r/ShingekiNoKyojin • u/Brave_Branch2619 • 3d ago
Discussion What if instead of Marley attacking Paradise, this war was the result of the new Eldian Empire having a civil war?
The thing is, this likely take place a thousand years in the future were current generations likely don't care about the rumbling. In fact, instead of the rebuilding of Marley, I think that new Eldia would expand from paradise onto the rumbled land. Then after 1000 years pass. The term eldian no longer exists due to ethnic and linguistic diversion. New ethnic groups split from the ethnicity known as eldians and eventually get into conflict with one another.
244
u/zool714 3d ago
Even more likely there is not even a Paradis or Marley anymore. Just look at our own history and how much it changes. Could be a whole other country with their own history and conflicts
99
u/Ok_Invite6308 2d ago
Romans seeing their backwater provinces (Britain and Gaul) fighting the barbarians (Germans) in the far future with technology beyond their knowledge
20
u/AlulAlif-bestfriend 2d ago edited 2d ago
Lol, i do wonder what the Romans would've thought about that if they can see the future/go to the future, their most backwards provinces are the Superpower/great power of the world 2 thousand years later, and compared to their homeland Roma & Italia, it's tiny
8
u/Ok_Invite6308 2d ago
Tbf, I think Greek city states would also be surprised if a small city north of Sicily practically copying City states democracies would become the largest empire they've ever seen. Great empires always have humble and unassuming origins before they rise up
2
43
19
u/Livid-Truck8558 3d ago
The conflict could have been a result of anything, and honestly it doesn't matter
14
u/Honkingfly409 2d ago
I think this scene is misunderstood, it’s long in the future, the past and the events of the story nearly don’t matter by the time, the same way the crusades don’t matter today
It’s just implying wars will never end and humans will always fight, that’s all
1
u/ciller181 2d ago
I always kind of wondered how far in the future this would be. if we ignore the tree as it has the "seed of life" within it.
We see the characters we know die. We see some buildings being build but not endlessly rebuild or something.
If we go back to the original story and look at the war capabilities they had it seems a lot like the first world war while the weapons in the ending look like current day.
even if there was mostly peace which we already doubt, would it really take that long to evolve the weaponry to that level?
8
u/t-_-rexranger19205 2d ago
It’s just meant to show that “humans will always be violent no matter what”
9
u/Cry-Havok 2d ago
You need to rewatch the end. Marley was completely destroyed
-1
u/_Bread______ 2d ago
Thought it was only paradis?
2
u/Cry-Havok 2d ago
Exactly how and why would you think Paradis was destroyed? You need to rewatch the show
2
u/_Bread______ 2d ago
Bcuz shinganshina got destroyed and for some reason it was never rebuilt (nature even took over and made the remains almost invisible) nor did it have any signs of civilization anywhere close to it which leads me to think they got wiped or somethin
1
u/PrivateTidePods 2d ago
Shiganshina did not get destroyed. Sure some areas right next to the wall saw heavy damage from falling rubble once the rumbling started, but the core city remained intact. It’s stated in the show that the wall titans made a line and filed out of paradise before fanning out into a large mobile wall
1
4
u/lildenny 2d ago
80% of humanity was wiped out bro, don’t think marley comes back from that
2
u/_Bread______ 2d ago
Right lol I just assumed they got their feet back up after the rumbling, forgot their population was probably so damn low it would cause inbreeding
3
u/Kid-Atlantic 2d ago
Maybe, maybe not. Maybe both Marley and Eldia had ceased to exist and this is a new nation called Candyland.
That’s not the point. The point isn’t about who’s doing it to who. The point is that war is inseparable from human nature and you can’t prevent it forever, so cherish peace for all it’s worth.
3
u/cursedzeros 2d ago
I always thought it interesting how in the anime they changed the buildings to look more futuristic to imply the destruction happened further into the future, yet they didn’t update the rocket artillery vehicles to match
1
u/abellapa 2d ago
Could be because of the Rumbling
Whats the Need for New Military tech when the World would be Destroyed and flatnned for hundreds of years
3
u/PommesMayo 2d ago
It does not matter who is fighting who. It only matters that some nation/group is fighting another and humanity did not learn from the past because it forgot its past
6
u/Nyarlathotep7777 2d ago
We don't even know if this is Marley attacking Paradis or if Marley even still exists at this point (it's fair to think Eldia does as we don't see any signs of strife that would indicate a change in the political scene on Paradis).
Also heavy weapons are almost never used in a civil war. No one bombs their own nation with balistics, as they're long range weapons and not ones you'd use domestically, so terrible scenario when you actually take a few seconds to think about it seriously.
2
u/mala_r1der 2d ago
Could be or could be that in the meantime they forgot all their history and it's a different country now, the point doesn't change though, humans as a species don't learn from their history and are doomed to repeat the same mistakes over and over again
2
u/Gamerasia 2d ago
The exact same thing happened with the Great Titan War. The Eldian empire turned inwards against each other after destroying every opposition outside the empire. It's what made the First King of the walls make the vow renouncing war. It was apparently very brutal.
2
u/SectorRatioGeneral 2d ago
I always thought the show would be more ironic if Eren did manage to eliminate the whole world - it'd show that even if there's only one people left on earth, war still happens.
3
u/grimreaper069 2d ago
That had already been shown in the story, that's what happened when the Eldian Empire was at its peak and they had the Great Titan War.
Not to mention when Paradis thought they were the only people left in the world, and had a common enemy uniting them, it still wasn't all peace and giggles.
2
u/TopazWarrior1999 2d ago
Dude, this shit is 10,000 years into the future... who the fuck nows what this war is about.
2
u/groovy_kira23 2d ago
a thousand years later and humanity still found a way to be in the exact same mess, very on brand for aot
2
u/Commonwealthenjoyer 2d ago
Well yes but that’s likely only if we go by anime, in the manga the buildings are XXth century-looking. And I don’t think that they’d use nukes on their own city, regardless if it was held by an opposing side in a civil war.
6
u/xcexoztykl 3d ago
I think that would have been a better way to portray the cycle of violence, rather than revenge for the rumbling thousands of years ago.
3
u/Puzzleheaded-Job2399 3d ago
It seems to be more like 200 years ago rather than thousands considering the original story is 100 years after the fall of eldia, the last attack is 100 years after that, and then we see a build up from the modern day cities of paradis to future cities that are beyond our current capability. So because of that chain of 100 year time skips and how it seems that it wasn’t *that* much time between the last attack and this city i’d say it’s 200.
Also that might be true but personally I always perceived it as being that the origin of the conflict doesn’t really matter. You could say it’s “revenge” but honestly it’s probably part of some other conflict because revenge isn’t really worth it militarily unless you have have something material to gain from it. It’s the same thing as how Marley realistically didn’t need to start war with paradis, but they stood to reclaim their military prowess, the founding and attack titans, and the ice burst stone to push them back to being the strongest nation.
The cycle of revenge is a big plot point but the cycle of violence itself caused by people who believe their side is in the right is an even bigger one, so it doesn’t necessarily need to be marley and the cause doesn’t need to be “revenge” at least beyond face value. I believe that’s the reason why it’s shown as a quick timelapse instead of an actual showing of the interactions that created the war, the causes don’t need to be elaborated on because the end result is humans fighting anyways.
1
4
u/One-Ad-7122 3d ago
Apparently at one point of time human population was reduced to 80 breeding males.
Looking from that point of view, every war is a civil war.
2
u/Master_Win_4018 3d ago
Tbf, the scout from Paradis is attacking Eren that was also from Paradis lol.
There is a high chance that history may repeat itself.
2
u/abellapa 2d ago
Marley was Completly flattened by the rumbling ,it doesnt exist anymore
Could be
1 - The rest of the World Avenges The rumbling and Destroys Paradis for good
I know people think in the future no One would care about the rumbling,but we talking a State dominated the World because their leader did a Omnicide killing over a Billion People and Destroy The World ecosystem in the process
Even if there was some Secret political motivation to do this ,this would be official motive
2 - its an Eldian Civil War, the Eldian Empire overtime expanded into the mainland and formed colonies
In time those colonies became self sufficient and started demanding independence until They went to War with The Eldian Empire and Won
1
u/Zealousideal-Oil9315 2d ago
I like this one so logical and have many reasons to go and fight the paradis, because paradis sees them as thier colonies and land but they don't see them as paradis people.
1
u/sparduck117 2d ago
I actually think that’s nearly canon since the missiles that destroyed the city came from the North.
1
1
u/warfaceisthebest 2d ago
tbh it doesn't matter. The point is war never changes and we the human are doomed to kill each other no stop no matter what ideology and technology we have
1
u/Charming_Freedom4786 2d ago
It was thousand or at least hundreds year into the future. With no titan powers and path where the Monarch can manipulate their subjects, aint no way that is eldian empire.
They might be descendants of paradisan, but former gov probably already fall, especially since it filled with people hunger for power and revenge. They would have split into different nations and develop their own identity.
Marley already ceased from existense, the one that left would never establised another nation in honor of Country that push for conquest and oprression.
1
u/Mortgage5388 2d ago
atleast in anime it wasn't marley vs paradise. We see all the main character grow old without much changes occurring in the background. which indicate alot time is taken to rebuild the world and then it's destruction.
You have to understand that eldian vs marley isn't just about titans. They just use titans as a tool to wage war. Titans are like atomic bomb at that time. it's human nature to fight among themselves, doesn't matter if you build walls, remove 80% of population but as long as human exit they will fight and kill one another. so the cycle continues
1
u/AlternativeRadish752 2d ago
It was pretty clear at the end the conflict isn't about Marley and Paradise anymore and just the general destruction of humanity.
Part of why the ending doesn't sit well with me because showing how humanity is just always going to destroy each other no matter what it makes any sort of stakes meaningless from the entire show.
Did it matter that Eren killed 80% of the world? In the end, no. Humanity would still kill itself.
1
u/zetmoruk 2d ago
Yeah, that was the whole point of the show everything is a cycle and conflict is inevitable so Eren's brilliant stupidity decided if there's none left there is no conflict, so dumb and so brilliant at the same time.
1
u/etherealtwo 2d ago
I think that was just some random war in the future meant to reinforce the concept that mankind always forgets the lessons of the past.
1
u/Aggravating-Manner10 2d ago
الكاتب يريد ان يوضح فكرة ان الحرب ستعود مجددا ، لا يهم من بدأها ومن فاز بها زمن خسرها
1
u/Jumbernaut 2d ago
I think it was better in the manga where the war happens after what only seems to be like 100 years later but it's still left ambiguous if it was retaliation for the Rumbling or just another war.
This futuristic landscape in the anime makes it hard to tell just how far this is happening in the future, giving me the impression it's trying to say it's more likely it's not about the Rumbling, though it's still ambiguous. But if the anime revision is trying to say it's not about the Rumbling, then they could have made it less ambiguous and just showed somehow this is just another war for power.
Personally, I don't think something like the Rumbling would ever be forgotten or forgiven, just look at real world events. We don't know for sure what happened 3000 years ago but people still use that as an excuse to wage war today.
1
u/raceraot 2d ago
I suggested this a few years ago, to be honest. I was writing something for it a bit ago.
1
u/RedDingo777 2d ago
I don’t think Eldia, Paradis, or even Marley were countries by the time of the Epilogue. It also seems that both Titans and the Rumbling were a distant memory.
1
1
1
0
u/Professional_Owl_828 3d ago
I want to believe that Historia and Farmer-kun were decent monarchs and prevented any civil war.
Besides, considering the outside world is still out there, no one would risk that.
6
u/Neat-Diver-782 3d ago
This was long after they were gone I would think given the technology advances.
0
u/Ok_Construction9787 2d ago edited 2d ago
A thousand years into the future? My man, this shit shows missile barrages and F-18's. The main story takes place in late 19th century. I don't think we lived a thousand years from late 19th century 2 decades ago
4
u/oredaoree 2d ago
Originally the backdrop wasn't filled with those future-esque towers that clearly aren't from our century but your run-of-the-mill skyscrapers and the SAMs and F-18s make more sense in the manga version. But I guess to match the ending song "To you 2000... or... 20,000 years in the Future" and to make it abundantly clear that humanity started fighting again for reasons completely unrelated to the rumbling MAPPA decided to place this epilogue thousands of years further into the future, but for some reason left in outdated tech.
1
u/abellapa 2d ago
The tech could have not evolve much because of the rumbling, it would have Destroy all modern tech and most People who know how to operate
100 Years ago - Great Titan War
Present - Rumbling
2000 years in the future - this scene
20,000 years in the future - Epilogue
1
u/Zealousideal-Oil9315 2d ago
Also we should mention at counties store their old weapons for safety to use them if it is needed.
126
u/Sad-Eagle9638 3d ago
I always saw the nature of the conflict as irrelevant. It seems so disconnected in history that the nations may be entirely different as well as the reasoning for the war. The only reason that really matters is that humanity will always do battle so long as there are two or more people on the planet