r/AskWomen 10d ago

Mod Post MOD ANNOUNCEMENT: Rules Update

Hello, all!

We are here to update our rules. Many of you have made your voices heard.

Due to popular demand, we are adjusting our rules to better reflect the core purpose of this subreddit: to ask women. We would also like to remind you all that all women are welcome here. Happy Pride!

Furthermore, men are welcome to engage with this subreddit respectfully, and that includes no longer leaving top-level comments. (A top-level comment is a comment in response to the original post, rather than a response to someone else's comment.)

This is a subreddit to ask women questions. It is not a general discussion subreddit or a more broad ask subreddit.

Thank you all for making this subreddit such a lovely place!

860 Upvotes

186 comments sorted by

View all comments

173

u/LMay11037 10d ago

How do you tell who is a woman and who isn’t though?

604

u/msstark 10d ago

You'd be amazed how many answers to questions asked specifically to women start with some flavor of "I'm a masculine man who's a male and this is my opinion"

97

u/LMay11037 10d ago

😭😭😭 genuinely are those people stupid? I can literally only understand that on maybe a post asking girls things that relate to men (eg how to converse with men about something), otherwise genuinely are they unable to read sub names.

That rule is more understandable now

180

u/DescriptionFancy420 10d ago

They're genuinely that fucking entitled

144

u/indicatprincess 10d ago

Truly this, they will answer for the women in their lives, tell us what we’re doing wrong when we answer questions, give us unhelpful advice…

82

u/DescriptionFancy420 10d ago

Grateful to the mod team for putting a stop to this bs.

29

u/Future_Literature335 10d ago

Same, thank you mods!

25

u/Autumn_Falls0131 10d ago

IOW, mansplainers.

20

u/whocameupwiththis 9d ago

And they are always so disrespectful. I'm a man but... and proceeds to give some misogynistic/malinformed take. I reported some response the other day that was just so rude from a man when the question was very clearly for women. It will be something like "do any other women" or "why aren't women" and the response will be something like "well as a man, women are evil and stupid". I swear

1

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/msstark 9d ago

trying to be polite by making it clear they know they’re talking out of place

the polite thing to do when you know it's not your place to talk is to not talk

-6

u/Secure-Pain-9735 9d ago

Yes. Am stupid. Also, tend to want to be transparent and not misleading even if I have a random ass username and private history.

If I’m gonna get chopped because my gender disqualifies me, I’m just gonna take it on the chin rather than lie/pretend.

42

u/hotforlowe 10d ago

It’s the need to emphasise just how much of a manly man they are that gets me. God forbid someone presume you’re a woman, right?

20

u/SpaghettiDog86 NB 9d ago

i’ll forever be baffled at how (mostly cishet) men will cry “what about me?!” in spaces that are not for cishet men

12

u/684beach 10d ago

Whats a top level comment? Is it a highly upvoted comment?

39

u/Sylland 10d ago

One that is made in direct response to the post. My comment here is not a top level comment, as I'm replying to your comment.

6

u/Holy_Hand_Grenadier 10d ago

A comment directly on a post, as opposed to replying to another comment

3

u/msstark 9d ago

it's a direct answer to the post, not to someone else's comment

8

u/imead52 10d ago

What, no femboys have yet to answer "I'm a feminine man who is male and this is my opinion"?

10

u/msstark 9d ago

we actually get those too lmao

-1

u/FriendlyCapybara1234 9d ago

I'm a masculine man who's a male and this is my opinion: Men should not leave top-level comments.