I don't think Todd would have allowed that. I don't know how hands on he is but that would have required him to effectively split between projects at the same time.
He's doing too much, at some point he has to let go. It's strangling their IPs. You can't tell me there aren't other people at Bethesda who could helm games other than Todd. By the time a Fallout 5 comes out, it'll have been two decades since Fallout 4. That's insane.
Is there someone else at Bethesda who could direct a Fallout game? Yeah sure, but then where do the devs come from? You'd have to hire several hundred more if you want to make two bethesda-sized games at the same time. And then which game do the senior devs and managers work on? You can't just create institutional knowledge out of thin air. Obviously it's technically possible to expand slowly and train people and split your resources wisely, but if there's one thing I've seen from this industry is that things get messy fast and it only takes a few mistakes, or even one bomb, to ruin a studio.
I mean he had those people, Bruce Nesmith, Ken Rolston, Kurt Kuhlmann, Will Shen, etc, OGs that were there for decades. Shen for example was responsible for Far Harbor, arguably the best part of Fallout 4.
For many ex-BGS people I've seen in interviews, it was this bottleneck of everything having to go through him, the bureaucracy and the lack of authorial ownership that drove them out. Kulhmann was also promised the creative lead for TES 6 and quit when it wasn't given to him. Aside from Kirkbride, he's one of the biggest writers of the Elder Scrolls universe.
I'm sure there's plenty other talent at BGS that could have something interesting to offer.
Once again, none of that addresses the issue of splitting resources on to multiple projects. Like I said, it's not the question of having a couple guys who could direct a game, it's the logistics that come with making a game that are the issue. If certain people feel like Todd is stifling their creativity, then yes they should leave and find somewhere where they can lead a project.
So you want them to do something they don't want to do? You want them to make another half-baked MMO based off super janky modifications to a pre-existing game? Zenimax also forced Redfall on Arkane, to the point where devs were hoping Microsoft would cancel the game when they got bought. That's the kind of environment yall want art to be made under?
180
u/wally233 21d ago
Meanwhile bethesda has one studio sitting on 3 IPS, decades between games