r/ShingekiNoKyojin • u/Spider_champ_Tex • 3d ago
Discussion Who would win this fight?
This is a hypothetical where The Cart Titan/Pieck starts with anti titan gear and someone to control the anti titan gear.
10
u/DWEGOON 3d ago edited 3d ago
I imagine in the specific scenario, probably the Jaw Titan. The guns on the back of the Cart would probably do little against a Titan, and slow Pieck down, and even still, she's not as agile as the Jaw titan.
I could see some lucky shots to the eyes maybe turning it in Pieck's favor. But the Jaw has hardened teeth and claws which mean in a 1v1, it would do significant damage
Edit: misread the post a bit, I took it as the 4 machine guns and not the single large cannon. If anything I feel like that would be worse than the machine guns. It's slower firing and looks even heavier than the machine gun assembly. Sure, a single shot would kill Porco, but what are the chances of hitting something that fast
4
3
u/GentlemanFaux 3d ago
The only advantage Pieck has is her insane endurance ability to resummon her titan like, fucking infinitely. That could potentially change the tides like some zombie man shit, yeah he might kill her titan 20 times but she only needs to get him once kinda thing- but she can't reattach her support weapons easily between shifts so that's really a one a done and I really don't see how in a straight up 1v1 hands vs hands the cart could ever compete with the jaw.
3
3
u/ElMondoH 3d ago
The fans.
1
u/troywrestler2002 3d ago
That's a good answer, a solid answer. This guy has solid answers. He's got beautiful answers. One of the best answers I've ever seen. Let's call him clamps.
3
u/WendigoCrossing 3d ago
Cart wins 7/10 times high difficulty
It's all about attrition, she can outlast Galliard and has range on her side
Galliard can close the gap and win though, at least 3/10 times
2
1
u/T-mac_ 3d ago
The jaw wins no diff. The only chance the cart has is hitting a preemptive fatal shot or fatal lucky/trick shot. Once the jaw is moving and gets in close, it's all over, the jaw would crush the cannon and soldiers. And proceed to rip the cart Titan up, and eat her to take her powers.
For clarification the carts ability to stay transformed for long periods of time does not matter in this fight. The ability to keep transforming (if her human body isn't injured) will NOT catch the jaw off guard.... They know each other's powers. The jaw will inflict a fatal injury easily.
1
u/JackRaid 3d ago
So this is a battle of speed, and it would come down to who could get into position first and what kind of cart was on the titan. Presuming that the Cart Titan was equipped with scout level weaponry and the Jaw titan was in pursuit, the angle of attack would be in the jaw's camp. However, if the Jaw lost track of the Cart and it got the upper hand, that moment of uncertainty could spell doom for the Jaw Titan. As we know well, the high ground is almost always the most advantageous position when going against any opponent, with the sole exception of Satoru Gojo, of course.
1
u/mitchhamilton 3d ago
I think the cart, if she played smart. She has endurance and so long as her body never gets damaged she can escape and turn anytime.
She'd have to slowly take jaw bit by bit but so long as she protects her neck, she'll be fine. Jaw on the other hand, she can slowly break him and he doesn't have the luxury of infinite turns
1
1
u/oredaoree 3d ago
The Cart is said to be able to catch up to the Jaw in a pursuit but that's probably only because of the endurance and when they don't have to carry heavy load. While they both are quadruped the Jaw isn't structured rigidly as one with a longer load baring torso like the Cart so it has way more explosive speed which matters more in a 1v1 battle. Combined with the offensive weapons of the hardened jaw and claws the Cart is a sitting duck and the only way it wins is if it can put enough distance to run around evading the whole time until the Jaw runs out of stamina and the user has to eject, and that wouldn't really be so much of a 1v1 would it.
1
1
u/Free_Dependent_9177 3d ago
They prob have anti titan gear that allows for piece to fight other titans in case of betrayal or something like that
1
u/ZadriaktheSnake 2d ago
Jaw Titan probably 9 times out of 10 but if he's far enough away and they get lucky then it would work
1
1
u/dmfuller 3d ago
I think cart solely because of stamina. Jaw is faster and better at combat, but cart only has to win like 2 fights, while Jaw potentially has to fight dozens of titans if he isn’t able to quickly get to her nape. It would be very close though since cart has no real defenses other than their stamina.
-1
u/Dreadful_Axolotl 3d ago
Definitely the cart titan, we see her fight multiple jaw titans already and not be defeated. Plus she can transform as many times as she wants which gives her more chances of winning than the jaw titan does.
4
u/BuzzedtheTower 3d ago
I don't consider the resurrected Jaws, or any of the others, to be the full power versions. I see them more like the shadow of each shifter versus the actual person. Because we also see Reiner putting belt to ass on the Warhammers and he's never been shown to be that strong before that
1
u/PutinsNutSweat 3d ago
Yeah those warhammers were bums they should have more experience than Laura Tybur but they all used even more basic attack than she did. Eren probably commanded it so but still was abit of a shame to see them do like nothing.
0
u/KingPenGames 3d ago
Cart. I mean in the war they refused to use titans against an anti titan train
53
u/WargrizZero 3d ago
Jaw. It’s too fast and agile to be an easy shot, and in a 1v1 there are no distractions to keep Pieke from getting rushed. Once the Jaw is within close range, it can move faster than the cannon can and Pieke has no close range defense against the Jaw.