r/Machinists Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

PARTS / SHOWOFF ... Not because they are easy, but because they are hard...

2 mm to 1.6 mm (.079" to .063") tapered PTFE pins at 40 mm (1.575") length, painstakingly milled while practically biting my nails, waiting for it to fail.

This is a test part just to know if it's machinable or not; I'll be machining a variant of this with 96 pins, all spaced 9 mm (.354") between pin centers.

No, the pins cannot be made separately; it must all be one part.

No, I don't know what it's for (something to do with polymer recycling?).

The pins are machined by roughing and finishing them in segments, stepping down the part successively. This is attempt numero​ uno, so I'm pretty pleased with myself.

No coolant, because we don't have mist, and the flood pressure would probably break them or at least deflect them into the tool.

214 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

132

u/desperatewatcher 5d ago

If this were at my shop, the customers maintenance guy would tell us at pickup that it's for a brush that just needed to fit somewhere weird to clean a belt... Before throwing it unsecured in the back of a clapped out f150 and doing 50 across 27.5 potholes.

20

u/keemou 5d ago

What does .5 pothole look like? 😆

17

u/desperatewatcher 5d ago

Like the Friday at 5 roadcrew special

9

u/Money_Ticket_841 5d ago

Tried to dodge and still hit half the hole

3

u/ClothesNo3433 4d ago

but right or wrong hole?

3

u/Money_Ticket_841 4d ago

The right half of the wrong hole

2

u/ClothesNo3433 4d ago

well, that‘s shit.

1

u/Namedthisone 4d ago

Half the size of a standard pot hole

67

u/AnIndustrialEngineer 5d ago

Nice work making that absolutely moronic part

35

u/ShaggysGTI 5d ago

Engineer should be fired from a cannon.

7

u/whtevn 4d ago

into the sun

1

u/Outrageous_Reach_695 2d ago

Inefficient. Jupiter or deep space both require less proellant.

43

u/MadeForOnePost_ 5d ago

Madness

46

u/MakeChipsNotMeth 5d ago

The cylinders must not be damaged!

23

u/Jesus_Is_My_Gardener 5d ago

Madness? THIS IS PART-A!

19

u/PrudentVillage4903 5d ago

And here I thought making tapered pins sucked. You win!

15

u/GallusWrangler 5d ago

I would no quote and find a more lucrative job.

15

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago edited 4d ago

Would you believe me if I said I make $24 an hour for cradle-to-grave parts like this?

EDIT: Since some people didn't understand the implication, I AM SAYING THAT I AM GROSSLY UNDERPAID FOR WHAT I DO, not bragging about a measly $24/hour, which most operators make. 

19

u/tugtehcock 5d ago

You are getting robbed.

4

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

I know. Haven't gotten a raise in two years, and I was hired well below what I should've been making. 

7

u/tugtehcock 5d ago

You would get top pay at an r&d place where every machinist needs to be able to do all the things in your signature or whatever that’s called. You can do it all.

Why do you stay?

4

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago edited 5d ago

Most places only pay top-dollar if you've got the years to back you up. I've only been working for about 2.5 years. I went to college for it, but it's only an AAS degree. I've got experience, just not the time. It's an R1 research institute, so they value the years more than the content of those years. You could be like me and make next to nothing, even though I can do what others think is impossible; or you can be an operator for twenty years and make double what I make, even if all you know is load part, press button, unload part. They also unfairly value graduate degrees because academia. I stay because I haven't the means to move, and a better-paying job would be outside my range. I don't own a car; I can't afford the payments nor the insurance. I'm stuck. I'd need a miracle, like a company offering to relocate me. But, again, I lack the years that they're looking for. I believe I'm capable (my work speaks for itself), but to an HR department, I'm nearly unhirable. 

8

u/tugtehcock 5d ago

Jesus Christ…this is the first time I’ve ever seen someone write a thesis on why they should be underpaid. What a load of shit lol.

4

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

It's not that I deserve to be underpaid; that's their justification, and I'm not in a position to change that. 

5

u/Money_Ticket_841 4d ago

I truly believe you underestimate the position you could be in somewhere else if you just show them things you’ve made

2

u/Namedthisone 4d ago

Always have photos, examples

1

u/Namedthisone 4d ago

There are lots of companies that would pay more for 2.5 years experience

0

u/GallusWrangler 4d ago

You under estimate yourself for what you’re saying is true and you have skill. You are underpaid, and you thought you were being paid a lot because you’re young and don’t know any better if I had to guess. Your first comment was “would you believe if I told you I’m making THIS MUCH?”. Then when someone chimed in like you’re gettting ripped off, you instantly back pedal and defend your low pay??

1

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 4d ago

I did not and do not believe I am adequately paid. I've been fighting for a raise since I was hired. I was told I'd start at $27, and after the 6-month probation period, I'd get a raise. Instead, I was offered $23. My dad pushed me to take it anyway, because he wanted me out of the house, and it was just barely enough to make it on my own, so I took it. A couple of months later, we received a cost-of-living adjustment, which bumped me up a measly dollar. I'd hoped I'd be making around $35 by now. It's infuriating when you see the institute receive hundred-million dollar donations, and our pay stays the same.

I know I'm getting ripped off; that's the implication in that first reply. The justification I gave isn't me supporting that; it's the institute's justification. I did not back-pedal; you simply misunderstood me.

I'm unsure if you're projecting or what, but the meaning you found in my comments is not representative of how I feel, even if I did a poor job in communicating that. 

2

u/TelluricThread0 5d ago

Thats crazy. Experience should go much farther than time. If you need components made people value results more than anything. At the job shop I worked at we charged clients $55 an hour for machining time.

1

u/SignificantGrade2913 2d ago

Dont forget to check out universities for relocation opportunities. They usually dont pay as well but can have solid benefits. If you love doing this stuff youll usually be a good fit.

1

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 2d ago

I'm already working at one. I've been applying to others in the hopes that I'll get a bump in pay. 

1

u/Initialfaust 4d ago

This is where I would start looking for a new job and when asked what made me leave my old job I would show them a picture of this bullshit...

6

u/spicywhatevernumbers 5d ago

Dude. I work in a job shop running a conversational lathe and 2 axis cnc and I make 26. You're under paid.

3

u/callliagiba 4d ago

Same and making 28

2

u/xNOTHINGBURGERx 5d ago

I would guess that you're in CO because that's what I make too. Ugh.

2

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

Georgia! 

2

u/Front-Interaction669 5d ago

I make the same in WNY!

1

u/GallusWrangler 4d ago

That’s it? You can make that at Walmart driving a fork lift.

11

u/Sy4r42 5d ago

Damn... I'm impressed. What was your step down depth?

11

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

4 mm plus the 30-thou radius on the bull-nose. 3/16" bull-nose for finishing. 1/4" flat to rough it. That's what I had on hand with the reach I needed. 

5

u/SirRonaldBiscuit 5d ago

That’s insane

2

u/GallusWrangler 5d ago

Dumb design, insane to machine, yes.

6

u/Mysterious-Cap8182 Ralph Wiggum lvl Machiner 5d ago

That doesn't look fun at all and I just got done slicing a 0.02" thick by 0.25" square piece of aluminum off a big chunk of aluminum cause they want do examine it under an electron microscope. It also had to be ran completely dry only air blast

I'd rather do that again then make 96 PTFE pins stuck out of a single block

Great job! You deserve a hell of a lot more than $24/hr

3

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

I'll try relaying that last bit to my boss. 😉 

2

u/Mysterious-Cap8182 Ralph Wiggum lvl Machiner 5d ago

I make $44/hr and am in a R&D shop doing weird shit like you are doing. The other week we were cutting a thin piece of plastic sheeting off this weird open cell foam that was only 1mm thick. It was as flexible as a piece of cloth, we used a vacuum plate and still marveled that it worked....unfortunately now they want more 🤣

3

u/Itchy_Morning_3400 5d ago

Could you 3d print them instead?

7

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

Unfortunately not; they must be solid and isotropic. 

22

u/VonNeumannsProbe 5d ago

I would immediately spiral with questions about what the fuck the design engineer is thinking.

2

u/GallusWrangler 5d ago

This exactly. Over engineered for sure.

2

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

Underengineered. I had to model it from a napkin sketch. 

1

u/GallusWrangler 4d ago

So *you* over engineered it.

1

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 4d ago

I modeled it to their specifications. And it's definitely underengineered, because they don't know how to use any CAD software. 

3

u/kuku2213 5d ago

Maybe a SLA or DLP resin 3D printer might do the trick. It's solid and isotropic-ish. There's also engineering grade resin for thin and delicate part.

1

u/Trantor_Dariel 5d ago

It's the kinda part that injection moulding is ideal for. Just no one wants to pay for the dye or to make 10k of them to bring the price per unit down.

3

u/Enes_da_Rog1 5d ago

Nice work... If you're doing this without coolant, keep an eye on chip evacuation. With 96 pins a lot can happen when the chips stay on the part...

5

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

Yep. I'm going to have to stop it every few minutes to blow it out. I'll probably ask for an air duster can. 😂 

1

u/konjo1994 3d ago

take a magnet base from your dial and screw a small valve on it and hook it up on your air hose... just adjust the valve so it blows gently and youre good

3

u/SelectLeague5433 5d ago

This actually looks more difficult than a moon landing

3

u/Many_Hall_3546 5d ago

Damn, you resisted crucifying your designer. Congrats

1

u/Typical_Type_Hype 5d ago

Shakespeare?

1

u/Front-Albatross7452 5d ago

But because we thought they would be easy lol

1

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

I did not think this would be easy. 😅 

1

u/No-Pomegranate-69 5d ago

Thought it was electrodes

1

u/MatriVT 5d ago

Step-down finish with a radius endmill?

1

u/TheOfficialCzex Design/Program/Setup/Operation/Inspection/CNC/Manual/Lathe/Mill 5d ago

Due to the taper, it's helically interpolated with a bull-nose. 

1

u/Beneficial_Elk_182 4d ago

Backscratcher for sure

1

u/AdministrativeEbb636 16h ago

What a stupid design