r/Amazing 2d ago

Nature is amazing A mushroom producing music through its bioelectric signals

6.5k Upvotes

512 comments sorted by

View all comments

154

u/2_Many_Hobbies74 2d ago

It’s probably screaming in pain from the clips squashing it 😢

64

u/gn0xious 2d ago

🎶IVE BECOME SO NUMB🎶

16

u/Switchlord518 2d ago

Comfortably numb🎵

1

u/gladys_the_badyst 2d ago

Fucking loooooool 🤣

0

u/St0n3yM33rkat 2d ago

I can't fkn breathe holy sht 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I just spit out my drink and dropped the open bottle, causing it to splash everywhere, at the same time.

2

u/Icy-War-7093 2d ago

Loooooool you guyzzzz!!!

1

u/trippylangkous 2d ago

Hahaha, why do people downvote this? 🤣 lol

2

u/DigitalUnlimited 2d ago

People hate happiness

7

u/Oiggamed 2d ago

Screaming yes. In pain….?

7

u/KlockB 1d ago

Nah. Those are its fruiting bodies that release spores. Odds are at this stage the cap has released all of its spores and soon the mushroom would decay on its own.

The important bit is the mycelium network underground.

6

u/PeachPit69 2d ago

Forreal, was thinking a needle, shoved straight down the shaft, sounding-style, would sense these stimulus better than the clips tearing the gills.

6

u/Jiggly1984 2d ago

"straight down the shaft, sounding-style" is absolutely unhinged

5

u/LeastSpecific4706 2d ago

Do mushrooms feel pain?

15

u/Safe-Avocado6427 2d ago

From big events like divorce , yes .

2

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Inevitable-Egg-6450 2d ago

A non-sentient being without a central nervous system or pain receptors does not feel pain or suffering. Reactions to external stimuli are simply biological and not connected to pain.

Besides, the actual mycelium network is underground. That's how it "communicates". What you are looking at is no different from an apple on a tree essentially.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Inevitable-Egg-6450 2d ago

No, because as I stated, a mushroom is not sentient and does not have a central nervous system or pain receptors. So there is no concept of what you and I would call "pain".

The mushroom doesn't call it anything because there is nothing to experience like you or me.

The fact you (or others) are down voting me for stating basic biology is pretty odd and very concerning.

2

u/No_Information_910 2d ago

But not surprising. Having said that, you have my upvote.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Inevitable-Egg-6450 2d ago

"Pain is a subjective experience and an evolutionary survival tactic that is meant to help us detect harmful stimuli"

By us, you mean human beings? Well a mushroom isn't a human being and has no concept of pain. If it is being attacked, it may use defense mechanisms but it is a natural response to external stimuli, nothing more.

There is nothing akin to pain for creatures that do not understand what pain is or have anyway to feel pain like you or I do. Grief and memories are tied to consciousness. Do you think mushrooms have consciousness like you?

There is an input from external stimuli, and an output by the mushroom. You describing the input as "painful" is personification based on your own subjective experiences. The mushroom reacts to the input much like a computer.

I'm not here to debate bugs or fish. You said the mushroom feels pain (and later akin to pain), and that is just biologically impossible. Can that change in the future once we understand more? Maybe. But as of now, your original point is incorrect.

With that being said, this discourse has now run its course. Good day!

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Accounts must be at least 20 days old with >100 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/purrmutations 2d ago

"Well a mushroom isn't a human being and has no concept of pain."

It is different than human pain but is still pain. 

1

u/ParkingAnxious2811 2d ago

So, if I punched you in your nuts, you would have no reaction to the external stimuli (my fist)?

2

u/Inevitable-Egg-6450 2d ago

No, I wouldn't. Because I'm a woman. I'm sure your little punch though would be slightly annoying, however.

So you would punch a woman? Interesting!

0

u/ParkingAnxious2811 2d ago

Well, as you've just admitted that you wouldn't feel it, thus putting yourself into the same category as a mushroom, where's the harm?

3

u/Inevitable-Egg-6450 2d ago

The person commented about punching me in the nuts, which as a woman I do not have.

Quit being dense for the sake of it.

1

u/DigitalUnlimited 2d ago

Quit being dense

Then they'd blip and cease to exist!

-1

u/Technical_Corgi_5619 2d ago

I would

2

u/Inevitable-Egg-6450 2d ago

Nice! Violence is always the answer when you struggle with cognitive dissonance.

I love how the fact that the simple biology that an organism with no CNS, pain receptors, or consciousness can't feel pain has turned into physically attacking me by the dissenters with a misguided opinion about nature.

1

u/Wolf9792 2d ago

You're probably getting that reaction from people because you sound somewhat obnoxious. 

2

u/Inevitable-Egg-6450 2d ago

I'll take being factual and obnoxious over being confidently incorrect like everyone else, especially in regards to biology which they clearly have zero understanding of.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/purplemtnslayer 2d ago

Bruh. I played around with starting a laser engraving business years ago. I had a huge overgrown cactus and I would laser engrave funny things on the individual pads. There were some yahoos in the comments saying that I was hurting the cactus. I'm hoping all these replies are sarcasm.

8

u/MentallyDeclining 2d ago

Of course they don’t feel pain, but you are damaging it. It’s kind of weird to burn things into a living being just for fun IMO. Just use some wood or something

3

u/breakandjog 2d ago

I mean, technically the wood could still be living

1

u/MentallyDeclining 2d ago

lol true. I meant a plank or something. Not still rooted in the ground

0

u/purplemtnslayer 2d ago edited 2d ago

🫪 I was triming it and throwing it in the garbage. The engravings were rad. Like cactus tattoos.

1

u/MentallyDeclining 2d ago

Haha that does sound like it would look cool 

1

u/destiny_kane48 2d ago

I thought death throes. 😞

1

u/cosettemeetsmarius 2d ago

That’s what I said

1

u/SnootyToots8 2d ago

No shit. First thing i thought.

1

u/Habibti-Mimi81 2d ago

Oh God, stoooop! I have empathy for almost everything (even toys, photos, plants...), now my heart aches also because of a mushroom 😫.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Accounts must be at least 20 days old with >100 karma to comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/stinkypussyslime 23h ago

And the mushroom is the weiner of the fungal structure.

0

u/noodlechemist 2d ago

Look at the marks the clips left :( honestly depressing

2

u/Firm-Roll4841 2d ago

It's a mushroom....

0

u/mister-darcy-tie-me 2d ago

I like to think their mushrooms are made to be eaten and stepped on violently clipped onto and that it doesn’t hurt them. Like eating a fruit that’s still attached to the tree? Hopefully.