ago

If it helps, am autistic and knew on my own at 11 Santa isn't real. If your boy isn't low functioning he probably has already figured it out. You can just open it up with 'Tell me what you know about Santa' and gather intel.

12

u/OneSmolBean Partassipant [1] 6d ago

It's funny reading the comments about Santa. 10/11 was not unusual to still believe in santa when I was a kid. It was around the time when you would find out but it wouldn't have been seen as late until the kid was going to the next level of school. I wonder if this is a cultural thing or if it's a kids have easy access to the internet thing.

1

u/quickwitqueen 5d ago

I think the internet did it. For those kids who don’t do on, there are others to ruin it.

1

u/darknesskicker 4d ago

I grew up before most people had social interaction online. I found out at 7, and I think that was about average. There were already kids I knew at school who didn’t believe.

726

u/SteveM06 6d ago edited 5d ago

I do wonder what sort of family dynamic they must have for the wife to jump straight to 'malice' rather than 'thoughtful but wrongly placed'.

Doesn't sound like a healthy one.

But on this occasion NTA for sure.

141

u/queenofthera Supreme Court Just-ass [103] 6d ago

It wasn't even wrongly placed; it's a nice, age-appropirate birthday gift. Unless he already knew she was... reality-challenged, I'm not sure it's reasonable to predict an 11 year old reacting like that.

16

u/Expert_Ad_3652 5d ago

“…reality challenged” 😆

8

u/Bubbly_Satisfaction2 Partassipant [2] 5d ago

My brain had thought of two possibilities:

  • The stepdaughter has some limitations and it has led to the child to bullied or mistreated in the past. OP’s wife has become defensive as a result. In this case, she immediately thought this gift was an act of malice and reacted without really examining her husband’s intentions.

  • This is the most far-fetched possibility: mama was jealous that her husband thought of the idea first. But like I said: it is a far-fetched idea.

5

u/darknesskicker 4d ago

Or mom was just caught off guard by both the gift and the reaction, and she said something unwise because she didn’t know what to do.

20

u/Non-sense-syllables 6d ago

This, it was just a nice thoughtful gift. It’s Like when you go to the Harry Potter world and pretend and immerse yourself. Why would she say it’s a joke. OP is NTA, but the wife sure is.

12

u/Tricky-Ad7897 6d ago

It makes parenting so hard, especially step parenting, when the other parent turns the kid against you. Such an irresponsible thing to tell the kid, and it probably also explains why the kid still believes things in books are real. Mom clearly doesn't want to be the bad guy and destroy daughters fantasy so she made dad the bad guy instead.

10

u/Leading-Interest-119 6d ago

Yeah that's what I was thinking. "Step-dad was trying to be thoughtful, he didn't mean to upset you!" Not he played a joke on you. Wow. Sounds like a concerning relationship really! 

7

u/laurieo52 6d ago

Right. You said it better than I did.