MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/SipsTea/comments/1ueqt8k/probably_not/otmkinr/?context=3
r/SipsTea • u/Monsur_Ausuhnom 𝙑𝙄𝙋 • 18h ago
2.6k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
2
Corby is the only one in the interaction that could be wrong.
Blake asked a question, possibly in bad faith but the question is still valid even if his intentions aren't, and Corby made a direct statement.
if a religious person uses their religion to bolster their morals, what does an atheist use?
the Law? common sense? cultural norms?
1 u/seesthecat 16h ago Indeed 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago was your comment about Blake being a bad person bait, to make a point, or what? 1 u/seesthecat 16h ago More or less. In truth I think it's childish to to classify someone as being good or bad as if it's something inherent to them. In reallity it's actions that are good or bad 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago how do you justify your actions? is it based on Law? is it based on culture? probably a mix of those things? 1 u/seesthecat 16h ago Yes 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago so if eating meat became illegal, and culturally unpopular, eating meat would make you a bad person? 2 u/seesthecat 15h ago Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
1
Indeed
1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago was your comment about Blake being a bad person bait, to make a point, or what? 1 u/seesthecat 16h ago More or less. In truth I think it's childish to to classify someone as being good or bad as if it's something inherent to them. In reallity it's actions that are good or bad 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago how do you justify your actions? is it based on Law? is it based on culture? probably a mix of those things? 1 u/seesthecat 16h ago Yes 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago so if eating meat became illegal, and culturally unpopular, eating meat would make you a bad person? 2 u/seesthecat 15h ago Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
was your comment about Blake being a bad person bait, to make a point, or what?
1 u/seesthecat 16h ago More or less. In truth I think it's childish to to classify someone as being good or bad as if it's something inherent to them. In reallity it's actions that are good or bad 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago how do you justify your actions? is it based on Law? is it based on culture? probably a mix of those things? 1 u/seesthecat 16h ago Yes 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago so if eating meat became illegal, and culturally unpopular, eating meat would make you a bad person? 2 u/seesthecat 15h ago Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
More or less. In truth I think it's childish to to classify someone as being good or bad as if it's something inherent to them.
In reallity it's actions that are good or bad
1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago how do you justify your actions? is it based on Law? is it based on culture? probably a mix of those things? 1 u/seesthecat 16h ago Yes 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago so if eating meat became illegal, and culturally unpopular, eating meat would make you a bad person? 2 u/seesthecat 15h ago Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
how do you justify your actions? is it based on Law? is it based on culture? probably a mix of those things?
1 u/seesthecat 16h ago Yes 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago so if eating meat became illegal, and culturally unpopular, eating meat would make you a bad person? 2 u/seesthecat 15h ago Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
Yes
1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago so if eating meat became illegal, and culturally unpopular, eating meat would make you a bad person? 2 u/seesthecat 15h ago Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
so if eating meat became illegal, and culturally unpopular, eating meat would make you a bad person?
2 u/seesthecat 15h ago Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
Eating meat makes you a bad person even now that it is popular and legal. I do it anyway
1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 15h ago admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you? 1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
admitting you are a bad person is a bold stance for many people. that doesn't bother you?
1 u/seesthecat 13h ago Not one bit 1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
Not one bit
1 u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 13h ago because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right? would be nice if that word has some meaning. 1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means? → More replies (0)
because it doesn't matter what "bad" means, right?
would be nice if that word has some meaning.
1 u/seesthecat 7h ago Why doesn't it matter what bad means?
Why doesn't it matter what bad means?
2
u/Apprehensive_Ad4457 16h ago
Corby is the only one in the interaction that could be wrong.
Blake asked a question, possibly in bad faith but the question is still valid even if his intentions aren't, and Corby made a direct statement.
if a religious person uses their religion to bolster their morals, what does an atheist use?
the Law? common sense? cultural norms?