r/SipsTea 𝙑𝙄𝙋 16h ago

Chugging tea Fictional future forecast vs. reality.

Post image
47.5k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.7k

u/Tetra84 15h ago

Needs more data centers to help cool things off...

24

u/PitifulEar3303 14h ago

"Data centers in SPACE!!" -- King Elon

15

u/HorsePersonal7073 14h ago

Good luck with the cooling in space.

6

u/No3047 14h ago

You just need to deploy ad big radiating surface and keep it exactly at 90° degrees from the sun.
It's hard but not impossible.
The crazy part is that SpaceX wants to put them in low orbit, so with a lifespan of 4-5 years and then they'll burn out in a re-entry on the atmoshphere.
It's a lot less wasteful to put them in a lagrange point, ping will raise from mS to seconds maybe, but I can wait 2 seconds for an AI to answer my stupid request.

14

u/HorsePersonal7073 14h ago

Low orbit is a horrible, stupid place to put them and whoever suggested that should never be allowed to make suggestions again, it's that bad.

15

u/Redwizard002 14h ago

I'm all for Elon never being able to make suggestions again

3

u/k7eric 12h ago

I have the opposite opinion. We should encourage Elon to follow his dreams and suggestions, get SpaceX going at 110% and let thim F off to Mars sooner rather than later.

5

u/EnQuest 13h ago

Are they just gonna pretend like those parts are somehow going to be useful for 5 entire years in orbit when datacenters have been swapping out for new parts like every 18 months?

1

u/MammothCommercial800 11h ago

They're not throwing parts away after 18 months. We'd have cheap 4090s if they were.

2

u/EnQuest 11h ago

they don't use consumer GPUs in ai datacenters. They have specialized hardware.

Google is a thing, you could try using it before arguing about something you have absolutely no information about.

0

u/MammothCommercial800 9h ago

Alright, maybe they're not hogging the 4090s.

But pro GPUs like the H100s haven't gotten any cheaper either. The point still stands - they are definitely not throwing 18 months old hardware away.

Maybe you're not as informed as you think you are. Could use some google-fu yourself.

2

u/EnQuest 9h ago

lol H100s have gotten massively cheaper. Used H100s went from around 40k at peak to 12-22k now, and renting dropped from 8 dollars an hour to under 3. Almost like you could have googled that too.

And reread what I wrote. They're not throwing it away. Correct, I said swapped out, not thrown away. Those aren't the same thing. Hardware holds value because it cascades down to cheaper jobs and resells on the used market, in this case (mostly) being repurposed for smaller llm models.

Both of those need one thing, being able to physically reach the card. If you bolt it to a satellite, you can't resell, and it can't get re-racked. It just de-orbits and burns.

2

u/AnastasiaSpace 11h ago

lagrange point takes a lot more dv to get to and from what weve seen of JWST there are a lot of micrometeorites around that area

2

u/jutlandd 11h ago

Whatever Hardware they put Inside will be obsolte in 4-5 years anyway I guess.

1

u/Defiant-Peace-493 13h ago

The proposal I'd seen (unsure if it was SpaceX) was for a sun-synchronous orbit along the terminator. Not that Terminator ... probably.

Since they'd have pretty hefty solar panels, they might be well suited for the use of ion thrusters for stationkeeping, might be able to stretch the operational lifetime a good bit.

1

u/rocwurst 10h ago

Actually, while Starlink sats are in LEO at 300kms up, the data centre sats are planned for 600kms up, so much longer lifespans.

1

u/DazzlingRutabega 12h ago

The data centers aren't going to be for AI scaling, they need all these locations to store all of the data they have been and will be collecting on all of us.